Public housing tower residents have been offered a reprieve by the state opposition, which is pledging to pause the tower demolition program and fix the buildings where possible to protect thousands of homes.
asserted
which → offer → homes
The David versus Goliath battle between the residents and the Victorian government was fought in the High Court this week, in a bid to establish whether those living in the towers were treated fairly as the state made plans to demolish and redevelop 44 towers across Melbourne.
asserted
state → fight → Melbourne
With residents involved in the class action – who live in three towers across Flemington and North Melbourne – expecting to wait until after November’s election for a verdict, opposition housing spokesman David Southwick said a Coalition government would pause and review the project.
asserted
government → involve → project
“What we see the government doing is demolishing people’s homes, many [who] have lived in these homes for 20-plus years, without any certainty of where they’re going to go,” Southwick said at the Victorian Council of Social Service’s community sector summit.
asserted
Southwick → see → summit
“We will certainly pause to ensure that no more of those towers will be demolished.
asserted
more → pause → towers
And where we can fix them up, we’ll fix them up, and ensure we get those many vulnerable Victorians … back into the communities that they have been in for years.”
asserted
they → fix → years
Southwick also criticised the number of apartments vacant within many of the remaining towers.
asserted
Southwick → criticise → towers
“When we have a housing shortage, why do we have so much vacant housing?
asserted
we → have → housing
Why haven’t they been fixed?” he said.
asserted
he → fix → ?
The government’s decision to demolish Melbourne’s 44 public housing towers has faced sharp criticism from residents, community members and advocates since it was announced by then-premier Daniel Andrews in 2023.
asserted
it → demolish → 2023
A legal challenge was launched almost immediately following the announcement.
asserted
challenge → launch → announcement
The class action was dismissed by the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal, before it was granted a rare application for special leave to appeal by the High Court, which was heard on Wednesday.
asserted
which → dismiss → Wednesday
Louisa Bassini, the managing tenancy and housing lawyer at Inner Melbourne Community Legal, which is representing residents from three of the 44 towers, said the case would set an important precedent for others living in public housing.
asserted
case → manage → housing
“Just because you don’t own your home, that doesn’t mean that a decision to relocate you doesn’t warrant procedural fairness,” Bassini said.
asserted
Bassini → own → fairness
Among those included in the challenge are North Melbourne residents Hawa Hussien and Hawa Warsame.
asserted
residents → include → challenge
The long-time friends and neighbours have both lived in the same public housing tower for 28 years.
asserted
friends → live → years
Between them, they have raised 17 children there, and love being close to family, friends and the wider community.
asserted
they → raise → family
Both women say the government’s decision to relocate them and knock down their beloved tower feels as if a rug has been pulled out from underneath them and their whole world.
asserted
rug → say → them
There’s been no interest from the department with regard to these people’s wellbeing and how they’re coping with this issue.
asserted
they → cop → issue
[They] feel like they have not been heard,” said Warsame’s daughter, who translated for the women.
asserted
who → feel → women
Two of the 44 towers have already been demolished and in January, a further seven were earmarked for the next phase of demolition.
asserted
seven → demolish → demolition
The project is expected to result in the relocation of about 10,000 residents.
asserted
project → expect → residents
Last month, the decision to bulldoze the towers was criticised in a United Nations report.
asserted
decision → bulldoze → report
Under the plan overseen by state government agency Homes Victoria, residents have been offered alternative accommodation in community housing properties, and relocated renters would later have the opportunity to return to social housing within their neighbourhood based on their eligibility and needs when the redevelopment had been completed.
asserted
redevelopment → oversee → eligibility
Social housing is an umbrella term which refers to both public and community housing.
asserted
which → refer → housing
Unlike state-owned public housing, community housing is owned and operated by independent not-for-profit organisations.
asserted
housing → own → organisations
Rent can be set at a higher rate, and utilities are charged separately.
asserted
utilities → set → rate
Hussien and Warsame were offered alternative accommodation in community housing in Kensington, but both declined because they said they did not receive accurate information about the rental agreement.
asserted
they → offer → agreement
They also said the residences felt unfamiliar and smaller than their current homes, and weren’t within the well-established community where they feel comfortable.
asserted
they → say → community
The thought of moving is “anxiety-inducing” and “borderline crippling”, Warsame’s daughter added.
asserted
daughter → move → ?
Both women say they hope the High Court will let them remain in their homes.
asserted
them → say → homes
“This whole issue, I feel like no one’s put a human lens to it.
asserted
one → feel → it
It’s been very much a politicised issue,” said Warsame’s daughter.
asserted
daughter → say → ?
“They’ve been praying endlessly that the decision is that they get to stay.
asserted
they → pray → ?
And they’re really hoping that that will be the outcome.”
asserted
that → hop → ?
At the High Court on Wednesday, lawyers representing the residents argued that the demolition decisions infringed upon their legally recognised rights, and that they had not been afforded procedural fairness.
asserted
they → represent → fairness
“Tenants had contractual rights to occupy and exclusively possess their homes,” they said, according to an outline of oral arguments released by the court.
uncertain
they → have → court
“The established social communities in the towers were an intrinsic aspect of tenants’ homes, and were necessarily dispersed by the decision [to demolish].”
asserted
communities → establish → decision
Homes Victoria argued that it had the power to develop land and its decision was “not capable of directly affecting” the individual legal rights of tenants.
asserted
decision → argue → tenants
“The [demolition] decision was the adoption of a general policy, was not based on considerations personal to any particular renter, and did not affect individual renters differently from each other,” lawyers for Homes Victoria argued, according to an outline of their oral arguments.
uncertain
lawyers → base → arguments
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
