Industry Minister Mélanie Joly is expected to speak Wednesday afternoon — her first public appearance since Stelco answered Ottawa’s legal threat over layoffs of up to 500 workers.
asserted
Stelco → expect → workers
Stelco’s letter, obtained by Global News, was dated Oct. 9 in response to one sent by Joly on Oct. 5, in which she gave the company an ultimatum and five days to respond.
asserted
she → obtain → ultimatum
Joly’s letter to the company expressed “extreme disappointment” and claimed the layoffs constitute a direct breach of the company’s commitments under the Investment Canada Act.
asserted
layoffs → express → Act
Stelco maintained in its response that it hasn’t done anything wrong and claims the accusations from the federal government are “false.”
The Ontario-based steel manufacturer announced last month that pressure from U.S. tariffs forced it to concentrate steel production at its Lake Erie Works plant in Haldimand, and halt production at its plant in Hamilton.
uncertain
pressure → maintain → Hamilton
Although the company said some of those workers would be offered positions at the Haldimand facility, hundreds are still expected to be out of work.
asserted
hundreds → say → work
U.S. President Donald Trump levied tariffs on steel products from Canada of up to 50 per cent under its Section 232 duties about a year-and-a-half ago, with other products like aluminum and autos also facing tariffs.
asserted
products → levy → tariffs
Here’s where things stand.
asserted
things → ’ → ?
What is Ottawa saying?
asserted
Ottawa → say → What
Joly claimed in her letter to Stelco on Oct. 5 that the market dynamics surrounding Trump’s tariff policies do not excuse Stelco from its commitments under the Investment Canada Act, and that the federal government would be using the “full force of the law” if those jobs are not preserved.
asserted
jobs → claim → law
Joly told reporters last week that the chief executive of U.S.-based Cleveland-Cliffs, which acquired Stelco in 2024, has supported steel tariffs and therefore cannot characterize the company’s plan to lay off up to 500 workers due to tariffs and market pressures as beyond its control.
asserted
which → tell → control
“He’s in favor of these U.S. tariffs against steel,” she said, referring to Cleveland-Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves’ public support of American steel tariffs.
asserted
she → ’ → tariffs
“They cannot say that this is now an act of God or force majeure.”
asserted
this → say → God
The government says Cleveland-Cliffs made a series of commitments when it acquired the Ontario steelmaker, including preserving jobs and the Stelco name, maintaining and expanding its Canadian operations, generating cost savings, broadening its customer base and supporting unionized steel jobs.
asserted
it → say → jobs
In a release from 2024, Cleveland-Cliffs announced the agreed acquisition of Stelco and said they would “maintain significant employment levels in Canada and Canadian representation on the management team.”
asserted
they → announce → team
Business lawyer Nassira El Hadri said the government appears to have moved past asking Cleveland-Cliffs to justify the layoffs, and is also asking for a plan outlining how it will comply with all of its undertakings.
asserted
it → say → undertakings
“They are not asking for an explanation,” said El Hadri, founder of Hadri Law in Toronto.
asserted
Hadri → ask → Toronto
“They’re saying, ‘You have to give us a plan on how you are going to comply.’
asserted
you → say → plan
“These undertakings are not goodwill gestures,” El Hadri said.
asserted
Hadri → say → ?
“They are binding.”
asserted
They → bind → ?
If the company responds by simply reiterating that the layoffs are necessary because of U.S. tariffs, she said the dispute could end up in court.
uncertain
dispute → respond → court
According to the federal government, the binding undertakings in the agreement from 2024 include:
- To respect Stelco’s historic brand by carrying on operations under the name, “Stelco, a Cleveland-Cliffs Company”;
- To maintain Stelco’s head office in Hamilton, with responsibility for Stelco’s day-to-day operations;
- To continue to employ at least the same number of unionized employees and the vast majority of non-unionized employees as were employed when the transaction was announced;
- To honour all existing collective bargaining agreements and Stelco’s employee benefit and pension commitments;
- To make significant capital and research and development expenditures in support of Stelco’s operations; and
- To ensure Stelco’s Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emission intensity do not increase and continue to be at least 25 per cent below the global average for integrated steel mills.
Stelco's claims
Stelco’s letter in response to Joly from Oct. 9 was authored by Stelco’s president, Paul Simon.
According to the seven-page letter, exports of cold-rolled and coated steel to the United States have plunged 58 per cent from pre-trade-war levels as foreign imports continue to undercut Canadian-made steel.
uncertain
imports → accord → steel
Simon also claimed in the letter that the company was open and transparent with the federal government for several months about its struggles.
asserted
company → claim → struggles
“Our early September meetings with several senior government officials, including representatives from your office, led Stelco to believe that the government understood the market realities confronting Stelco’s Hamilton Works finishing lines,” the letter said.
asserted
letter → include → lines
“Stelco submitted its annual report confirming its compliance with the employment undertakings in November 2025.
asserted
Stelco → submit → November
That report highlighted that Stelco was facing significant challenges due to the unforeseen consequences stemming from unprecedented U.S. tariffs and Canada’s failure to advance an effective ‘Fortress North America’ trade regime.”
asserted
Stelco → highlight → regime
“Your representation that Stelco’s planned layoffs cause it to breach its undertakings is false as the undertakings do not stipulate a commitment to avoid layoffs.”
asserted
undertakings → plan → layoffs
In the letter, Simon described an industry upended by U.S. tariffs, weakening demand and continued foreign steel imports.
asserted
Simon → describe → tariffs
“Stelco cannot continue to produce cold-rolled and coated steel products without incurring significant losses that are not sustainable,” Simon said in the letter.
asserted
Simon → continue → letter
“As such, we will continue with the idling of Hamilton Works.”
asserted
we → continue → Works
What happens next?
asserted
What → happen → ?
Over the weekend, Joly issued a statement in a social media post acknowledging she had received the letter from Stelco, and maintained the federal government’s stance.
asserted
she → issue → stance
“The Government of Canada continues to expect Stelco to meet its legally binding commitments to employees.
asserted
Stelco → continue → employees
These commitments were agreed upon as undertakings under the Investment Canada Act and do not cease to apply because of changing business strategy or market conditions,” said Joly in the statement.
asserted
Joly → agree → statement
“As our legal team reviews the Stelco letter, all options are on the table.”
asserted
options → review → table
The Aporia
