NSW Police Commissioner Mal Lanyon used an eleventh-hour intervention to try to prevent the state’s police watchdog from holding public hearings examining the conduct of officers during a demonstration against the visit of Israeli President Isaac Herzog.
asserted
Lanyon → use → Herzog
The Law Enforcement Conduct Commission’s public examinations were due to start no earlier than September.
asserted
examinations → start → September
On September 15, the commission said a “range of procedural issues” meant the Operation Makalu hearings would not proceed.
asserted
hearings → say → issues
On Thursday, it announced they would begin after all, with an October 19 opening address.
asserted
they → announce → address
Private examinations will run for five weeks before public hearings of senior commissioned officers begin.
asserted
hearings → run → officers
The probe will examine police behaviour after a series of violent clashes outside Town Hall in early February, including allegations of officer misconduct.
asserted
probe → examine → misconduct
Police face allegations they engaged in unnecessary brutality in dealing with protesters, with body-worn camera footage showing an officer revelling after a violent altercation.
asserted
officer → face → altercation
More than 800 complaints were lodged over the way NSW Police handled Sydney’s anti-Herzog protests.
asserted
Police → lodge → protests
In a 63-page document released on Thursday detailing the rationale for using public and private hearings, the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC) revealed that Lanyon made submissions arguing witness examinations should be heard in private and not be livestreamed.
asserted
examinations → release → submissions
His submission questioned “whether any examination is to take place in whole or in part in public”.
asserted
examination → question → public
Lanyon’s submission argued that the police watchdog had “no express power” for counsel assisting – headed by Kirsten Edwards, SC – to make an opening statement.
asserted
counsel → argue → statement
In its submission to the commission, counsel assisting challenged Lanyon’s position that examinations should only be held in private and not livestreamed, arguing it would “leave the existing public account as the only public account until the commission’s report is published”.
asserted
report → assist → account
The document noted the police commissioner had co-operated with the LECC, disclosing footage on September 7 collected from members of the public, which could be relied on during public and private hearings.
uncertain
which → note → hearings
It noted Lanyon “was not obliged to provide this substantial body of material ahead of the opening and examination”.
asserted
Lanyon → note → opening
But the LECC said two days later the commissioner raised an issue about the use of public hearings.
asserted
commissioner → say → hearings
That challenge subsequently raised legal and factual arguments, “including legal arguments concerning the LECC Act never advanced before in the history of the commission and its work”.
asserted
challenge → raise → commission
The police watchdog noted there had been no objection raised from March 23, when Lanyon was first invited to participate in the commission’s investigation and the use of public examinations was foreshadowed, until the intervention in late September.
asserted
use → note → September
“The timing of these issues being raised by the commissioner of police is more than regrettable given its impact on the orderly progress of the investigation, the preparation for examinations and the efficient and effective use of public resources by both the commission and the NSWPF and the associated cost and disruption flowing from the delay,” the LECC wrote.
asserted
LECC → raise → delay
Sue Higginson, the Greens spokesperson for justice, condemned the six-month delay as an effort to derail the work being done by the independent police watchdog.
asserted
Higginson → condemn → watchdog
“This was an extraordinary attempt by the police to suppress the public examination of allegations of serious misconduct by uniformed police officers, and to prevent public scrutiny of the political decisions and command structures that led to police violence against protesters,” she said.
asserted
she → suppress → protesters
The commission, referring to the private evidence of a senior sergeant in mid-September, said the Operation Makalu investigation raised issues of a “potentially systemic nature” in the use of force in policing and in “the training, supervision and command” of the riot squad.
asserted
investigation → refer → squad
Police had raised concerns about officers involved in public hearings being identified, noting there was anxiety in attending these examinations and argued there was a potential “chilling effect” upon officers prepared to undertake public order work as a result of providing evidence.
However, counsel assisting the commission argued that “visible and fair accountability for the public order role is part of what sustains the community’s confidence in the NSWPF”.
asserted
what → raise → NSWPF
The commission determined that at least some public examinations were appropriate, noting the large number of complaints lodged, and use of statutory powers exercised by police, but not all would be held in public.
“If the commission’s investigation was conducted entirely or almost entirely in public, it may have an adverse impact on the community by provoking community discord in a way that impacts negatively on social cohesion,” the LECC concluded.
uncertain
LECC → determine → cohesion
Chief Commissioner Peter Johnson, SC determined that police witnesses up to the rank of inspector would not be identified during proceedings – they would be provided with pseudonyms – and their evidence taken in private examinations.
“I am not satisfied that effective measures can be put in place to guard against identification of those officers if their evidence is given in public,” he wrote.
asserted
he → determine → public
NSW Police said it acknowledged the decision by the LECC to hold private hearings as part of Operation Makalu, and it awaited the findings.
asserted
it → say → findings
The LECC has been publicly pushing for legislation to be strengthened to give it a “clear statutory entitlement” to access the information it needs to conduct investigations.
asserted
it → push → investigations
This would allow the police watchdog to access crucial NSW Police documents.
asserted
watchdog → allow → documents
The Aporia
