- Published
More than 260 industry leaders from business, finance and law have held a meeting to discuss the role high value residents play in Jersey's economy.
asserted
residents → publish → economy
Jersey's high value residency programme, external grants residential status to highly skilled and economically active high net worth individuals.
asserted
external → grant → individuals
One attendee at the Chamber of Commerce lunch on Thursday, Mary O'Keeffe, said high value residents "were extremely important" to the island.
However, one former economic advisor to the government described the tax contribution of high value residents as "piffling".
asserted
advisor → say → residents
About 260 families currently live in Jersey having relocated through the scheme.
asserted
families → live → scheme
O'Keefe who runs Mary O'Keefe relocation, external to help high value residents settle in the island said they contributed a lot to the economy and philanthropic causes.
"
asserted
they → run → economy
They are extremely important, so here today the room is full of private bankers, tax accountants, lawyers, people like myself and professionals who all work with high net individuals.
asserted
who → work → individuals
"So, they bring an enormous amount to the economy and that doesn't even touch on what they bring in regard to philanthropy."
asserted
they → bring → philanthropy
High value residents pay a 20% tax rate on the first £1.25m of worldwide income, external.
asserted
residents → pay → income
They then pay a 1% on any income above £1.25m and there are some who feel these individuals should be paying more tax, external.
asserted
individuals → pay → tax
O'Keefe said: "I can understand that but that's not looking at the argument the right way.
"
asserted
that → say → argument
First of all, the basic pay that they pay is £250,000 and that's before you even look at their worldwide income.
asserted
you → pay → income
"And the 1% often equates to many millions and that's what people don't understand.
"
asserted
people → equate → what
High net worth individuals are extremely mobile, they are fluid, they can pick up and go wherever they want and they want to go somewhere that's safe, that's secure, that their wealth is going to be looked after and they're not going to feel that they're going to be ripped off."
Garry Bell, a tax advisor to high value residents, said if tax for wealthy individuals was increased he believed Jersey would lose them.
asserted
Jersey → pick → them
He said if the money they made above £1.25m was taxed at 20% instead of 1% it could damage the economy.
uncertain
it → say → economy
"If we tax those individuals at 20% the numbers would reduce dramatically.
asserted
numbers → tax → %
So instead of having a net increase of say 18 or19 individuals a year you're probably only looking at one or two," Bell said.
asserted
Bell → have → one
"So, we're sacrificing by seeking to tax them more, we're sacrificing that the direct income tax take, the stamp duty take, the employment, the GST, there's a whole raft of economic benefits that we sacrifice by actually seeking to tax those individuals at 20%.
asserted
we → sacrifice → %
"We are competing with a number of other jurisdictions, Dubai - zero tax.
asserted
We → compete → jurisdictions
He said the amount of tax they pay is "piffling, frankly".
asserted
they → say → tax
"I think it's quite divisive, particularly in such an unequal island community.
asserted
it → think → community
As a development strategy, who benefits?
asserted
who → benefit → strategy
They benefit because they're paying very little tax on their income but is it going to benefit young Jersey people?
asserted
it → benefit → people
I suspect its going to contribute more to ratcheting up of house prices, ratcheting up of prices in the shops, and a higher cost of living generally.
asserted
its → suspect → living
"And where they contribute to the island's economy, outside paying frankly minimal amounts of tax, lies with construction work.
asserted
they → contribute → work
"They've built endless, frankly, rather ugly and inappropriately sized houses."
asserted
They → build → houses
The Aporia
