With $80 billion in debt and a sprawling media empire to combine, David Ellison will have his hands full with the now court-approved combination of Paramount and Warner Bros Discovery, known as Skydance.
asserted
hands → sprawl → Skydance
But so-called “expert” opinion has him failing before he even starts.
asserted
he → call → ?
His quest to create an artistically and financially successful company is doomed because, well, they say so.
asserted
they → create → company
Ellison may even be selling pieces of it pretty soon when he wakes and realizes he won’t be able to make the numbers work, their reasoning goes.
uncertain
reasoning → sell → it
Yet if history, including the history of this deal, is any guide, the experts you see quoted and opining about the supposedly insurmountable challenges of Ellison & Co. aren’t worth that proverbial bucket of spit.
asserted
you → include → spit
I say this not as a hater of the experts that have tracked this saga, which began when the indie producer running the small-ish Skydance studio made his first move trying to buy the iconic yet fading media conglomerate Paramount from the Redstone family.
asserted
producer → say → family
Rather, this column is meant to serve as a cautionary tale, a commentary on how elite opinion forms a narrative even when that narrative begins to unravel.
asserted
narrative → mean → narrative
That unraveling began almost immediately, when the so-called smart guys doubted his ability to convince the initially reluctant Redstones to sell him Paramount.
Intense battle
It continued when he faced an intense battle over WBD with streaming giant Netflix.
asserted
he → begin → Netflix
Then after persuading the initially reluctant David Zaslav to sell him Warner Bros. Discovery, no one in this chattering class really expected him to convince the hyperpolitical California AG Rob Bonta to quickly drop his antitrust suit with few conditions so Ellison could consummate the deal and move on with the media merger of the century.
uncertain
Ellison → persuade → century
Even worse, with every victory the opinion makers seemed to double down on their misread that David Ellison was a lucky-sperm kid movie producer of middling success.
asserted
Ellison → seem → success
Sure, he had big dreams of creating a media behemoth — but only with the big bank account of his father, the billionaire Oracle co-founder Larry Ellison, mainstream reasoning went.
asserted
reasoning → have → father
David didn’t deserve to be anywhere near iconic properties like the Warner Studio or CNN, according to the experts.
uncertain
David → deserve → experts
The fact that his dad is pals with President Trump and he went out and hired the brilliant and heterodox journalist Bari Weiss to run CBS only seemed to confirm their confirmation bias.
We all make mistakes, which is why I’m not naming names, though it’s not hard to find out who these people are.
They hail from Wall Street, academia or the media.
asserted
They → go → Street
They may sound like they know what they’re talking about with their snappy dial-a-quotes and first-class academic pedigrees.
uncertain
they → sound → quotes
Sounding good may get you that linchpin quote in the Times or some clicks on your quick takes — but not much else.
uncertain
Sounding → sound → takes
You might be saying, so what?
uncertain
You → say → ?
It’s just a media issue.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
True, but there’s also a bigger problem here about how false narratives are shaped by biases, most of them political and elitist that go beyond this one merger.
asserted
that → ’ → merger
If you’re keeping score, it hasn’t been a good few years for expert opinion makers.
asserted
it → keep → makers
Recall that their solutions to COVID, including harsh lockdowns, turned out to be spectacularly bad.
asserted
solutions → recall → lockdowns
Meanwhile, the investing public relies on real-time, and above all, evenhanded digestion of facts.
asserted
public → invest → facts
This deal was heavily wagered on arb-trading desks across Wall Street or on various prediction market platforms.
asserted
deal → wager → platforms
People at the companies themselves needed the unbiased scoop to figure out whom they would be working for in the coming years, or if they would be working at all.
asserted
they → need → years
As it turns out, they would have been better off consulting an Ouija board than following the chattering class.
asserted
they → turn → class
No, but they have their blind spots — much of it caused by ideological biases — which were at the heart of our nation’s COVID reaction and many more stories in recent years.
asserted
which → have → years
Those biases were front and center in the miscalculations surrounding what went down with Ellison and WBD.
asserted
what → surround → Ellison
As much as elite opinion makers (and I would include my media brethren) tout their egalitarianism, they are an insular bunch (same prep schools, same colleges, same dinner parties and the rest).
asserted
they → include → egalitarianism
They’re also a sneering bunch when it comes to outsiders and those who veer off the progressive plantation.
asserted
who → ’re → plantation
David Ellison, with his indie film background and family ties to Trump, represented the ultimate target to sneer at.
asserted
Ellison → represent → target
A more self-aware “expert” would know that he’s got good genes from his father, one of the smartest men in Silicon Valley with a decades-long track record.
asserted
he → know → record
David must have learned something from pops.
asserted
David → learn → pops
Do a little research on him and you’ll find that David Ellison is no lucky-sperm kid.
asserted
Ellison → do → him
He’s had commercial success in producing movies (“Mission Impossible,” “Top Gun”) that people actually watch.
asserted
people → have → that
Also, when David began proving the elite consensus wrong, the bias didn’t correct.
asserted
bias → begin → ?
Consider the most recent elite consensus that Bonta would never ever settle his fallacious antitrust lawsuit to stop the deal, even when Ellison threatened to leave town and take all his jobs with him.
asserted
Ellison → consider → him
It was an idle threat, we were led to believe, until Bonta folded like a cheap suit when he realized the elites miscalculated Ellison’s determination.
asserted
elites → lead → determination
But if you’re going to trust, also verify.
asserted
you → go → ?
The Aporia
