Disturbing new insights have been offered into why a wealthy Houston mother lost custody of her little girl hours before she shot her dead in a murder suicide.
asserted
she → offer → suicide
Cibelle Savella, 35, was not believed to pose any physical safety risk to her four-year-old daughter Vivian, said Charlotte Rainwater, a lawyer who acted on behalf of Vivan's father Aaron Savella.
asserted
who → believe → father
Rainwater, who fought a civil case taken against Aaron by Cibelle, told the Daily Mail that there were fears for Vivian's emotional wellbeing if she remained in her mother's custody.
asserted
she → fight → custody
Asked if there were any fears or indicators that Cibelle, of Houston in Texas, would erupt in violence, Rainwater said: 'Absolutely not.
asserted
Rainwater → ask → violence
The custody change occurred based on the judge's ruling that afternoon, and it was really more based in like an emotional safety for the child.
asserted
it → occur → child
'(That) was more of the basis for that ruling than anything, and it really had nothing to do with the physical safety of the child.
asserted
it → have → child
Cibelle Savella (left) murdered her daughter Vivian (right) then shot herself in the head on Tuesday, hours after being told her ex-husband Aaron Savella would have full custody of their daughter.
asserted
Savella → murder → daughter
Cibelle succumbed to her head wounds two days later
Cibelle and Aaron pictured on their wedding day in 2020.
asserted
Cibelle → succumb → 2020
Aaron's lawyer Charlotte Rainwater said a custody judge who ruled in favor of Aaron feared for Vivian's 'emotional safety' at the hands of Cibelle
'
asserted
who → say → Cibelle
I don't think anyone involved, the judge, the parties, the lawyers.
asserted
I → think → anyone
I don't think anyone anticipated that this child was in any way, shape, or form potentially in physical danger.
asserted
child → think → danger
Just a few hours after Tuesday's ruling by Harris County Judge Audrie Lawton-Evans, Cibelle shot Vivian dead at her $840,000 townhouse in a gated community.
asserted
Cibelle → shoot → community
Cibelle shared the property with her second husband, Chick-Fil-A franchisee Greg Kubala.
asserted
Cibelle → share → husband
Cibelle also shot herself in the head and initially survived, but succumbed to her wounds in hospital on Thursday afternoon before she could be charged with any crime.
uncertain
she → shoot → crime
Rainwater did not share further details on how Cibelle allegedly put Vivian's 'emotional safety' at risk.
uncertain
Cibelle → share → risk
A court docket previously obtained by the Daily Mail offered clues.
asserted
docket → obtain → clues
Cibelle, who was Brazilian, was banned from speaking Portuguese in front of her daughter unless a Portuguese-speaking third party from the Guardians of Hope service was also present.
asserted
party → ban → service
Vivian killed her daughter and fatally-injured herself at an $840,000 townhouse she shared with second husband Greg Kubala in Houston.
asserted
she → kill → Houston
Police are pictured at the scene after the murder suicide
Cibelle is pictured with second husband Greg in an undated photo.
asserted
Cibelle → picture → photo
Her divorce from Aaron Savella was finalized in 2024 and it is unclear when she remarried
Tuesday's ruling said Cibelle was not allowed to be around Vivian at all unless a member of Guardians of Hope staff was present.
uncertain
member → finalize → staff
The Houston-based organization provides safe child visitation and exchange services for families caught up in high-conflict custody battles.
asserted
organization → base → battles
Previous court rulings banned either Cibelle or Aaron from disparaging the other in front of Vivian.
asserted
rulings → ban → Vivian
They were also barred from letting the youngster hear anyone in their company criticize the other parent.
asserted
anyone → bar → parent
Vivian was to live with Aaron, a private equity lawyer, after Tuesday's ruling and was due to be handed over to her dad on the evening of her murder.
asserted
Vivian → live → murder
Cibelle was ordered to pay child support to Aaron and contribute 50 percent of the cost of any medical expenses.
asserted
Cibelle → order → expenses
Vivian Savella is pictured in a photo shared by her devastated father Aaron in the wake of her murder
Vivian and her father Aaron.
asserted
Savella → picture → Vivian
Aaron's lawyer Charlotte Rainwater told the Daily Mail it was 'unfathomable' that Cibelle would inflict such violence on the couple's daughter
She was banned from attending Vivian's school activities, including school lunches, performances and field trips.
Cibelle was also banned from consenting on Vivian's behalf to any medical, dental or surgical treatment her daughter might require during an emergency.
Rainwater told the Daily Mail that there was no history of Cibelle physically abusing Vivian prior to Tuesday's murder-suicide.
She said she was unsure why Cibelle's marriage to Aaron had ended.
The couple wed in 2020, split in 2022 and had their divorce finalized by 2024, but legal battles over custody of Vivian were continuing to simmer at the time of the murder-suicide.
uncertain
battles → tell → suicide
Rainwater said the divorce was resolved to the satisfaction of Cibelle and Aaron.
asserted
divorce → say → Cibelle
She said Cibelle's decision to murder her child and kill herself was 'unfathomable' and that neither she, nor Aaron, nor the 'sweet' judge that oversaw the case had any inkling of what would unfold.
asserted
what → say → inkling
The little girl was 'loved without limit' by her dad, a statement released by his attorneys said
Asked how Aaron was doing, she said his mother happened to be in Houston at the time of the murder-suicide and was now comforting her son.
Rainwater added: 'I think that they're doing you know as as good as you can under the circumstances.'
asserted
you → love → circumstances
A statement issued on behalf of Aaron after Vivian's murder said he was 'devastated' and added: 'Aaron did everything the law asks of a parent who is trying to protect his child.
asserted
who → issue → child
He trusted the courts.
asserted
He → trust → courts
He followed every order.
asserted
He → follow → order
He waited for the process to work,' his lawyers said.
asserted
lawyers → wait → ?
'On Tuesday, a judge placed Vivian in his primary care, and she was supposed to come home to him that evening.
asserted
she → place → him
She never did.
asserted
She → do → ?
The statement went on to say how Vivian was 'loved without limit by her father, Aaron, and by everyone whose life she touched.'
asserted
she → go → life
The Aporia
