While the highest profile examples of violence directed at Jewish Canadians and their places of worship repeatedly occur in major centres such as Toronto and Montreal, problems can be found across the country.
asserted
problems → direct → country
The main feature of this annual, federally-funded event organized by the Saint John Newcomers Association is an array of booths representing countries from around the world, all staffed by locals proudly displaying their culture and promoting their heritage.
asserted
all → fund → heritage
As its slogan suggests — “Celebrate Diversity. Build Community. Experience the World — Right Here in Saint John!” — it’s a relaxed, non-political event highlighting Canada’s best attributes.
uncertain
it → suggest → attributes
In August 2025, a group of anti-Israel protesters went looking to make trouble.
asserted
group → look → trouble
Video from that day shows the group chanting slogans and trying to intimidate the Israeli booth.
asserted
group → show → booth
Later things got out of hand.
asserted
things → get → hand
Fortunately, Saint John police did their job and responded quickly.
asserted
police → do → job
In the end, two protesters were arrested, one was charged with assault, another with obstruction of justice.
asserted
another → arrest → justice
A coalition of activist groups, including the Palestinian Solidarity Committee of Saint John, claimed the mere presence of an Israeli booth at Culturefest had caused “tensions and divisions” and thus led to the violence.
asserted
presence → include → violence
In June, this group “asked” the organizers of the festival to “reconsider the participation of the Israeli Zionist Group” stating that it would be “wise and responsible” and that failing to do so “risks further harm to community relations and public safety.”
asserted
failing → ask → relations
The veiled threat appeared to work.
asserted
threat → appear → ?
After some back and forth with event organizers, the local group N.B. Israeli Community decided to take a pass on the 2026 festival.
asserted
group → decide → festival
Organizer Esti Barlevy told the Saint John Telegraph-Journal newspaper that “we don’t feel safe to participate.”
asserted
we → tell → newspaper
As for her discussions with event staff, she said, “No one took accountability, no one reached out and talked about security and how we can prevent it from happening this year.”
asserted
we → say → it
Left to fend for themselves, Barlevy and her organization made the only choice possible: stay home to stay safe.
asserted
choice → leave → themselves
As a result, the Jewish pavilion was nowhere to be seen at this summer’s Culturefest.
asserted
pavilion → see → Culturefest
It was as if Saint John’s Jewish community didn’t exist — which is, of course, the goal of the protesters.
asserted
which → exist → protesters
The mobs’ veto triumphed, once again.
asserted
veto → triumph → ?
Another troubling aspect of this case is the lack of attention it garnered.
asserted
it → garner → attention
A CBC News headline after the first day of the event blithely stated: “Saint John cultural festival running smoothly after last year’s conflict, arrests.”
asserted
festival → state → conflict
With Jews deciding it’s not safe enough to attend, the cultural festival is now a success.
asserted
festival → decide → ?
It is disgraceful to imagine that an event can be considered to be “running smoothly” simply because no one got arrested for allegedly punching a Jew or damaging an Israeli flag.
uncertain
one → imagine → flag
A group choosing not to attend out of fear for their safety is not a synonym for success.
asserted
group → choose → success
Acceding to the demands of a marginal group of intolerant protestors will not put an end to Jewish hatred.
asserted
Acceding → accede → hatred
It will merely emboldened further action meant to shame all Jews and banish Israel from its place in the world.
asserted
It → embolden → world
If we want to confront antisemitism in Canada, we must prevent further situations like this from occurring.
asserted
we → want → this
The proper approach is not to look the other way (or perhaps secretly rejoice) when a Jewish group skips an event.
asserted
group → look → event
Organizers and public officials would never remain silent if another religious or cultural group of Canadians felt the need to back out of an event in similar fashion.
asserted
group → remain → fashion
The proper approach is to say that such demands from radical groups to remove an Israeli booth from a community cultural festival is unbecoming of Canada and to double down on security and statements of support.
asserted
demands → say → support
In addition, these troublemakers should be warned of the legal consequences they will face if they continue intimidating Jewish Canadians.
asserted
they → warn → Canadians
Further, we need to recognize that the notion of “blood guilt” — whereby Canadian families, Jewish or otherwise, are collectively punished for decisions or actions of others — has no place in Canada.
asserted
families → need → Canada
It should be possible to peacefully celebrate Jewish culture without inevitably making it about a conflict far away.
asserted
it → celebrate → conflict
Blood guilt is anathema to the very concept of individual responsibility that animates western society.
asserted
that → animate → society
The organizers of Culturefest should have stated clearly and unequivocally that they believe in their own slogan about celebrating diversity and building community.
asserted
they → state → community
Instead, during the festival this weekend its co-director Lorne Daltrop told CBC: “We are offering a very peaceful, full experience here today…
asserted
We → tell → experience
No one is thinking about any other disturbance or anything else that might have happened in the past … people are really able to enjoy” — as if nothing happened and it didn’t matter that the Israel pavilion wasn’t there this year.
uncertain
pavilion → think → past
Atlantic Canada has an antisemitism problem every bit as worrisome as that in the bigger cities of central Canada.
asserted
Canada → have → Canada
In Nova Scotia and New Brunswick, synagogues have been repeatedly damaged.
asserted
synagogues → damage → Scotia
In 2024, a Fredericton high school girl was beaten up by a classmate.
asserted
girl → beat → classmate
Her family believed it was because of her Jewish identity.
asserted
it → believe → identity
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
