The term hate crime may evoke an image of an antisemite punching a Jewish person or a racist pushing an Asian woman onto the subway tracks.
uncertain
antisemite → evoke → tracks
But in New York, hate crimes can include more than illegal acts committed against individuals.
asserted
crimes → include → individuals
They can also include crimes committed against property.
asserted
They → include → property
In New York, certain forms of graffiti can count as aggravated harassment in the first degree under a controversial law that raises free speech concerns.
asserted
that → count → concerns
"A person is guilty of aggravated harassment in the first degree" when he or she commits a variety of offenses "with intent to harass, annoy, threaten or alarm another person" based on that individual's identity, including "race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender," or religion.
asserted
he → commit → race
The law applies to anyone who "etches, draws, paints," or otherwise places a swastika on public or private property.
asserted
who → apply → property
The aggravated harassment provision requires law enforcement to make subjective determinations.
asserted
provision → require → determinations
The state must decide whether an act, such as drawing a swastika, is intended to harass a specific religious group.
asserted
act → decide → group
Last year, when anti–Elon Musk protesters in Brooklyn and Manhattan vandalized Teslas with swastikas, The New York Times reported that it was "clear that the vandals…were using the swastikas to attack" Musk, Tesla's CEO and a top Trump administration adviser—"not to broadcast their own support of Nazism.
asserted
vandals → vandalize → Nazism
Yet the cases were investigated as hate crimes.
asserted
cases → investigate → crimes
In June, a student who raised a flag with two swastikas and a Star of David above a New York University building was charged with aggravated harassment and other hate crimes.
asserted
who → raise → harassment
The student admitted to the conduct but pleaded not guilty to the hate crime and aggravated harassment charges.
asserted
student → admit → charges
According to the New York Post, he raised the flag because "he was upset with how NYU handled political issues around Israel."
uncertain
NYU → accord → Israel
Is it a crime to criticize your school's handling of political issues regarding Israel?
asserted
it → criticize → Israel
In New York, law enforcement makes that call.
asserted
enforcement → make → call
First Amendment advocates have previously scrutinized the provision.
asserted
advocates → scrutinize → provision
In 2018, a SUNY Purchase student was charged with aggravated harassment after he put up posters around a campus building featuring Adolf Hitler, a swastika, and a quote from Mel Brooks' movie The Producers.
asserted
he → charge → movie
Hoover Institution fellow Eugene Volokh called the prosecution "unconstitutional," noting thatthe government"can't target for special criminal punishment racist signs.
asserted
Volokh → call → signs
Under R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul (1992), he noted, "a ban on racist 'fighting words' is unconstitutional even if a ban on 'fighting words' generally is constitutional, so a ban on unauthorized signs that display a swastika is unconstitutional even if a ban on unauthorized signs generally is not."
asserted
ban → note → signs
In other words, the government cannot forbid a specific expression of speech.
asserted
government → forbid → speech
While New York residents and leaders may rightfully condemn swastikas, the state should prosecute criminals for illegal actions, not motivating ideologies.
uncertain
state → condemn → ideologies
This article originally appeared in print under the headline "New York Tries To Legislate Away 'Hate'."
asserted
York → appear → Hate
The Aporia
