President Donald Trump asked the U.S. Supreme Court on Friday (October 9, 2026) to revive his dismissed lawsuit against his 2016 Democratic rival Hillary Clinton accusing her of conspiring along with former FBI Director James Comey and others to rig that year's election by linking his campaign to Russia.
asserted
Trump → ask → Russia
The Republican President filed his appeal after a federal judge threw out the case and imposed nearly $1 million in sanctions against Mr. Trump and one of his lawyers for bringing a "frivolous" suit.
asserted
judge → file → suit
A U.S. appeals court subsequently upheld the dismissal and sanctions.
asserted
court → uphold → dismissal
Mr. Trump's lawyers wrote in the appeal that Supreme Court review of the case is needed in order to protect the Presidency.
asserted
review → write → Presidency
They wrote that the decisions by the lower courts reflect "a deeply troubling trend of federal courts using sanctions and disciplinary threats to punish the President and his lawyers for legitimate legal positions that those courts (erroneously) reject."
asserted
courts → write → that
In 2022, when he was out of office after losing the 2020 election, Mr. Trump sued Ms. Clinton, Mr. Comey, former British intelligence officer Christopher Steele, the Democratic National Committee and numerous others in a lengthy complaint filed in federal court in Florida.
asserted
Trump → lose → Florida
Mr. Trump, who has a history of suing adversaries, alleged that in the lead-up to the 2016 election, Ms. Clinton conspired with allies to discredit him with a "false narrative" that he and his campaign colluded with Russia.
asserted
he → have → Russia
The lengthy suit alleged "racketeering" and a "conspiracy to commit injurious falsehood”, among other claims.
uncertain
suit → allege → claims
Mr. Trump defeated Ms. Clinton in that election, despite losing the national popular vote, and served his first term in office from 2017 to 2021.
asserted
Trump → defeat → 2021
U.S. government officials have accused Russia of meddling in the 2016 election, and an investigation led by former FBI chief Robert Mueller documented extensive contacts between members of the Trump campaign and Russian operatives who sought to influence the election in his favor.
asserted
who → accuse → favor
Mr. Trump has called the idea of Russian interference a "hoax”.
asserted
Trump → call → interference
Since losing to Democrat Joe Biden in 2020, Mr. Trump has made false claims of widespread voting fraud in that year's election.
uncertain
Trump → lose → election
Mr. Trump regained the Presidency by defeating Democrat Kamala Harris in 2024, and has continued to make those false claims.
uncertain
Trump → regain → claims
U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks dismissed Mr. Trump's lawsuit against Ms. Clinton, citing numerous inadequacies, including that Mr. Trump waited too long to bring some of the claims.
uncertain
Trump → dismiss → claims
The judge likened Mr. Trump's lawsuit to a "two-hundred-page political manifesto outlining his grievances against those that have opposed him”.
asserted
that → liken → him
Mr. Middlebrooks later ordered Mr. Trump and his lead attorney in the case, Alina Habba, to pay nearly $1 million in fees and costs, imposing the sanctions for bringing a case that the judge said was intended "to dishonestly advance a political narrative."
asserted
judge → order → narrative
The judge also faulted Mr. Trump and his lawyers for a "continuing pattern of misuse of the courts”.
asserted
judge → fault → courts
Mr. Middlebrooks found that the lawsuit used abusive litigation tactics, contained "knowingly false" factual allegations and asserted "frivolous" legal theories.
asserted
lawsuit → find → theories
The Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the judge's rulings in 2025, including the sanctions.
asserted
Court → base → sanctions
"Many of Mr. Trump's and Ms. Habba's legal arguments were indeed frivolous," the 11th Circuit stated.
asserted
Circuit → state → arguments
In Friday's filing, lawyers for Mr. Trump and Ms. Habba said the time limit for filing the lawsuit should have been extended because he chose to defer suing during his first term in office in order to carry out his constitutional responsibilities as President.
asserted
he → say → President
"This Court's intervention is necessary to protect the Presidency, and to prevent judicial disagreement from becoming a license to punish its advocates," the filing stated.
asserted
filing → protect → advocates
Mr. Mueller, serving as a special counsel appointed by the Justice Department, issued a 2019 report on his investigation.
asserted
Mueller → serve → investigation
The report stated that Russia "interfered in the 2016 presidential election in sweeping and systematic fashion”, but also stated that "the investigation did not establish that members of the Trump campaign conspired or coordinated with the Russian government in its election interference activities”.
asserted
members → state → activities
Mr. Mueller said in his report that he found "numerous links" and that the Trump campaign "expected it would benefit" from Russia's effort to tilt the election in Mr. Trump's favor.
asserted
it → say → favor
Mr. Trump's then-Attorney General William Barr appointed a different special counsel, John Durham, in 2019 to look into potential missteps by the FBI.
asserted
Barr → appoint → FBI
In a 2023 report, Mr. Durham concluded that the FBI lacked "actual evidence" to investigate Mr. Trump's 2016 presidential campaign and relied too heavily on tips provided by Mr. Trump's political opponents to fuel the probe.
asserted
FBI → conclude → probe
Mr. Trump's Justice Department last year indicted Mr. Comey, one of several adversaries of the President hit with criminal charges, accusing him of making false statements and obstructing Congress after he was accused of lying about authorising leaks to the news media.
asserted
he → indict → media
A federal judge subsequently dismissed the indictment, finding that the prosecutor who Mr. Trump handpicked to prosecute Mr. Comey had been unlawfully appointed.
asserted
Trump → dismiss → Comey
Mr. Steele, working for an opposition research firm that was hired by a law firm on behalf of the Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee, produced a dossier that alleged ties between Mr. Trump's campaign and Russia as well as other salacious accusations, all of which Mr. Trump denied.
asserted
Trump → work → which
The Aporia
