As death row inmate Christa Pike remains in hospital following a failed lethal injection, we take a closer look at the track record for botched executions in the US.
asserted
we → remain → US
Days after receiving two doses of the lethal injection drug pentobarbital, death row inmate Christa Pike remains alive.
Her attempted execution, which made headlines around the world, left many wondering: how often does a death penalty go badly wrong?
asserted
penalty → receive → many
In the United States, the answer is: more often than you think.
asserted
you → think → States
And what happened to Christa Pike should concern even those who are in favour of the death penalty, according to Julian Koplin, a lecturer in bioethics at the Monash Bioethics Centre.
uncertain
who → happen → Centre
"If you are in favour of the death penalty, you think that in principle, [for] certain kinds of crimes … it might be proportionate justice for you to lose your own life," Dr Koplin told the ABC.
uncertain
Koplin → think → ABC
"But that's not to say it would be appropriate to torture someone.
asserted
it → say → someone
"Executions themselves are not meant to be overly painful.
asserted
Executions → mean → ?
"We don't still burn people at the stake."
asserted
We → burn → stake
During that time period, the US conducted 8,776 executions, according to political science professor Austin Sarat.
uncertain
US → conduct → Sarat
Methods included lethal injection, hanging, gas, electrocution and firing squad.
asserted
Methods → include → injection
According to the Death Penalty Information Center, an execution is "botched" when it departs from standard protocol.
uncertain
it → accord → protocol
Dr Sarat, who published a book analysing the US execution history, estimated about 3.14 per cent of them were botched.
asserted
cent → publish → them
Botched executions were those "involving unanticipated problems [that] caused unnecessary agony for the prisoner".
"With each development in the technology of execution, the same promises have been made, that each new technology was safe, reliable, effective and humane," he wrote.
asserted
he → botch → execution
"Those claims have not generally been fulfilled."
uncertain
claims → fulfil → ?
In commentary published last week, Dr Sarat also noted Pike's case was "not an isolated event".
asserted
case → publish → commentary
According to author Dr Sarat's analysis in 2014, 75 of 1,054 lethal injection executions conducted had gone wrong in some way.
uncertain
75 → accord → way
All 27 death penalty states, along with the US military and US federal government, have authorised the method.
asserted
states → authorise → method
Lethal injection has the highest rate of being botched compared to any other execution method, according to Dr Sarat.
uncertain
injection → have → Sarat
Prior to Christa Pike, no person has ever survived the lethal injection drug being administered.
asserted
person → survive → drug
"Seven people prior to Ms Pike had survived failed execution attempts," the Death Penalty Information Center said.
asserted
Center → survive → attempts
"But in all of those, the execution was called off due to difficulties setting an IV line, and no drugs were ever administered.
asserted
drugs → call → line
'Ghastly, uncomfortable' questions about death sentences
It's still unclear what exactly went wrong during Christa Pike's execution.
uncertain
what → go → execution
The Tennessee Department of Corrections team responsible for establishing intravenous (IV) lines used at least seven syringes in their attempt, according to an emergency motion filed by Pike's legal team.
uncertain
team → establish → team
At least one needle was allegedly bent "in a 90-degree angle" when it was removed.
uncertain
it → bend → angle
Pike's ordeal lasted from shortly after 7pm, when the first dose was administered, to almost 9pm, when emergency services were called to the prison.
asserted
services → last → prison
In August 2022, death row inmate Joe Nathan James Jr was subjected to what a witness described as "carnage".
asserted
witness → subject → carnage
James suffered multiple unsuccessful attempts to establish an IV line, according to a report by human rights organisation Reprieve.
uncertain
James → suffer → Reprieve
"A private autopsy later documented numerous injuries, including three unexplained cuts in Mr James left arm, deep bruising, and needle puncture wounds," the report said.
"When [James] was brought into the execution chamber, witnesses reported that he appeared to be unconscious."
asserted
he → document → chamber
One of these cuts was concluded in that private autopsy to likely be a "cutdown", a medical procedure where a deep cut exposes a vein.
asserted
cut → conclude → vein
Some experts have speculated the drug entered the tissue in Pike's arm, rather than entering the vein.
asserted
drug → speculate → vein
After arriving at a Nashville hospital, both her arms were found to be "swollen, burned, and blistered".
asserted
arms → arrive → hospital
"Ms Pike's experts have compared pentobarbital to 'bleach' or 'Drano'," court documents said.
asserted
documents → compare → bleach
"It is caustic and highly alkaline and burns upon contact, including skin, tissue, and veins."
She remains intubated and on a ventilator, according to her legal team, who say it may be several days before her full condition is known.
uncertain
condition → burn → team
The size of death row has declined every year since 2001, and the total population of death row is now down by more than a third compared to its peak of slightly less than 3,600 at the turn of the 21st century.
asserted
population → decline → century
But while the population has decreased, the time spent on death row has only increased.
asserted
time → decrease → row
Inmates now spend decades on death row waiting for their execution.
asserted
Inmates → spend → execution
In Christa Pike's case, she had been waiting more than 30 years.
asserted
she → wait → years
According to a poll by Washington-based analytics firm Gallup, less than half of US adults aged 18-54 support the death penalty.
uncertain
half → accord → penalty
Support for the death penalty has been declining since it peaked at 80 per cent approval in 1994, according to Gallup's research.
uncertain
it → decline → research
A total of 44 per cent of Americans said they opposed the death penalty.
asserted
they → say → penalty
…and 9 more, not listed.
The Aporia
