- Published
Ambitious responses to tackling extreme violence in the wake of the Southport attack were not taken forward by the Home Office because of cost, a public inquiry has heard.
asserted
inquiry → publish → cost
The Southport Inquiry, set up after three girls were murdered at a dance class in July 2024, is hearing evidence on how the risk from "violent-fixated individuals" can be managed.
asserted
risk → set → individuals
The hearing was told a Home Office unit had identified key issues with the challenge of non-ideological extreme violence (NIEV) ahead of a meeting with the cabinet secretary in June last year.
asserted
unit → tell → June
Four "high ambition responses" to the issues were set out by the Home Office but the inquiry heard all of these would require more money to be delivered.
asserted
all → set → money
Alice da Silva Aguiar, nine, Bebe King, six, and Elsie Dot Stancombe, seven, were killed by then 17-year-old Axel Rudakubana at the Taylor Swift-themed dance class, while 23 other children suffered physical or psychological injuries.
asserted
children → kill → injuries
The issues, set out in a report, included that there was limited evidence on the scale and scope of the problem of NIEV; that multi-agency frameworks were not adequate for managing cases; there was uncertainty about effective interventions and there was no clear ownership across law enforcement.
asserted
frameworks → set → enforcement
The unit also reported that the online environment was "increasingly acting as an accelerant and enabler of NIEV".
asserted
environment → report → NIEV
Jonathan Emmett, from the Home Office, told the inquiry: "The intent behind putting any note of that type together, and that note specifically, is absolutely to get at the strategic issues and not to shy away from them in any sense."
asserted
note → tell → sense
The Home Office's four "high ambition responses" to the issues included proposing a "serious and sustained effort" to reduce the risk in the online environment.
asserted
responses → include → environment
Prevention partnerships to reduce the pool of extreme violence risk were also listed, along with a national prevention gateway backed by effective multi-agency systems, and strengthening the anti-terror programme Prevent to handle the "sustained surge and broader range of referrals".
asserted
partnerships → reduce → referrals
Details of what the responses would involve were redacted in the copy of the report shown to the inquiry.
asserted
responses → involve → inquiry
The inquiry was told the Home Office, in anticipation of a multi-year spending review in June 2025, recognised that work would instead need to focus on "cost-neutral improvements" in the short term.
asserted
work → tell → term
Counsel to the inquiry Nicholas Moss KC said: "It does seem on the face of the record that what were described as 'high ambition responses' were deliberately not taken forward at this time because of the limitations of funding in the then cycle of the spending review?
asserted
described → say → review
Emmett replied: "Yes, that's correct."
asserted
that → reply → ?
Moss KC quoted former prime minister Sir Keir Starmer's statement following the conviction of Axel Rudakubana for carrying out the attack, in which Sir Keir said there were questions about the accountability of the Whitehall and Westminster system and that: "Southport must be a line in the sand."
asserted
Southport → quote → sand
Moss KC said: "It might be said by some outside observers that sentiment doesn't sit entirely comfortably with an acceptance that the spending review meant that high ambition responses would need to be, at least for the moment, put on hold?"
Emmett said part of the context for the decision-making was that it was understood the inquiry would be making its own strategic recommendations in due course.
The inquiry also heard a separate Home Office review in May last year, which looked at how violence-fixated individuals were managed, found a "confused picture", with inconsistencies in implementation and a lack of understanding of the behaviours and profile of the cohort.
uncertain
individuals → say → cohort
The report found the system ran the risk of "allowing cases to fall between the cracks".
asserted
cases → find → cracks
Moss KC said it was a "somewhat bleak but candid assessment of the scale of the problem", which Emmett agreed with.
asserted
Emmett → say → which
The Southport Inquiry began formally on 7 April 2025 to examine the overall timeline of the killer's history and interactions with various public bodies.
asserted
Inquiry → begin → bodies
The first phase of the inquiry found the attack "could and should have been prevented".
Rudakubana was handed a 52-year minimum prison sentence at Liverpool Crown Court in January 2025.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Merseyside on Sounds and follow BBC Merseyside on Facebook, external, X, external, and Instagram, external.
uncertain
Rudakubana → find → Facebook
You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
asserted
You → send → 2230
The Aporia
