According to Bayside Council, in Sydney’s south, when it’s a “community gathering”.
uncertain
it → accord → south
A group campaigning against developer Stockland’s proposed $2.9 billion, 25,400-square-metre data centre at the former Kogarah Golf Club site on the banks of the Cooks River was left bemused after the council wrote to it this week informing them they would not be allowed to hold a protest in a park on Friday evening.
asserted
they → campaign → evening
Despite submitting a “Form 1” notice informing the NSW Police about their intent to hold the gathering – billed on social media as a “no AI data centres” event featuring speakers, a community barbeque and 15-minute film screening at Cahill Park in Wolli Creek – Bayside Council has told the group no.
asserted
Council → submit → group
In correspondence seen by the Herald, the council wrote to the group saying it had “not received an event application, booking request or sufficient information to assess the proposed activity”.
asserted
it → see → activity
The group required approval, council said, because it was holding a “community gathering” involving food, a film screening and “amplified sound”.
asserted
it → require → food
“As council has not been provided with the information necessary to undertake a proper assessment, including consideration of the proposed activities, infrastructure, venue availability, park capacity, operational impacts and any other event scheduled at the site, council is unable to support the event proceeding on the advertised date,” the council staffer wrote.
asserted
staffer → provide → date
Despite the warning, the group, called Stop the Cooks River AI Project, or SCRAP, insists it will proceed with the demonstration, saying councils do not have the power to ban protests.
asserted
councils → call → protests
“Their initial correspondence just said well we don’t support this going ahead, you can apply to hold an event, but it’ll take a minimum of eight weeks to assess.
asserted
it → say → weeks
We haven’t existed for eight weeks,” one of the group’s members, Caitlin Boyce, said.
asserted
one → exist → members
“We’ve told them we’re happy to work with them on any reasonable requests, and that we’re more than happy to comply with things like not putting posters up on trees and staying off the sporting fields.
asserted
we → tell → fields
On Thursday, Bayside Council wrote to the group again insisting they would need public liability insurance to hold a protest, which SCRAP estimates could attract up to 100 people.
uncertain
SCRAP → write → people
The council is opposed to the proposed data centre, and lodged a submission to a NSW parliamentary inquiry warning the glut of controversial proposals under assessment in the state were consuming scarce industrial land near Sydney Airport and Port Botany.
asserted
glut → oppose → Airport
It has not said whether it plans to issue fines to the group, or attempt to block the protest from proceeding.
asserted
it → say → protest
It did not respond to a request for comment from the Herald.
asserted
It → respond → Herald
The stand-off exposes a tension between local council regulations, which often require permission for events, and the broader implied freedom of political expression.
asserted
which → expose → expression
The attempt to restrict the community group’s demonstration has drawn the ire of other groups, with Anastasia Radievska, the protest rights campaigner at the Australian Democracy Network, saying the attempt to impose “red tape” on protests could deter smaller community organisations from organising.
uncertain
attempt → restrict → organisations
“When councils have the power to say yes or no to a protest, a democratic right turns into a permission slip,” she said.
asserted
she → have → slip
It is not the first time the nascent group has faced restrictions on its campaign against the proposed data centre.
asserted
group → face → centre
Last month, SCRAP members were moved on by security while attempting to hand out leaflets on the village green at Wolli Creek.
asserted
members → move → Creek
After relocating to a footpath across the road from Wolli Creek train station, the group were told that land was also privately owned.
asserted
land → relocate → station
The group complied with the request, but one of its members, University of Sydney academic and long-time activist Paddy Gibson, wrote to the company that owns the Wolli Creek development, Discovery Point, to insist on its “statutory and constitutional rights to engage in public political activities in NSW”.
asserted
that → comply → NSW
The company – which is owned by the Australian arm of Singaporean property developer Frasers – replied that it did not allow “political campaigning, protest activity, distribution of campaign material or associated signage anywhere within the privately owned Discovery Point property”.
asserted
it → own → property
That ban extended to the “privately owned roads, common areas and other areas forming part of the Discovery Point property”, the company wrote in correspondence seen by the Herald.
asserted
company → extend → Herald
Gibson said he was “incredulous” at the email.
asserted
he → say → email
“I just wrote to them saying, like, mate, there’s an implied freedom to political communication in this country,” he said.
asserted
he → write → country
“We’ve got rights, mate.”
asserted
We → get → rights
“It’s not as if we were setting up a stall trying to sell mobile phones or something, we’re handing out leaflets.”
asserted
we → ’ → leaflets
A representative from Discovery Point said he was unable to comment, but confirmed the “Discovery Point precinct is privately owned and managed land”.
asserted
precinct → say → Point
The Aporia
