Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has built a national following by channeling the energy of Americans who are worried about the influence of corporations, including makers of vaccines, drugs, processed foodsand pesticides.
asserted
who → build → vaccines
But last week the leader of the “Make America Healthy Again” movement threw his support behind an unlikely industry: artificial intelligence.
asserted
America → make → industry
At a MAHA summit featuring AI and Silicon Valley executives, Kennedy declared that the technology would free Americans from “medical tyranny” by allowing them to “fact check their own medical advice.”
asserted
them → feature → advice
“We’re never ever again going to be able to be dominated by public officials who tell us: ‘Trust the experts,’” Kennedy told the invite-only audience.
asserted
Kennedy → go → audience
Some prominent MAHA voices quickly criticized Kennedy’s embrace of AI, saying the movement's leaders are increasingly cozying up to the corporate interests they once scrutinized.
asserted
they → criticize → interests
At the same time, medical experts say Kennedy’s vision of AI as a check against the medical establishment is fundamentally flawed.
asserted
vision → say → establishment
“He obviously doesn’t understand how AI works,” said Dr. Zeke Emanuel, a cancer specialist and bioethicist at the University of Pennsylvania.
asserted
Emanuel → understand → Pennsylvania
“AI aggregates the information we have in the medical literature and in case studies.
asserted
we → aggregate → studies
And that means what you’re actually getting is medical expertise.”
asserted
getting → mean → what
Both OpenAI and Anthropic offer health-focused chatbots that can analyze users' medical records and answer their healthcare questions.
asserted
that → offer → questions
Their models are trained on thousands of peer-reviewed medical papers and professional guidelines and incorporate feedback from doctors.
asserted
models → train → doctors
“He wants AI to mimic what he says,” Emanuel said.
asserted
Emanuel → want → what
“But that’s not what good AI is going to do.”
asserted
AI → ’ → what
HHS spokesperson Emily Hilliard said Emanuel was describing “one narrow use” of the technology.
asserted
Emanuel → say → technology
Kennedy wants to give Americans more control of their own health data by using AI “to help them understand it, interrogate it, compare it with the evidence, and make better decisions with their doctors,” Hilliard said.
asserted
Hilliard → want → doctors
The technology will help doctors work faster, giving them “more time to treat and care for patients,” she added.
asserted
she → help → patients
MAHA leader defends corporate sponsorships
OpenAI and Anthropic were among the sponsors of last week’s MAHA Summit.
asserted
OpenAI → defend → Summit
So were more than a dozen other companies with pending business before the U.S. government, including developers of psychedelic drugs, fitness wearables and an experimental cancer test.
asserted
companies → pende → drugs
Sponsors paid up to $300,000 and many received speaking slots on panels that included some of the administration’s top health officials, including Dr. Mehmet Oz of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
asserted
that → pay → Services
“It was classic pay-to-play,” said Dr. Robert Malone, a vaccine researcher who has questioned the safety of mRNA shots and recently served on a federal vaccine panel under Kennedy.
asserted
who → pay → Kennedy
Malone and other figures in the MAHA movement say the summit showed how big companies are replacing the “MAHA moms” and other grassroots activists who originally powered the movement.
asserted
who → say → movement
“There was no representation of people that have been at the core of MAHA and its creation, whether it be physicians or patients or patient advocates,” Malone said.
asserted
Malone → be → MAHA
The summit was organized by MAHA Center Inc., one of a number of nongovernment groups run by Kennedy associates that are dedicated to promoting his agenda.
asserted
that → organize → agenda
Others include the MAHA Institute, a think tank, and MAHA PAC, a political fundraising operation.
asserted
Others → include → Institute
Tony Lyons, a publisher who runs the MAHA Center, MAHA PAC and several related groups, addressed criticisms about corporate sponsorships at a reception ahead of the summit.
asserted
who → run → summit
“The truth is we’re trying to build the biggest movement we can possibly build to actually get things done,” Lyons said.
uncertain
Lyons → try → movement
The Trump administration has embraced AI
Kennedy's alliance with Silicon Valley is consistent with broader efforts across the Trump administration.
asserted
alliance → embrace → administration
President Donald Trump has vigorously resisted efforts to bring greater oversight to AI companies, who have helped drive the stock market to record highs.
asserted
who → resist → highs
One of Trump’s first actions after returning to the White House was revoking a Biden administration executive order on AI oversight.
asserted
One → return → oversight
It took the administration more than 16 months to replace it with its own order.
asserted
It → take → order
In recent weeks, Trump announced a move to let the AI industry police itself, tried to rebrand the technology as “super intelligence” and brushed aside bipartisan concerns about the impacts of data centers on nearby residents.
asserted
industry → announce → residents
Meanwhile, Dr. Oz and other administration officials have touted AI as the answer to a litany of U.S. health problems, including rising medical costs, healthcare fraud, physician shortages and the shuttering of rural hospitals.
asserted
Oz → tout → hospitals
Medicare officials have been in discussions with several medical chatbot companies, including one behind a Utah program that provides AI-enabled refills of prescriptions.
asserted
that → include → prescriptions
The remarks from Kennedy and other officials last week reflect a “techno-utopian” view of AI’s potential benefits, says Glenn Cohen, a Harvard Law School bioethics expert.
asserted
Cohen → reflect → benefits
Cohen notes that much of RFK’s agenda over the past year has focused on trying to curb food industry practices he views as harmful to consumers, including the use of artificial colors and undeclared chemical additives.
asserted
he → note → colors
Given Kennedy's skepticism of “big food,” Cohen said he was surprised the health secretary didn't see “the risk that market incentives may diverge from the public good.”
uncertain
incentives → give → good
Some of the most prominent MAHA organizations are actively organizing against AI interests.
asserted
Some → organize → interests
For example, Moms Across America operates local and national campaigns warning against pollution, water use and electricity costs associated with data center construction.
asserted
Moms → operate → construction
The group was founded by Zen Honeycutt, a former staffer for Kennedy’s presidential campaign.
asserted
group → found → campaign
Moms Across America did not respond to a request for comment.
asserted
America → respond → comment
…and 12 more, not listed.
The Aporia
