The Pentagon has said it will livestream the upcoming execution of convicted mass shooter Nidal Malik Hasan by firing squad – a first for the United States.
asserted
it → say → States
A Pentagon spokesperson made the announcement on Thursday, drawing uproar from legal quarters as experts and rights groups raised concerns that it could violate US and international laws and, in particular, put minors at risk.
uncertain
it → make → risk
Recommended Stories
list of 4 items- list 1 of 4Trump approves firing squad execution for Fort Hood attacker Nidal Hasan
- list 2 of 4Hegseth says firing squad execution of Fort Hood shooter will be ‘public’
- list 3 of 4Fort Hood shooter to be executed by firing squad: All to know
- list 4 of 4Police
asserted
shooter → approve → squad
What we know
asserted
we → know → What
The US military rarely invokes capital punishment, last executing an officer by hanging in 1961.
asserted
military → invoke → 1961
Firing squads are even rarer, and were last used in the military in 1945.
asserted
squads → use → 1945
Here’s what we know:
asserted
we → ’ → what
What was Hasan convicted of?
asserted
Hasan → convict → What
Nidal Malik Hasan, a then-Army major, opened fire at an Army processing centre in Fort Hood, Texas, on November 5, 2009, killing 13 people and injuring 32 others.
An Army psychiatrist found he was acting in an effort to stop military deployments to Afghanistan and to halt the killing of fellow Muslims.
asserted
he → open → Muslims
Following a lengthy military trial in which Hasan made little effort to defend himself, a jury convicted him in July 2013 of 13 counts of premeditated murder and 32 counts of murder, and imposed the death penalty.
asserted
jury → follow → penalty
Although he said he acted on religious grounds and was found to have corresponded with al-Qaeda-linked elements, Hasan was not convicted of “terrorism” as the US military justice code does not have a stand-alone charge for it.
asserted
code → say → it
This week, the Pentagon said US President Donald Trump had given the go-ahead for Hasan to face a firing squad.
asserted
Hasan → say → squad
The military requires presidential approval for executions, and only the president can stipulate a particular method.
asserted
president → require → method
When and where will Hasan be executed?
asserted
Hasan → execute → ?
On Thursday, a Pentagon official said Hasan was to be executed at the same Fort Hood military base where he killed 13 people in 2009.
asserted
he → say → 2009
The official said the execution would be livestreamed.
asserted
execution → say → ?
Acting Secretary of the Army Adam Telle set the execution date for December 3 at 1pm local time (18:00 GMT).
asserted
Telle → act → pm
What has Hegseth said?
asserted
Hegseth → say → What
Speaking in a podcast interview this week, Hegseth said the livestream would act as a deterrent.
asserted
livestream → speak → deterrent
“We’ll make sure that people are able to watch it, that it’s public, because people need to understand that there’s serious consequences for these types of things,” Hegseth said during the interview with far-right podcaster Jack Posobiec.
asserted
Hegseth → make → Posobiec
He added that the timing of the execution was symbolic.
asserted
timing → add → execution
“We’re going to do it at one o’clock, which is when he did it, and it’s going to be soldiers with rifles executing the firing squad.”
asserted
it → go → squad
Who normally attends executions?
asserted
Who → attend → executions
The rules vary in the 27 US states where death penalties are still in place.
asserted
penalties → vary → place
Texas law allows up to five close relatives of the victim, a spiritual guide, justice officials, state-ordained chaplains, a judge, the sheriff, and the media to attend an execution.
asserted
relatives → allow → execution
Rainey Bethea was publicly hanged in Owensboro, Kentucky, after confessing to the rape and killing of 70-year-old Lishia Edwards.
asserted
Bethea → hang → Edwards
What does international law say about public executions?
asserted
law → say → executions
The US is a signatory to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), which bans torture, cruel, inhuman, or degrading punishment.
asserted
which → ban → torture
While the convention does not completely ban the death penalty, it does strictly restrict its use to the “most serious crimes” and encourages its abolition.
Washington ratified it in 1992, but it issued reservations and stated that the US would retain the right to impose capital punishment as it sees fit.
asserted
it → ban → punishment
Legal experts say the public execution of Hasan could violate the clause against degrading punishment under the convention.
uncertain
execution → say → convention
A livestream would likely also be recorded and shared widely.
asserted
livestream → record → ?
What does US law say about who can witness executions?
asserted
who → say → executions
British-American human rights lawyer Clive Stafford Smith, who has represented clients on death row in the US and founded the Louisiana Capital Assistance Center in New Orleans in 1993 to represent low-income individuals facing the death penalty, called the move “barbaric”.
asserted
who → represent → move
He said a public execution broadcast in this manner would violate several laws in the US that prohibit the transmission of obscene, indecent, or graphic material, especially to minors.
asserted
that → say → minors
There’s no single federal law stipulating who may witness executions, but death penalty states typically prohibit minors.
uncertain
states → ’ → minors
Likewise, the Army’s justice code (PDF) prohibits minors from witnessing an execution.
asserted
code → prohibit → execution
“I’ve watched six executions, and I suffer from PTSD [post-traumatic stress disorder] to this day,” Stafford Smith told Al Jazeera.
asserted
Smith → watch → Jazeera
“It’s a nightmare, and you’ll have people who will have traumatic responses to it.”
asserted
who → ’ → it
Smith said several legal challenges are likely, and the Army will likely have to consider several factors if it does go ahead with broadcasting the execution.
asserted
it → say → execution
Challengers are likely to question how the US military will prevent children from viewing the livestream, and how they will make Hasan’s shooting less ghastly based on the body parts targeted, he said.
asserted
he → question → parts
…and 9 more, not listed.
The Aporia
