A top US official has faced online criticism after appearing to endorse a false claim that India's stock market had collapsed following the Trump administration's latest restrictions on foreign workers, including Indian IT professionals.
uncertain
market → face → professionals
Anthony D'Esposito, Inspector General of the US Department of Labor, reacted to a post by American conservative commentator Benny Johnson on X with the words “Ruh roh”.
asserted
D'Esposito → react → words
The post claimed that India's stock market had “completely COLLAPSED” after the Trump administration suspended major technology companies from a programme linked to employment-based green cards.
asserted
administration → claim → cards
Social media users criticised the response, with some accusing the official of amplifying misinformation about India.
asserted
some → criticise → India
On October 8, the Trump administration suspended eight major technology companies, including Cognizant, Infosys, Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), Wipro, HCL, Capgemini, Microsoft and Adobe, from the Permanent Labor Certification, or PERM, programme.
asserted
administration → suspend → programme
The move came amid the administration's broader efforts to curb what it alleges is the misuse of foreign worker programmes at the expense of American workers.
asserted
it → come → workers
PERM is a key step in the employment-based green card process.
asserted
PERM → base → process
Employers seeking to sponsor most foreign workers for permanent residence must generally obtain certification from the Labor Department that there are not enough qualified, willing and available American workers for the position and that hiring a foreign worker will not adversely affect US wages and working conditions.
asserted
hiring → seek → wages
What Benny Johnson claimed about Indian markets
Reacting to the restrictions, Johnson claimed that the Indian stock market had crashed because of the administration's action against the tech companies.
asserted
market → claim → companies
“The largest IT outsourcing firms in the world, Cognizant, Infosys, Tata, Wipro, HCL and Capgemini were removed from the Permanent Labor Certification Program,” Johnson wrote on X.
He also claimed that 75 per cent of Cognizant employees in the US were Indian nationals and pointed out that Infosys, Tata, Wipro and HCL were based in India.
asserted
Infosys → remove → India
Johnson further alleged that these companies had sought millions of foreign workers over the years and questioned whether India's economy was based on “scamming” the US.
asserted
economy → allege → US
However, a community note attached to Johnson's post pointed out that Indian stock markets had closed hours before the US administration announced the restrictions on October 8.
asserted
administration → attach → October
This undermined the claim that the announcement had caused the market to crash that day.
uncertain
market → undermine → claim
Users question US official
D'Esposito's brief response to Johnson's post prompted criticism from users who questioned why a senior US official appeared to engage with a claim contradicted by the community note.
uncertain
official → question → note
“How do you became inspector general, without even knowing the facts?
asserted
you → become → facts
Read the community notes,” one user wrote.
asserted
user → read → notes
Another user criticised the apparent amplification of the claim, writing: “Top US official is spreading fake news that Indian markets collapsed.
uncertain
markets → criticise → news
And they have the gall to call Indians ‘scammers.’
asserted
they → have → Indians
While Indian benchmark indices fell sharply on Thursday, the decline was attributed to rising crude oil prices, the Reserve Bank of India's rate hike, and foreign investor outflows.
asserted
decline → fall → India
On Friday, October 9, the Sensex and Nifty rebounded in early trade after two sessions of losses.
asserted
Sensex → rebound → losses
The 30-share BSE Sensex rose 292 points to 71,876.10, while the NSE Nifty gained 84.60 points to 22,310.40.
asserted
Nifty → rise → 22,310.40
Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) shares surged more than 4 per cent after the company reported a 15 per cent year-on-year rise in net profit to Rs 13,884 crore.
asserted
company → surge → crore
The controversy comes amid heightened scrutiny of Indian technology companies and foreign worker programmes under the Trump administration.
asserted
controversy → come → administration
The latest PERM suspensions could affect the green card sponsorship process for employees of the companies involved, although the move does not, by itself, mean that all their Indian employees have lost their jobs or visas.
uncertain
employees → affect → jobs
The Aporia
