California’s laws aimed at protecting workers from the impacts of artificial intelligence could pave the way for broader workplace safeguards across the US as calls for regulating the technology mount.
uncertain
calls → aim → technology
As the federal government goes hands-off on AI, California is taking the reins to address workers’ biggest fears.
asserted
California → go → fears
On Thursday, California governor Gavin Newsom signed a suite of new laws that ban bosses from relying entirely on AI to decide whether to fire workers, using it to predict employees’ emotional states or collecting neural data, meaning the information from electrical signals of someone’s brain or nerves.
asserted
that → sign → brain
They also require companies to notify workers if layoffs were caused by AI and prohibit AI surveillance in workplace bathrooms.
asserted
layoffs → require → bathrooms
The new laws come as workers increasingly worry whether AI will take their jobs, lead to discrimination and increase workplace surveillance.
asserted
AI → come → surveillance
Unions, worker advocates and even some lawmakers pushed for the new rules, a regulatory shift for a technology that has largely developed unchecked.
asserted
that → push → technology
California, home to many of the leading companies developing AI, represents one of the first states to roll out a sweeping set of workplace regulations targeting the technology.
asserted
California → lead → technology
“It’s a turning point,” said Lorena Gonzalez, president of the California Federation of Labor Unions, AFL-CIO, who’s been helping leaders across the country write regulations.
asserted
leaders → ’ → regulations
“It’s really the first time we’re seeing California workers showing the country that we don’t have to accept [this].”
asserted
we → ’ → this
Other states that have recently passed individual laws aimed at AI’s use in the workplace include Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois and Texas, narrower in scope than California’s.
asserted
that → pass → California
And more bills across the county are being lined up for consideration, Gonzalez said.
asserted
Gonzalez → line → consideration
California’s laws aim to target workplace surveillance measures like heat maps that track employees’ movements, including how long they spend in the bathroom, or having their emotional states monitored.
asserted
states → aim → bathroom
Amazon warehouse workers have previously complained about being timed on their bathroom breaks, for example.
asserted
workers → complain → example
And at Kaiser Permanente, nurses have said automated systems rated their tone of voice in patient interactions.
asserted
systems → say → interactions
But the laws could also prevent future unexpected harms.
uncertain
laws → prevent → harms
“We don’t know all the places companies are using AI, and that is and should be scary,” Gonzalez said.
asserted
Gonzalez → know → AI
Part of the strategy for worker advocates and union groups like the California Federation has been following AI companies’ latest products.
asserted
Part → follow → products
“If it’s being sold, that’s a good indication” it could be in use, Gonzales said.
uncertain
Gonzales → sell → use
The federation also plans to use the momentum to revive issues like requiring employers to disclose when they’re using AI in the workplace, which was a bill that died in the state’s assembly appropriations committee this year.
asserted
that → plan → committee
California’s new laws are a key step in gaining regulatory ground for worker advocates, said Robin Feldman, director and founder of AI Law & Innovation Institute at The University of California College of the Law, San Francisco.
asserted
Feldman → gain → Law
Still, the statutes are somewhat limited in how they are implemented.
asserted
they → implement → ?
“The bills have no private enforcement,” Feldman said.
asserted
Feldman → have → enforcement
“In other words: workers can’t sue.
asserted
workers → sue → words
Only the government can enforce the laws.”
asserted
government → enforce → laws
The new regulations come amid a backdrop of record AI spending at big tech companies along with massive job cuts.
asserted
regulations → come → cuts
But workers have started pushing back.
asserted
workers → start → ?
In June, Meta paused a program that tracked workers’ computer activities to train its AI models.
asserted
that → pause → models
And one month later, dozens of employees filed a lawsuit claiming the tech company’s AI tools targeted those with disability accommodations or on medical or parental leaves for layoffs.
asserted
tools → file → layoffs
Meanwhile, safety concerns, including fears that AI could destroy humanity, have been garnering more attention from lawmakers across the country and prompted OpenAI and Anthropic to call for slowing the pace of development.
“Workers are increasingly part of that movement, speaking up about the fear of job loss and the dehumanizing experience of being surveilled and controlled by an algorithm,” said Annette Bernhardt, senior tech policy adviser at UC Berkeley Labor Center.
uncertain
Bernhardt → include → Center
While the new laws “have teeth”, according to Danielle Ochs, shareholder at employment law firm Ogletree Deakins’ San Francisco office, it’s unclear how sweeping the change will be.
uncertain
change → have → office
Ochs said employers generally aren’t grappling with the AI uses outlined in the new regulations and instead are more interested in how to responsibly implement AI across their systems.
asserted
employers → say → systems
“Having 10 hoops you have to jump through per tool is not reflective of reality,” she said.
asserted
she → have → reality
It would be better to have “guardrails that are more aligned” with employers’ wider use of AI rather than focused on specific tools or uses.
asserted
that → have → tools
She says opponents worry that the new rules could unexpectedly prohibit helpful AI that might, for example, ensure truckers don’t fall asleep at the wheel.
uncertain
truckers → say → wheel
While it’s too soon to gauge how effective the laws will be, worker advocates believe the momentum is moving in a positive direction.
asserted
momentum → ’ → direction
Gonzalez said the measures are only the beginning of addressing AI’s potential impacts.
asserted
measures → say → impacts
“We have so much work to do,” she said.
asserted
she → have → work
“But this should give us all hope we can win … against the tech lobby, against big corporations, because we are the majority.”
asserted
we → give → corporations
The Aporia
