A hospital consultant and his partner have launched a legal battle against the former owners of their £625,000 home after being told not to shower or even flush the loo whenever it rains because of the risk of raw sewage backing up into the house and garden.
asserted
it → launch → house
Radiologist Brett Ibbeson and Karen Man Yan Chan claim they were tricked into buying the detached house in Suffolk when the previous owners 'fraudulently' claimed the property had never flooded.
uncertain
property → claim → Suffolk
Dr Ibbeson and Ms Chan later discovered a catalogue of complaints filed against Anglian Water by previous owners William and Suzanne Temple, including one reporting 'residual 3Ps (pee, poo and paper)' in the front garden caused by an overflowing sewer.
asserted
Ibbeson → discover → sewer
Now they want the full purchase price refunded, along with expenses including hotel and Airbnb accommodation when they had to move out because of the ongoing sewage problem.
asserted
they → want → problem
In a High Court claim, Dr Ibbeson and Ms Chan say they bought the four-bed, three-bathroom house in the rural village of Brockley near Bury St Edmunds in March 2025 after being assured in a property information form that it had never flooded.
uncertain
it → say → form
During legal inquiries into the property, the vendors were allegedly asked again about problems with the sewer.
uncertain
vendors → ask → sewer
The four-bedroom, three-bathroom house in the rural village of Brockley near Bury St Edmunds
There is a pumping station around 20 yards from the home
Dr Ibbeson and Ms Chan claim they later discovered a catalogue of complaints filed against Anglian Water, who run the pumping station (pictured) by the previous owners
Previous owner William Temple, left, and Brett Ibbeson, who bought the house last year
They allegedly said they had occasionally experienced problems with the downstairs lavatory not flushing properly, but that Anglian Water had been quick to carry out repairs to the pumping station when contacted.
But months after moving in, the new owners say they discovered that a sewage pumping station on neighbouring land could become overwhelmed during periods of wet weather.
uncertain
station → be → weather
Anglian Water then advised them to severely restrict their water use at the property when it was raining, they claim.
uncertain
they → advise → property
That advice included being told over the phone not to shower or flush the loo.
asserted
advice → include → loo
The couple say that using water at the property increases the likelihood of sewage escaping from manholes on the site and backing up into the house.
asserted
sewage → say → house
Then, in November 2025, the couple discovered what they say was a long history of problems involving the sewer and pumping station.
asserted
they → discover → station
They were given a copy of 16 complaints made by Mr and Mrs Temple, who had owned the house since 2014.
asserted
who → give → 2014
They were given a copy of 16 complaints allegedly made by Mr and Mrs Temple, who had owned the house since 2014.
uncertain
who → give → 2014
The former owners were said to have told Anglian Water that, from November onwards for several months, their downstairs loo and upstairs shower did not work and that there was 'residual 3Ps (pee, poo and paper) in the front garden'.
asserted
loo → say → garden
There were also records showing Anglian Water attending the property numerous times.
asserted
Water → be → property
Dr Ibbeson and Ms Chan accuse the Temples of making 'fraudulent false representations', knowing they were false, or being reckless whether they were true or false.
asserted
they → accuse → representations
The couple claim the Temples had even threatened to report Anglian Water to environmental health in March 2023 and had sought compensation.
uncertain
Temples → claim → compensation
They allegedly continued complaining until they put the house on the market, and are also said to have requested emergency drainage of the pumping station five times.
uncertain
they → continue → station
Dr Ibbeson, a consultant radiologist for West Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust, and Ms Chan say they would never have bought the property if they had known the truth.
asserted
they → say → truth
They say they have no desire to live in the house because of the sewer problems and will sell it unless the court orders rescission [cancellation] of the contract.
asserted
court → say → contract
Their expenses relating to the property have so far reached just over £54,000, they say.
asserted
they → relate → 54,000
Dr Ibbeson and Ms Chan accuse the Temples of making 'fraudulent false representations' about the house, knowing they were false, or being reckless whether they were true or false
These include the cost of an investigation by a drainage engineer and hotel and Airbnb bills of £2,112.86.
asserted
These → accuse → 2,112.86
They are also seeking future conveyancing costs, a mortgage early redemption fee of £18,085.95, future hotel and Airbnb expenses, and future borrowing and interest costs.
asserted
They → seek → 18,085.95
The couple are also seeking compensation for distress, inconvenience and the loss of use and enjoyment of the property, based on its notional rental value.
asserted
couple → seek → value
After Mr and Mrs Temple were sent a letter of claim in February, they admitted 'there was a small number of occasions where there was a small surcharge of sewage in the garden' but have continued to deny liability.
uncertain
they → send → liability
Dr Ibbeson and Ms Chan say they have therefore been left with no choice but to take legal action.
asserted
they → say → action
No defence to the claim, issued last month, has so far been lodged.
uncertain
defence → issue → claim
Dr Ibbeson and the Temples were contacted for comment.
asserted
Ibbeson → contact → comment
The Aporia
