It is a bruised OpenAI that is set to limp into the Australian political spotlight today.
asserted
that → set → spotlight
It had been pencilled in for a centre stage performance, tapping into a bit of Silicon Valley star power, to convince Australians they should want the AI company to make our nation its second home.
But it is hard to imagine a worse warm up act than Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's announcement that OpenAI's agents had "hacked" into a Medicare statistics website making global headlines.
asserted
agents → pencil → headlines
It wasn't exactly a digital armageddon, given the incident was neither particularly sophisticated nor revealed anything of importance.
asserted
It → give → importance
Even though it was quite novel and a taste of things to come.
asserted
it → come → things
But you wouldn't have known from the whack Albanese gave the company amid his global push for AI regulation.
asserted
Albanese → know → regulation
He used an international stage to shame the company, revealing it had sent a 2:42am email to a government inbox advising of the hack.
asserted
it → use → hack
The situation was made worse after subsequent reporting that OpenAI's agents had also tried to hack other federal government agencies and, dropping late on Friday afternoon before the long weekend, the NSW government's news of another hacking.
asserted
agents → make → hacking
The Australian government hack was the tip of the iceberg as OpenAI disclosed similar incidents to more than 100 other organisations.
asserted
OpenAI → disclose → organisations
The company has tried to stem the bleeding with a formal apology and sent out a US-based top-level executive, chief strategy officer Jason Kwon, to show they're taking it seriously.
asserted
they → try → it
Last time Kwon was here he was wining and dining top public servants.
asserted
he → win → servants
This time he might feel like he's on the menu.
uncertain
he → feel → menu
OpenAI isn't the only AI company appearing before the committee, with Anthropic, Google and Microsoft representatives also set to appear, but it has, for better or for worse, been given the top billing.
asserted
it → appear → billing
AI doom predictions not helping
Outside those snafus the preceding weeks weren't much kinder.
asserted
predictions → help → snafus
Last month was dominated with headlines of researchers at AI companies leaving or, weirdly, not leaving, because of their stated belief there was a good chance they were building a technology that would kill all of humanity.
asserted
that → dominate → humanity
Now, there's a lot of skepticism around this point of view given it seems to "yada yada" the fairly consequential steps between "AI gets very good" and "the global population goes to zero".
asserted
population → be → zero
Regardless of your views of the likelihood of AI annihilation there's no doubt the gloomy predictions became part of the global zeitgeist.
asserted
predictions → be → zeitgeist
In September, Democratic pollster David Shor found that the importance of AI as an issue for American voters had increased "dramatically" in just a week, amid the controversy.
asserted
importance → find → controversy
These existential fears only reinforce existing concerns with 70 per cent of Australians saying they think AI is moving too fast, according to polling put out in September by the Minderoo Foundation.
uncertain
AI → reinforce → Foundation
Overall, the hacks, AI doomerism and the barrage of coverage about data centre proposals and the backlash against them has hardly been an ideal warm-up act.
asserted
hacks → warm → them
Bipartisan reform and maybe political cover
To understand what we should expect from today it's worth looking at the origins of this hearing.
asserted
it → understand → hearing
The creation of a Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence was in fact initiated by the Coalition, with both Andrew Hastie and Aaron Violi speaking in favour of it, moved by Tony Burke, and passed on voices.
asserted
Hastie → initiate → voices
Contrast that with its duelling federal inquiry, the data centres and artificial intelligence inquiry led by Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young, which struck a notably skeptical tone about the social license of AI infrastructure and the companies using it.
asserted
which → contrast → it
Instead, we've gotten a snap inquiry with terms of reference so long and broad you almost need AI to summarise it.
asserted
you → get → it
There are some serious and important questions that OpenAI will hopefully face, including but not limited to why it lets its AI have access to the open internet without safeguards or close monitoring.
asserted
AI → be → safeguards
This is an industry that simultaneously claims to take safety seriously while letting its unmuzzled creations loose into the world.
However, the speculation among the AI industry and its watchers is that the main purpose of the inquiry is in setting the stage for bipartisan-backed reforms that would pave the way for AI companies to train in Australia.
uncertain
companies → claim → Australia
No doubt, the Albanese government would like some political cover for any tough decision.
asserted
government → like → decision
Some in the opposition have signalled they're happy to work with the government, even if they wouldn't mind seeing some political pain first.
asserted
they → signal → pain
Out of everything the government has flagged as an area that needs reform, copyright looms large as the issue that feels the furthest from an solution.
asserted
that → flag → solution
AI companies say they need some kind of deal that would let them train their AI in Australia legally and without fear of repercussions for what is assuredly mass copyright infringement under Australian law.
asserted
what → say → law
Creatives and rights-holder groups accuse the AI companies of stealing their work and now refusing to even try to operate legally by signing deals.
asserted
Creatives → accuse → deals
They will make that case when they appear at the hearings today, before AI companies get a chance to defend themselves.
asserted
companies → make → themselves
Some in the government think this will show the status quo isn't working for anyone and something needs to change.
asserted
something → think → anyone
Last month, we got a glimpse of what the government has been working on behind the scenes with two proposals to change the law to pave the way for AI training on copyrighted material.
asserted
government → get → material
Now it's the companies' turn to convince us that it's all worth it.
asserted
it → convince → us
But after the last few months it's going to take quite a virtuoso performance for OpenAI to get this audience onside.
asserted
audience → go → performance
The Aporia
