A young Australian taken as a boy to live with the Islamic State was on the brink of travelling home when American soldiers snatched him from a Syrian prison and transported him to Iraq, where he could face trial on terror charges.
uncertain
he → take → charges
Yusuf Zahab, who is now 23, was 12 years old when his parents took him to live in the so-called caliphate, and is the only male issued a passport by the Australian government as part of attempts by family members earlier this year to bring Zahab and 34 women and children home.
asserted
parents → take → Zahab
As family members travelled to Syria in February to try to bring the women and children home, the United States was transferring 5704 prisoners, including Zahab and 12 other Australians, to Iraq.
asserted
States → travel → Iraq
The forced transfer came in the face of a deteriorating security situation in north-eastern Syria.
asserted
transfer → force → Syria
In Iraq, many will face trial as alleged terrorists, and possibly the death penalty.
uncertain
many → face → terrorists
It remains unclear if Zahab will be among them.
uncertain
Zahab → remain → them
Two sources, including one close to his family, say he has been told he will not be prosecuted because he was a minor during the conflict.
asserted
he → include → conflict
“Iraqi investigators that have met with him found that he never took up arms or supported the death cult and had never been involved in anything that made him a combatant, supporter or adherent,” one of the Australia-based sources said.
asserted
one → meet → sources
The senior counterterrorism advisor at Human Rights Watch, Letta Tayler, issued a scathing report on Monday about the prospect of fair trials in Iraq and the responsibilities of western countries.
asserted
advisor → issue → countries
She told this masthead Zahab’s case was particularly shocking.
asserted
case → tell → masthead
“Yusuf’s only crime appears to be he was brought to Syria as a boy by adult relatives,” Tayler said.
asserted
Tayler → appear → relatives
“He’s been detained for years without charge or trial, separated from his family, wounded, including in the head, come down with serious illnesses and is given up for dead, only to be discovered in Syria where he was last seen.
asserted
he → detain → Syria
And if he hadn’t suffered enough, he was then transferred to Iraq at the moment he was ready to be sprung from detention in northeastern Syria.
asserted
he → suffer → Syria
The mind reels at the amount of trauma this boy has suffered.
asserted
boy → reel → trauma
Tayler agrees it is possible he will not be tried.
asserted
he → agree → ?
Iraq is “looking very carefully at the young men who were detained since they were children, so I would not be surprised if Iraq doesn’t bring charges against Yusuf Zahab,” she said.
asserted
she → look → Zahab
Another Australian source with knowledge of the situation said if he was released, Zahab could be reunited with his passport – which is in safe keeping in Syria – and returned to Australia.
uncertain
which → say → Australia
“Certain community members are discussing what they can do to give him justice,” the source said.
asserted
source → discuss → justice
“I think it wouldn’t be that difficult to get Yusuf from Iraq into Syria, get his passport and get him back here, but there’s a procedure we need to go through.”
asserted
we → think → him
The source said it was likely Zahab would need to go before an Iraqi judge who could order his release.
uncertain
who → say → release
Though the authorities there would prefer cooperation or contact with the Australian government, there had been little to none.
asserted
authorities → prefer → none
Australia has consistently refused to offer any assistance to those linked to Islamic State, and has said of another prisoner, Tareq “Dr Jihad” Kamli that he can “rot in jail” in Iraq.
asserted
he → refuse → Iraq
The Human Rights Watch report says 5704 detainees had been taken from Syria in January and February without any legal basis into the Iraqi legal system which has “a documented history of torture and unlawful executions”.
asserted
which → say → torture
Iraq had only days to prepare before 1100 adults arrived with serious and contagious diseases including tuberculosis, according to sources cited by Human Rights Watch.
uncertain
adults → have → Watch
“One man died in transfer and 14 others died after arrival, apparently from serious health conditions”.
asserted
others → die → conditions
The Al-Karkh prison authority told Tayler the cells were now filled to 158 per cent capacity.
asserted
cells → tell → capacity
More than 440 transferred detainees are children, including one who is 12.
asserted
who → transfer → one
The Iraqi government and Human Rights Watch have urged countries, including Australia, to take responsibility for their citizens, repatriate them and try them in their own countries.
asserted
government → urge → countries
“The international community must step up and assume its responsibility,” according to Ali Diaa, the administrative director of Iraq’s National Centre for International Judicial Cooperation, which is overseeing the investigations.
uncertain
which → step → investigations
“We are looking for tangible support, not workshops and conferences.”
asserted
We → look → support
Iraqi law allows for the prosecution of children as young as nine, but Diaa told Human Rights Watch that 95 per cent of children were unlikely to be prosecuted.
asserted
cent → allow → children
The outcome for young men detained since childhood, such as Yusuf Zahab, remains unclear, the report said.
uncertain
report → detain → Zahab
“This situation is not unique to Australia,” report author Letta Tayler told this masthead.
asserted
Tayler → tell → masthead
“But Australia certainly could take a leadership role by bringing this young man home.”
Cut through the noise of federal politics with news, views and expert analysis.
uncertain
Australia → take → news
Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter.
asserted
Subscribers → sign → newsletter
The Aporia
