In late 2024, FBI investigators had enough evidence to launch a sweeping bribery probe that could ensnare top lawmakers, including Sen. Susan Collins.
uncertain
that → have → Collins
The agency was examining interactions between Collins and a top donor: Martin Kao, CEO of defense contractor Navatek.
asserted
agency → examine → Navatek
According to Kao, in 2019, the head of the pro-Collins super PAC met with him and other Navatek execs and asked for a $500,000 donation.
uncertain
head → accord → donation
Government contractors are banned from making political contributions.
asserted
contractors → ban → contributions
For the company to offer donations to Collins in exchange for an official action, or for Collins to accept, would constitute criminal bribery.
asserted
Collins → offer → bribery
To skirt campaign finance laws and conceal the source of the funds, Kao sent an initial $150,000 to the super PAC using a shell company, saying he had cleared it with his lawyer.
asserted
he → skirt → lawyer
The head of the super PAC knew Kao was behind the donation.
asserted
Kao → know → donation
“Very smart,” he replied in an email viewed by ProPublica.
asserted
he → reply → ProPublica
Weeks later, Kao told his team Collins committed to getting the company $32 million in naval contracts.
asserted
Collins → tell → contracts
But the FBI saw through Kao’s shell company ruse.
asserted
FBI → see → ruse
In 2022, a grand jury indicted him for making illegal campaign contributions.
asserted
jury → indict → contributions
Facing years in prison, Kao revealed the full scheme to the FBI, hoping to reduce his sentence.
asserted
Kao → face → sentence
What he told them has never before become public.
asserted
told → tell → them
Kao and his close associates donated nearly $900,000 to dozens of politicians, allowing Navatek to establish operations in half a dozen states with more than $40 million a year in government funds.
asserted
Navatek → donate → funds
Collins, Kao said, was Navatek’s most important patron.
asserted
Kao → say → ?
Then President Donald Trump returned to office — and the FBI and Department of Justice teams that handled public corruption cases were eviscerated.
asserted
that → return → cases
The investigation died, and the government stopped talking to an informant who had offered a road map to corruption in Congress.
asserted
who → die → Congress
ProPublica revealed the existence of the case for the first time.
asserted
ProPublica → reveal → time
Collins’ deputy chief of staff said that her office “vigorously” denies allegations of bribery and pay-for-play made by Kao and that her office “fully cooperated” with the FBI.
asserted
office → say → FBI
After our story was published, the senator mustered a defense that was full of incorrect and misleading claims, calling ProPublica’s reporting a “smear job” that took “the words of a twice-convicted felon over my office, campaign staff and me.”
uncertain
that → publish → office
ProPublica reviewed a trove of evidence gathered by the FBI and thousands of pages of legal records, and interviewed dozens of people familiar with Navatek, its Washington operations and the FBI inquiry to conduct our own investigation.
asserted
ProPublica → review → investigation
The White House referred us to the FBI.
asserted
House → refer → FBI
A spokesperson said the FBI “ultimately found nothing implicating Senator Collins” or her campaign.
asserted
FBI → say → Collins
The FBI spokesperson did not address questions about the new phase of the investigation prompted by Kao’s account.
asserted
spokesperson → address → account
Navatek founder Steven Loui said Kao’s methods were “unethical and illegal” and that the company fully complied with law enforcement.
asserted
company → say → enforcement
Watch our video to learn more on how we independently corroborated much of Kao’s account.
asserted
we → watch → account
The Aporia
