Opposition Leader Basil Zempilas has challenged WA Labor state secretary Mark Reed to pay back a $6600 donation from homelessness and domestic violence charity Ruah.
asserted
Zempilas → challenge → charity
Ruah Community Services disclosed the “gift” to WA Labor last month, which the party confirmed was the ticket price to attend one of its fundraising events.
asserted
party → disclose → events
More than $38 million of Ruah’s $45 million in revenue in 2024-25 came from grants, including from the WA government.
asserted
million → come → government
The donation drew the ire of the opposition and the Greens, which both questioned why a charity would spend crucial funding to pay for access to government ministers through the Labor events.
asserted
charity → draw → events
Zempilas called on Labor to pay the money back.
asserted
Zempilas → call → money
“I am stunned that there has been a donation go from Ruah to the WA Labor Party.
asserted
donation → stun → Party
But I am even more staggered that the WA Labor Party has accepted that money from a charitable organisation,” he said.
asserted
he → accept → organisation
“Have they totally lost their moral fibre?
asserted
they → lose → fibre
Are they totally bereft of any direction and knowing what is right and what is wrong?
asserted
what → know → direction
This is a charity, and they are somehow being asked to donate money to the WA Labor Party to have access.
asserted
they → ask → access
“I met with Shelter WA yesterday.
asserted
I → meet → WA
I didn’t charge them any money to come in and discuss the issues that are a priority for the social services sector, and I meet with a whole range of those in this community space all the time.
asserted
I → charge → space
It is shameful that WA Labor has accepted money from a charity.
asserted
Labor → accept → charity
“The first thing Mark Reed should do today is refund that money to Ruah ...
asserted
Reed → do → Ruah
how many meals could it provide for those that Ruah provide homelessness services for?
uncertain
Ruah → provide → services
How much shelter could it help accommodate?
uncertain
it → help → shelter
The Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission warns against donating to political parties and attending political fundraising events “because the charity will run the risk of being found to have a purpose of supporting a particular candidate or party.”
asserted
charity → warn → candidate
Ruah was approached for comment, but chief executive Debra Zanella previously told The West Australian the donation was appropriately disclosed.
asserted
donation → approach → Australian
“The payment indicated represented a purchase of tickets to an event, where we advocated for the clients and communities we serve,” Zanella said.
asserted
Zanella → indicate → clients
Reed did not respond to questions about Zempilas’ challenge to pay back the money.
asserted
Reed → respond → money
He said the party’s schedule of events was open to the full spectrum of businesses and entities from across WA and interstate.
asserted
schedule → say → WA
“WA Labor complies with the WAEC’s disclosure requirements,” he said.
asserted
he → comply → requirements
Ruah was at the centre of a political fight between the Cook Government and Zempilas in his previous role as Perth lord mayor, when the City of Perth shut its women’s shelter in East Perth in 2023 and the charity attempted to open a new centre in Northbridge.
asserted
charity → shut → Northbridge
Ruah received $10.7 million in the May budget for crisis accommodation.
uncertain
Ruah → receive → accommodation
Planning Minister and Perth MP John Carey defended charities paying to attend Labor fundraisers, saying when he worked for Pew Charitable Trusts before entering politics, he attended a Liberal business forum with former premier Colin Barnett.
asserted
he → defend → Barnett
“Ultimately, that is a decision for each of those organisations,” he said.
asserted
he → say → organisations
“I understand why Basil is being so hyper about this, he really dislikes Ruah.
asserted
he → understand → Ruah
He shut down the women’s shelter.
asserted
He → shut → shelter
“He was humiliated as part of that, and quite frankly, he has an ideological hatred of Ruah.”
asserted
he → humiliate → Ruah
The Aporia
