A benefits fraudster who sold fake luxury gear on Instagram has claimed that £158,000 found stashed among baby clothes was her children's life savings.
asserted
158,000 → sell → clothes
Megan Carney-Borrowman flogged the counterfeit goods, purporting to be Chanel, Burberry and Versace, on social media to her thousands of followers.
asserted
Borrowman → flog → followers
She built a massive business empire with accounts linked to the mother showing more than £4million was deposited over a four-year period.
asserted
4million → build → period
The mother-of-four from Southport, in Merseyside, was aided by her husband, 35-year-old Jordan Borrowman, and by her mother, Sandra Carney, 65, who also roped in her long-term business partner, Adam Yaffe, 53.
asserted
who → aid → partner
The four defendants were sentenced over two days at Liverpool Crown Court this week with Carney-Borrowman being handed a sentenced of four years and three months for conspiracy to commit trademark offences.
asserted
Borrowman → sentence → offences
Carney-Borrowman and her husband's home was raided for the first time in November 2022 after Chanel tipped off anti-crime units to the illicit activity.
asserted
Chanel → raid → activity
Neither of them were home, and when they were later asked claimed to not have their phones.
asserted
they → ask → phones
Borrowman said his phone was lost and it has never been recovered, although the court heard it was used again following the arrest.
asserted
it → say → arrest
Meanwhile Carney-Borrowman tried to deceive officers by handing over her son's phone in a failed attempt to pass it off as her own.
asserted
Borrowman → try → own
However, Carney's phone was recovered and messages led police to uncover Yaffe's involvement.
asserted
messages → recover → involvement
Analysis of Carney-Borrowman's accounts following her first arrest found she made significant cash withdrawals and her home was searched again in April 2023.
asserted
home → follow → April
The second raid prompted the discovery of her phone, on top of her curtain rail in the master bedroom.
asserted
raid → prompt → bedroom
Megan Carney-Borrowman built a £4million business empire flogging counterfeit goods online
Pictured: Cash seized from Carney-Borrowman's family home in connection with her counterfeit goods conspiracy
More significantly however, as James Rae, prosecuting, told the court: 'She also sought to prevent the officers searching her baby's bedroom, although it became apparent that the real reason was that there was £158,000 in cash concealed in there.
asserted
reason → build → cash
This was seized despite the defendant claiming that it was her children's savings that she had withdrawn.
asserted
she → seize → that
'
The seizure of the phone proved to be significant for the investigation, with it showing a 'very large volume of chats from which it was overwhelmingly evident that she was selling counterfeit goods and using a 'drop-shipping' method to import them from the overseas supplier directly to the customer's address'.
asserted
she → prove → address
Police found Carney-Borrowman had eight business bank accounts as well as 18 personal accounts, some in the name of her young children.
asserted
Borrowman → find → children
The court heard between 2019 and 2023 the business accounts received nearly £4,319,952.73, and £753,419.50 of it was paid into her personal accounts.
asserted
753,419.50 → hear → accounts
Carney-Borrowman was then arrested for benefit fraud in May 2024, with an investigation by the Department for Work and Pensions finding she benefited to the tune of around £68,300 made up of a failure to declare her self-employment income; her purchases of two houses; her residing with Borrowman; and their joint assets.
uncertain
her → arrest → Borrowman
She was also found to have made a bogus insurance claim after telling Halifax she had lost her expensive Rolex on a night out in Blackpool.
uncertain
she → find → Blackpool
But when North West Regional Organised Crime Unit (NWROCU) officers attended her home, they saw a Rolex on her wrist that matched the same serial number as the apparently missing timepiece.
asserted
that → attend → timepiece
Footage from the NWROCU shows the moment an officer questions Carney-Borrowman about the Rolex on her wrist.
asserted
officer → show → wrist
After being asked if she was wearing a Rolex, she told an officer 'it's not real...you're not taking it off me.
asserted
it → ask → me
After being told to hand it over, she added: 'It's actually my mum and dad who got it for me so I could probably get a receipt.'
uncertain
I → tell → receipt
When asked if it was a genuine, Carney-Borrowman changed her answer and confirmed it was.
asserted
it → ask → answer
Mr Rae told the court Carney-Borrowman was the 'prime mover' in the offending, 'clearly supported and encouraged by her mother'.
asserted
Borrowman → tell → mother
Borrowman was said to have been a significant beneficiary from the proceeds of the counterfeiting, and had at times sold, packaged and carried goods as part of the conspiracy, although in a supportive role.
asserted
Borrowman → say → role
Meanwhile Yaffe was said to have 'encouraged, cautioned and advised' Carney-Borrowman.
asserted
Yaffe → say → Borrowman
In mitigation, Nicholas Clarke, defending Carney-Borrowman, told the court her remorse was not self-pitying but 'reflective of the genuine fear she has for her children'.
asserted
she → defend → children
He said there were developmental concerns regarding all her children, and her youngest had ongoing appointments at Alder Hey Children's Hospital.
asserted
youngest → say → Hospital
A Rolex seized from Carney-Borrowman's property
Mr Clarke said: 'Her children revolve around her and most of her waking life is dealing with them...the reports set out the concerns she has about all of the children being looked after by others.'
asserted
she → seize → others
He told the court that Carney-Borrowman had PTSD following the tragic death of a child in April 2022.
asserted
Borrowman → tell → April
The prosecution said that Carney-Borrowman had lied to the author of her original pre-sentence report and claimed she only started selling counterfeit goods as a result of her daughter's death when she felt unable to engage in conventional employment.
asserted
she → say → employment
Michael Lavery, for Carney, said his client had worked her whole adult life, had carried out several selfless acts 'over a number of years to assist people less fortunate than her' and had supported her two daughters; both of whom had children of their own.
asserted
both → say → own
He told the court: 'It seems to anyone approaching this case that this is a mother doing her best for a daughter who has a number of problems.
asserted
who → tell → problems
There is no more a person than a mother who wants to help her child, misguided and naïve it has been.'
asserted
it → be → child
Richard Vardon, representing Borrowman, said: 'It may be the position that the mother of the children cannot care for them in the immediate future so they would be more impacted if this defendant was to go to prison as well.'
uncertain
defendant → represent → prison
Andy Evans, for Yaffe, told the court his client's offending was characterised by his relationship with Carney-Borrowman.
asserted
offending → tell → Borrowman
'He assisted her with things mundane, things tragic and difficult, and things happier, such as becoming her wedding photographer,' he said.
asserted
he → assist → things
Sentencing, Judge Louise Brandon said: 'The business operated through Instagram accounts and WhatsApp ordering systems with multiple bank accounts, corporate structures, direct overseas suppliers, drop-ship methods, concealed payments and efforts to avoid detection.'
asserted
business → sentence → detection
The judge added: 'Involvement at any level of counterfeiting are grave offences.
asserted
Involvement → add → counterfeiting
…and 14 more, not listed.
The Aporia
