A Republican congressional candidate accused Democratic Rep. Pat Ryan of sending his kids to schools near Washington, DC instead of in the suburban New York district he claims as his primary residence.
uncertain
he → accuse → residence
GOP candidate Jackie Auringer, who’s running against Ryan for a House of Representatives seat in New York’s Hudson Valley region, is calling for an investigation into whether the Democrat or another household member claimed DC as a residence for tuition-free public school enrollment.
asserted
Democrat → run → enrollment
“Pat Ryan has collected more than $60,000 from taxpayers for lodging in Washington while receiving a $12,400 veterans property-tax exemption on his claimed primary residence in New York,” Auringer said.
asserted
Auringer → collect → York
“At the same time, we now know his family has been using DC schools.
asserted
family → know → schools
The question for DC officials is simple — who claimed DC residency, and were those representations accurate?”
asserted
representations → claim → residency
Auringer sent a letter to the DC Office of the State Superintendent of Education, which investigates questions of nonresidency in the city’s public schools.
asserted
which → send → schools
Auringer said reviews are mandatory following a report of potential fraud.
asserted
reviews → say → fraud
Democratic socialist Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has previously said whether or not an elected official enrolls children in public schools is an indication of whether he or she is invested in the district.
asserted
he → say → district
In 2018, Ocasio-Cortez criticized her primary opponent, then-Democratic Rep. Joe Crowley, for enrolling his kids in Virginia schools near the capital instead of in his Queens-Brooklyn district.
asserted
Cortez → criticize → district
Crowley’s family lived in Virginia full time while he maintained a home in the district.
asserted
he → live → district
“A Democrat who takes corporate money, profits off foreclosure, doesn’t live here, doesn’t send his kids to our schools, doesn’t drink our water or breathe our air cannot possibly represent us,” the-insurgent Ocasio-Cortez said in a campaign video at the time.
uncertain
Cortez → take → time
She shocked the political world by toppling Crowley, who was also the Queens Democratic Party chairman, in the that year’s primary election.
asserted
who → shock → election
The 18th District encompasses parts of Orange, Dutchess and Ulster counties.
asserted
District → encompass → counties
The Auringer campaign claims it has evidence that at least one of Ryan’s children attended a DC public school in 2024.
uncertain
one → claim → 2024
Under DC rules, only one parent with custody needs to be a DC resident for a student to attend as a resident, meaning it could be legal if Ryan’s wife, Rebecca, claimed District of Columbia residency, according to Auringer’s camp.
uncertain
wife → need → camp
Nonresident students permitted to attend are required to have a tuition agreement and pay tuition.
asserted
students → permit → tuition
DC law also could impose penalties when a person knowingly provides false information to a public official in connection with student residency verification.
uncertain
person → impose → verification
Those penalties include retroactive tuition and either a fine of up to $2,000 or imprisonment for up to 90 days.
asserted
penalties → include → days
Cases involving knowingly false residency information may also be referred to the DC Office of the Attorney General.
uncertain
Cases → involve → General
“This is simple: Is Pat Ryan paying his share of school taxes anywhere?” Auringer asked.
asserted
Auringer → pay → taxes
“The records exist,” Auringer said.
asserted
Auringer → exist → ?
“OSSE should review them, determine what representations were made about residency and whether they were accurate, and take whatever action the facts warrant.”
asserted
facts → review → action
Ryan refused to answer whether his two sons are enrolled in school in DC or the 18th District.
asserted
sons → refuse → DC
“For the safety of his family, we do not comment on the location of his four- and seven-year-old children,” a Ryan spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → comment → children
Ryan, a former Ulster County executive and Army veteran, was first elected to Congress in 2022 and is seeking a third-term.
asserted
Ryan → elect → term
He’s heavily favored to win re-election.
asserted
He → favor → election
The independent Cook Politcal Report rates the district as “solid Democrat.”
asserted
Report → rat → Democrat
Auringer works in her family’s construction business, Urban Precast, where she serves as a project manager and managerial accountant.
asserted
she → work → manager
Members of the House of Representatives serve two-year terms at an annual salary of $174,000.
asserted
Members → serve → 174,000
The Aporia
