The easy thing for the people who live on the banks of the River Dart in Devon might have been to grumble and groan about the sewage spills that blight their beloved waterway.
uncertain
that → live → waterway
Instead, citizen environmentalists in the area have created a unique online platform that flags up spills in real time, highlights spots that are repeatedly polluted, and sets out where improvement work is planned – and where it isn’t.
asserted
it → create → spots
Friends of the Dart (FOD), an independent, not-for-profit organisation, says its River Hub is the first platform to pull together, overflow by overflow, such a sweep of granular detail about how one British river is being polluted.
asserted
river → say → detail
It argues it should be up to water companies or the Environment Agency to provide this sort of information in a user-friendly way – but claims they don’t – so it has done the digging and provided what it believes is a vital service.
Rob Worthington, one of the designers of the platform, said there was a lot of justified anger about sewage.
uncertain
Worthington → argue → sewage
“We built River Hub to help channel that constructively: to show where the problems are and why, so communities can help decide what gets fixed first.”
asserted
what → build → that
The launch comes in the week that South West Water (SWW) was fined almost £800m for sewage spills, including in Cornwall’s River Camel, which like the Dart rises on the moors and plunges down to cherished tourist hotspots.
asserted
which → come → hotspots
It also coincides with the prime minister, Andy Burnham, telling the Labour conference that water was a symbol of what had gone wrong with Britain and promising to reverse Margaret Thatcher’s “ideological ban” on the public ownership of water companies.
asserted
what → coincide → companies
Worthington told the Guardian about River Hub while sitting on a bench at Steamer Quay on the Dart in the market town of Totnes.
asserted
Worthington → tell → Totnes
This is a designated bathing water spot – but Worthington says he would not swim there, knowing about what goes on a little farther upstream.
asserted
what → designate → ?
The hub has a page that people can check to find out where spills are happening right now and where they stopped in the last 12 hours.
asserted
they → have → hours
Worthington acknowledged other independent sewage maps, such as Top of the Poops, also do this job.
asserted
maps → acknowledge → job
“But River Hub takes this a lot further,” he said.
asserted
he → take → this
A section called Why it keeps happening? probes issues such as whether sewage treatment works have the capacity to deal with the sewage produced by the size of the population it serves.
asserted
it → call → population
The hub concludes that not all do.
asserted
all → conclude → ?
In Who is fixing it?, the hub spells out works that are taking place or planned, with the dates they are due to be completed, and also draws attention to problem spots where there is no planned remedial work.
asserted
they → fix → spots
A lengthy How we know? section sets out the hub’s methodology – for example, where the rainfall data it uses to classify each dry spill comes from.
asserted
it → know → spill
Much of the data used, such as SWW spill information and permits, is in the public domain but some of it can be difficult to spot, and FOD had to extract some through freedom of information requests.
asserted
FOD → use → requests
Worthington has worked on the hub alongside his day job as a business analyst and accepted that the picture the platform provided was incomplete and there could be inaccuracies.
uncertain
platform → work → analyst
He and the rest of the team are happy to be corrected when they have got something wrong.
asserted
something → correct → team
They are offering the model for free to any groups who want to do the same thing on their local river.
asserted
who → offer → river
Organisations FOD has links with have already shown an interest.
asserted
FOD → have → interest
People who live in and around Totnes tell tales of falling ill after swimming in the Dart and its tributaries.
asserted
who → live → Dart
Emma Roberts, an interfaith minister and theatre director, said she ended up in hospital with an E coli infection after a dip.
asserted
she → say → dip
“It’s shocking really.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
The river is alive and we should all be protecting it, not putting poo into it.”
asserted
we → protect → it
She is not a member of FOD but thinks the hub will help.
asserted
hub → think → FOD
“The more information people have, the more pressure that we can put on.”
asserted
we → have → that
A quick check of the hub reveals that place where she got ill was close to a treatment work that FOD believes does not have sufficient capacity.
asserted
FOD → reveal → capacity
Olivia Doherty, who works in children’s rights and participation, said her son Seamus, 17, recently suffered stomach problems after swimming in the Dart.
asserted
Seamus → work → Dart
She said the United Nations had made it clear that young people had a right to safe spaces.
asserted
people → say → spaces
“For me that includes our rivers.
asserted
that → include → rivers
Getting into the river is a big thing for children here.
asserted
Getting → get → children
It’s so wrong if they miss out because it’s too dirty.”
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Ben Brierley, who runs kayak tours and courses on the Dart, said the hub could help him work out where and when it was safe for his clients to be submerged in the river.
uncertain
clients → run → river
Brierley expressed frustration that water companies have been given a deadline of 2035 by the UK government to reduce sewage flowing into bathing water and areas of ecological importance, and 2050 for other places.
asserted
companies → express → places
“It’s bonkers that we’ll be putting sewage into our rivers until 2050,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → 2050
SWW said it welcomed people taking an interest in rivers’ health.
asserted
it → say → health
A spokesperson said its WaterFit Live site provided customers with a wide range of information, including near real-time storm overflow data, bathing water information and details about investment programmes.
asserted
site → say → programmes
The spokesperson said: “We are committed to making information accessible and continue to develop the platform to help customers better understand our work to improve river health.”
asserted
customers → say → health
An Environment Agency spokesperson said it was taking action to tackle pollution on the Dart and welcomed the initiative from local communities to use data to raise standards.
asserted
it → say → standards
…and 9 more, not listed.
The Aporia
