Political strategist on how Trump's personal grievances could affect the GOP
NPR's Steve Inskeep speaks with political strategist and former senior Republican congressional adviser Rina Shah about how President Trump's personal grievances and projects are affecting the chances of GOP candidates in the upcoming election.
uncertain
grievances → affect → election
MICHEL MARTIN, HOST:
Rina Shah has been listening with us.
asserted
Shah → listen → us
So Mara mentioned the president's complaints, and in some cases, moves against people like Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, Federal Reserve governor Lisa Cook, the media, the government of Norway.
asserted
Mara → mention → Norway
Is - does any of that motivate voters at this point, either in his base or independents?
asserted
any → motivate → base
Well, I think it's really important to see what this really is.
asserted
this → think → ?
The diesel deal and the energy ceasefire announcement, I believe, are less about immediate relief and more about creating a permission structure for Republican candidates.
asserted
I → believe → candidates
The volumes are really too small to meaningfully move prices before November 3.
asserted
volumes → move → November
I think most analysts are saying that plainly, and most of us kind of get that.
asserted
most → think → that
But the move lets candidates say that the president is trying something on cost instead of doing nothing.
asserted
president → let → nothing
The risk is that Zelenskyy's criticism and then the lack of clear details on the ceasefire turn it into another foreign policy story that down-ballot Republicans then have to explain rather than use.
MARTIN:
asserted
Republicans → turn → that
But also it doesn't work.
asserted
it → work → ?
It doesn't seem to be working.
asserted
It → seem → ?
He's saying one thing, and the facts prove to be otherwise.
asserted
facts → say → thing
And to that end, you know, the president's defending - he's aggressively defended his decision to launch trade wars with much of the world, his military war with Iran.
asserted
he → know → Iran
Those are both things that have raised prices for Americans.
asserted
that → raise → Americans
The latest NPR/PBS News/Marist poll indicates that independent voters favor Democrats by 19 points on the economy.
asserted
voters → indicate → economy
So the question is, you're saying, even if it creates a permission structure, does that - is that enough?
asserted
that → say → that
Well, look, let's look at the broader midterm picture here.
asserted
's → look → picture
Trump is running the same play he always has - make every race about himself and then bet that his base's intensity outweighs his approval numbers, which we know are pretty dismal.
asserted
we → run → numbers
The difference this cycle is that the grievances that are driving a lot of the White House's agenda - which are media fights, the Department of Justice's action against people from the first term, his personal score-settling - those are more self-generated than they were in 2016 or '18.
asserted
they → drive → 2016
Back then, a larger share of what he amplified tracked the existing voter frustration.
asserted
he → amplify → frustration
Now more of it originates from inside the administration, and it's getting projected outward, and that really changes the utility for candidates.
asserted
that → originate → candidates
It motivates the core base, but it doesn't give swing voters a new reason to show up when their main concern is still the price of diesel and groceries.
asserted
concern → motivate → diesel
But I'd be remiss if I didn't mention here the practical problem for Republicans in these next three weeks, and it's that there is not a clean off-ramp for them.
asserted
it → mention → them
Candidates in really tight races would prefer a more narrow message on things like border enforcement and costs, and the White House is not structured at all to deliver that.
asserted
House → prefer → that
Trump treats the midterms as an extension of his own presidency rather than a set of local races, which is really unusual, even by our modern standards.
asserted
which → treat → standards
Presidents have always campaigned, but they have rarely, rarely made themselves the constant central character this late while the party is trailing on the economy.
asserted
party → campaign → economy
And what that does is forces candidates to either fully nationalize their races or spend time creating distance, and neither of which is ideal with three weeks left.
asserted
neither → force → weeks
So if the president can't or won't focus his message on what voters care about right now, and if there doesn't seem to be anybody in the president's circle who can get him to do that
asserted
him → focus → that
, is there anything that congressional candidates can do?
asserted
candidates → do → that
Look, three weeks out, it's very hard for anyone to redirect him.
asserted
anyone → look → him
He sets the agenda.
asserted
He → set → agenda
The people closest to him can sometimes influence timing or emphasis on a particular issue like prices, but they rarely change his overall focus or stop him from going where he wants to go.
asserted
he → influence → him
At this point in the midterm cycle, I think the political reality of the map and the polls can sometimes force a more narrow message.
asserted
reality → think → message
But that's really different, again, from someone inside Trump world circle - they're successfully shifting him.
asserted
they → shift → him
I would say this - look, if the polls are right and Republicans are trailing on the broad economy or the cost-of-living question, the other issues that can still drive their turnout are the border and public safety.
asserted
that → say → turnout
Those have consistently been stronger for Republicans in recent cycles, and they give candidates a concrete contrast - things like enforcement, resources and results, versus what they argue has been a more permissive Democratic policy.
asserted
they → give → enforcement
OK, before we let you go through...
asserted
you → let → ?
Republicans are outspending Democrats in these final weeks.
asserted
Republicans → outspende → weeks
Do they have - is that enough to erase some of these Democratic advantages that we're seeing in the polls?
asserted
we → have → polls
…and 9 more, not listed.
The Aporia
