Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
Jan Crawford sat down with Justice Alito for an extended interview.
asserted
Crawford → sit → interview
But I think this discussion of the Dobbs leak is significant:
asserted
discussion → think → leak
The fallout began in late April 2022, when Politico notified the Court that it had a copy of the draft and intended to publish it.
asserted
it → begin → it
The justices were gathered in the Court's private dining room for one of their regular lunches when the chief justice told them of the leak.
asserted
justice → gather → leak
By tradition, the justices have lunch together when they're in the building for arguments or conference, sometimes a few days a week.
asserted
they → have → arguments
It's a chance for them to talk about anything other than the cases.
asserted
them → talk → cases
Hearing during a collegial lunch that a draft opinion had leaked for the first time in Court history was difficult for the justices to process.
asserted
justices → hear → history
Alito said he was "stunned."
asserted
he → say → ?
"It was quite a shock," Alito said.
asserted
Alito → say → ?
"But within a relatively short period of time, the thought occurred to me, and I think to the others in the majority, that this would endanger us.
asserted
this → occur → us
And it made us targets for assassination."
Security, Alito said, ramped up immediately.
asserted
Alito → make → assassination
A month later, in June of 2022, the world would know why.
asserted
world → know → 2022
In the middle of the night, as Justice Brett Kavanaugh and his family slept in their Maryland home, a would-be assassin approached their backyard with a bag containing a gun and rounds of ammunition, a knife and nail punch, duct tape, zip ties, a crowbar and other burglary tools, including special shoes to silence his footsteps.
asserted
assassin → sleep → footsteps
He was intent on killing justices before the Court released its Dobbs decision.
asserted
Court → kill → decision
With its narrow 5-4 majority, it would only take one justice.
asserted
it → take → justice
He said on private messaging boards he aimed to kill at least three of the conservatives and, as prosecutors later put it, "single-handedly and irrevocably to alter an entire branch of the United States government."
asserted
prosecutors → say → government
At the last minute, the man spoke to his sister on his cell phone, and she managed to talk him out of it.
asserted
she → speak → it
He was arrested and later convicted for the attempted assassination of Kavanaugh.
asserted
He → arrest → Kavanaugh
"His goal was to change the decision in the case.
asserted
goal → change → case
So that was quite predictable," Alito said.
asserted
Alito → say → ?
"And whoever leaked it knew or had good reason to know that that would be the consequence of leaking it.
asserted
that → leak → it
And Politico knew, or should've known, that that would be the consequence of their decision to publish it."
Politico has explained its decision to publish the leaked draft as an "unprecedented view into the justices' deliberations" that is "plainly news of great public interest."
The leaker remains unknown.
asserted
leaker → know → interest
After Politico published its piece in early May, one theory was that a conservative had leaked the draft to keep the five votes in place, in case any of the justices in the majority were wavering.
uncertain
any → publish → majority
"It's implausible that any of us would have done that for exactly the reason I've mentioned, because this pinned a target on our backs," Alito said.
asserted
Alito → do → backs
"And it was very fortunate that that planned attack (on Kavanaugh) was not successful."
asserted
attack → plan → Kavanaugh
There were two general theories of who might have leaked the opinion.
uncertain
who → be → opinion
One theory is the leak came from the right as a means to lock in the votes and prevent a flip.
asserted
leak → come → flip
As second theory is the leak came from the left as a means to put pressure on the majority to flip the vote, or worse, plant the seeds for deligitimizing the Court.
asserted
leak → come → Court
Alito says quite clearly that whoever leaked should have been aware that the publication would put a bullseye on the back of the five-member majority.
asserted
publication → say → majority
No conservative would plausibly take that action.
asserted
conservative → take → action
Alito firmly rejects the first theory.
asserted
Alito → reject → theory
The second theory remains viable.
asserted
theory → remain → ?
Crawford also confirms that Justice Thomas assigned the majority opinion.
asserted
Thomas → confirm → opinion
With Roberts in dissent, urging the five not to overturn Roe, Thomas was the senior justice in the majority.
asserted
Thomas → urge → majority
He assigned Alito the opinion.
asserted
He → assign → opinion
This was the speculation, and reinforces that from the get-go, Chief Justice Roberts did not support overruling Roe.
asserted
Roberts → reinforce → Roe
The Aporia
