A prominent Palestinian Israeli politician has been forced to withdraw from the upcoming elections over his remarks about the Gaza war, while Israeli far-right leaders have remained untouched despite their incendiary rhetoric and calls for violence against Palestinians.
asserted
leaders → force → Palestinians
The Israeli political institutions, including the electoral body, have been accused of double standards for targeting Palestinian politicians and parties in Israel.
asserted
institutions → include → Israel
Recommended Stories
list of 3 items- list 1 of 3Israel’s Supreme Court advises Arab party leader to drop election bid
- list 2 of
asserted
Court → advise → bid
3Israel’s Lapid accuses Netanyahu of ‘fear-mongering’ over attack warning
- list 3 of 3The
asserted
Lapid → accuse → warning
Sami Abu Shehadeh, the leader of the Balad party, withdrew his candidacy after the Supreme Court warned he could be disqualified from the race.
uncertain
he → withdraw → race
He has described the decision to disqualify him from the upcoming elections as “a historical catastrophe for democracy”.
asserted
He → describe → democracy
That court advisory came after Israel’s central elections committee barred him from running over comments he made about the war on Gaza.
asserted
he → come → Gaza
The election, set for October 27, has renewed scrutiny of the challenges faced by Palestinian citizens of Israel seeking political representation.
asserted
election → set → representation
Experts and critics, including Palestinian rights groups, have accused electoral system staff of applying a double standard in which Arab candidates have faced attempts to remove them from the ballot, while far-right Israeli politicians accused of repeatedly inciting violence against Palestinians have been allowed to run.
“It’s always been the case whether the Israeli political system, the political elite, has always designed the political system in a way to ensure that it’s a Zionist state, not just or even a Jewish state,” Zaidon Alkinani, founding director of the Arab Perspectives Institute, told Al Jazeera.
asserted
Alkinani → include → Jazeera
So, what happened, and what does the controversy say about Palestinian participation in Israeli elections?
asserted
controversy → happen → elections
Abu Shehadeh is a historian from Jaffa and the leader of Balad, a Palestinian nationalist party that advocates equal rights for all citizens of Israel.
asserted
that → advocate → Israel
He served in the Knesset from 2019 until 2022.
asserted
He → serve → 2022
His candidacy was challenged by far-right Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir over an article published on October 8, 2023, the day after the Hamas-led attacks on Israel, which he described as “an important historical event”.
asserted
he → challenge → event
Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara backed his disqualification, arguing the wording could amount to support for armed struggle.
uncertain
wording → back → struggle
Abu Shehadeh, speaking at the Supreme Court on Thursday, said he did not support “armed struggle”, but acknowledged that a paragraph in the article had been incorrectly worded.
asserted
paragraph → speak → article
The Balad leader said his intention was to urge moving the conflict towards a political process.
asserted
intention → say → process
Last month, the Central Elections Committee voted to bar Abu Shehadeh, Hadash politician Ofer Cassif and the two main Arab-majority electoral lists – the Joint List, which includes Balad, Hadash and Ta’al, and Ra’am, or the United Arab List.
asserted
Committee → vote → Balad
The Supreme Court overturned the bans on the two lists and Cassif.
asserted
Court → overturn → lists
In the late 1980s, the pro-Palestinian Israeli spent time in jail for refusing to serve as a soldier in the occupied territories.
asserted
Israeli → spend → territories
He claimed in 2021 that police beat him while he participated in a protest against an illegal Jewish settlement in occupied East Jerusalem.
asserted
he → claim → Jerusalem
Abu Shehadeh accused the Supreme Court of bowing to pressure from Ben-Gvir and questioned how a politician he accused of promoting violence and displacement against Palestinians could seek his exclusion from the election.
“Someone [Ben-Gvir] who was calling for starving people to death in Gaza, for preventing medicine, water and food, and supports the occupation and ethnic cleansing in the [occupied] West Bank … was able to disqualify me, a human rights activist for three decades,” Abu Shehadeh told Al Jazeera.
uncertain
Shehadeh → accuse → Jazeera
Adalah, the legal rights group representing him, called his withdrawal “a severe blow” to Palestinian citizens’ right to political representation.
“This entire process was a deliberate attempt to delegitimise Palestinian citizens and their parliamentary representatives and to turn racism against Palestinians into election propaganda,” it said in a media statement.
asserted
it → represent → statement
Have Israeli leaders used incendiary language?
asserted
leaders → use → language
Before the Supreme Court hearings, petitions were also submitted seeking to disqualify the parties of Ben-Gvir and that of another far-right cabinet member, Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich.
asserted
petitions → submit → member
The Central Elections Committee rejected those petitions, leaving both parties on the ballot.
asserted
Committee → reject → ballot
Section 7A of Israel’s Basic Law on the Knesset provides the legal grounds for barring candidates or electoral lists, including rejecting Israel’s character as a “Jewish and democratic state”, promoting racism, or backing an armed campaign against Israel by a hostile state or a designated “terrorist” group.
asserted
Section → provide → state
Attorney General Baharav-Miara found that the attempts to exclude the far-right parties lacked sufficient legal basis.
asserted
attempts → find → basis
Ben-Gvir and Smotrich have repeatedly faced international backlash over their incendiary rhetoric towards Palestinians.
asserted
Gvir → face → Palestinians
In 2025, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Norway imposed sanctions on both ministers, accusing them of repeatedly inciting violence against Palestinians in the occupied West Bank.
asserted
Kingdom → impose → Bank
More recently, Ben-Gvir proposed a seven-year plan for Palestinians to leave Gaza through what he called “voluntary emigration”.
asserted
he → propose → what
“Instead of illusions of peace now, we need actions of emigration now,” he said in September.
asserted
he → need → September
“Instead of [them] digging tunnels, it’s time to pack suitcases.”
asserted
it → dig → suitcases
Smotrich has also advocated the displacement of Palestinians from Gaza and annexation of the occupied West Bank.
asserted
Smotrich → advocate → Bank
Both he and Ben-Gvir have called for the permanent takeover of Gaza and re-establishment of Jewish settlements there, proposals Netanyahu has rejected.
asserted
Netanyahu → call → proposals
The different treatment of Abu Shehadeh and Israel’s far-right politicians has led Palestinian politicians and experts to accuse the electoral system of applying a double standard.
asserted
treatment → lead → standard
Palestinian political analyst and playwright Ahmed Najjar told Al Jazeera that Abu Shehadeh’s case exposed what he described as the “two-tier nature of Israeli democracy”.
asserted
he → tell → democracy
“This is not the equal application of the law,” he said.
asserted
he → say → law
“It establishes one threshold for Jewish Israeli politicians and another for Palestinian citizens of Israel.”
asserted
It → establish → Israel
Najjar pointed to the contrast between the court’s treatment of Abu Shehadeh’s October 2023 article and the continued eligibility of Ben-Gvir and Smotrich, despite inflammatory statements attributed to the two far-right politicians.
asserted
Najjar → point → politicians
“Jewish extremism can be accommodated within Israel’s political system,” Najjar argued, “while Palestinian political speech is treated as an existential threat”.
asserted
speech → accommodate → threat
…and 12 more, not listed.
The Aporia
