In short:
The Greens say a "loophole" for private school fees is a sticking point in Labor's proposed trust laws.
asserted
loophole → say → laws
Jim Chalmers will introduce legislation for the 30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts on Wednesday, amid stiff business opposition.
asserted
Chalmers → introduce → opposition
Labor requires the support of the Greens in the Senate to pass the tax hike, given that the Coalition is opposed.
asserted
Coalition → require → hike
Parents who pay private school fees from their trust funds could escape Labor's proposed trust tax, in what the Greens say is a "loophole" that must be closed.
uncertain
that → pay → tax
Treasurer Jim Chalmers will today unveil a bill to impose the 30 per cent minimum tax on some trusts.
asserted
Chalmers → unveil → trusts
The budget proposal has enraged the business lobby and unnerved Labor backbenchers anxious about small business hostility.
asserted
proposal → enrage → hostility
The Greens, whose votes are required in the Senate, have the opposite concern.
asserted
votes → require → concern
On Tuesday, the party called for a Senate inquiry into the bill, saying an early draft was "watered down" and the proposal would not get a "free pass".
asserted
proposal → call → pass
The ABC can reveal the Greens' main concern is an exemption for money paid from trusts to charities, non-profits and other tax-exempt entities, including private schools.
asserted
concern → reveal → schools
"People who are wealthy enough to set up trusts should not get a tax break to pay for private school fees when this option is denied to people who can't afford expensive accountants," Greens economic spokesperson Nick McKim told the ABC.
asserted
McKim → set → ABC
"The treasurer needs to knock this out of the legislation."
In a draft proposal last month, the government indicated it would cap the amount of exempt money each year, but that cap has not yet been set.
asserted
cap → need → money
The proposal does not change the tax treatment of private schools, since this avenue already exists.
asserted
avenue → change → schools
But by carving charitable payments out from the new higher rate of tax, the Greens will argue this makes the avenue more attractive.
asserted
avenue → carve → tax
"There is far too much leniency," Senator McKim said.
asserted
McKim → be → ?
"Labor is just trying to funnel ever-increasing revenues into the private education system when public schools are being starved of funds.
asserted
schools → try → funds
"
Chalmers beleaguered on two fronts
Mr Chalmers says the proposal is a crackdown on those who use trust funds as a vehicle to reduce their tax bills.
asserted
who → say → bills
The 30 per cent minimum tax applies only to so-called "discretionary" trusts, a term the tax office uses to identify trust structures that give their owners the flexibility to shift their money into the names of family members, holding companies, or others.
asserted
that → apply → members
Tax experts say these complicated structures allow a minority of very wealthy, highly motivated people to achieve dramatic reductions in the tax they pay.
asserted
they → say → tax
The government expects to raise $4.5 billion from the tax in its first year of operation.
asserted
government → expect → operation
But business lobbies and the opposition have argued discretionary trusts are used for a range of legitimate purposes, including by small business owners.
asserted
trusts → argue → owners
The government has outlined several exemptions, including for family farms that are placed within trusts, charities that operate as trusts, and trusts that are set up to manage deceased estates.
asserted
that → outline → estates
But Andrew McKellar, chief executive of the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, said the tax still sent "the wrong message" and targeted business unfairly.
asserted
tax → say → business
"We urge all members of parliament to … listen to the views of those small businesses who will be affected: small and medium-sized home builders, family pharmacies, newsagents, small retailers, restaurants and cafes," he said on Tuesday.
asserted
he → urge → Tuesday
The government estimates that 350,000 active small businesses — roughly one in six — used discretionary trusts in 2022-23, the last year of available data.
asserted
businesses → estimate → data
Treasury analysis suggests 140,000 of those would not need to pay the new tax.
uncertain
140,000 → suggest → tax
Others will get government assistance to restructure their affairs, although there remains concern that those who restructure their businesses as companies would have to pay state and territory stamp duties in the process.
asserted
who → get → process
The concerns have been echoed by some Labor backbenchers, with several questions put to Mr Chalmers about the bill's consequences in a Tuesday Labor caucus meeting.
Summarising the angst, one Labor backbencher told the ABC they were "not happy about these compounding attacks on small business".
From little holes, big holes grow
The government is wary about business hostility and has added further exemptions since May to address its concerns.
uncertain
government → echo → concerns
The exemption for trust money given to charities, schools and sports clubs was one such concession.
asserted
exemption → give → charities
But Dale Boccabella, an associate professor of accounting and tax at the University of New South Wales, warned that every concession risked creating unintended loopholes, especially given trust laws are notoriously complex.
asserted
laws → warn → loopholes
"The reality is that a small minority of downtown lawyers and accountants sniff a little opening and they will make it into a big opening.
asserted
they → sniff → opening
Whether we like it or not, that's the history in this area."
asserted
that → like → area
Mr Boccabella said it was possible the law could be drafted with so-called "integrity provisions" to stamp out payments such as school fees if the parliament considers that they are not in the spirit of the law, adding that the Greens' concern was worth probing.
uncertain
concern → say → law
"I know why people would be concerned.
asserted
people → know → ?
We've got a long history in Australia, going back to the 1970s, where people were making donations to church-run schools, and it was well known that the quid pro quo was a reduction in your school fees," he said.
asserted
he → get → fees
The High Court has tried to clamp down on that practice in the past, ruling that "gifts" to charities for tax purposes cannot come with strings attached.
asserted
gifts → try → strings
But even where these precedents exist, Mr Boccabella said enforcing them was a challenge for the ATO.
asserted
enforcing → exist → ATO
"It's great having a rule, but you've got to enforce it on a case-by-case basis, and the ATO doesn't have the resources to administer even our current rules for trusts on a meaningful scale.
asserted
ATO → have → scale
They just cannot do it," he said.
asserted
he → do → it
Mr Boccabella said his biggest concern with the draft laws was that people who choose to restructure from a trust into a company could still achieve much of the same discretion and could still substantially reduce their tax.
uncertain
who → say → tax
"I think there's a case to be really blunt and really prescriptive …
asserted
I → think → ?
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
