Not long after President Donald Trump offered to bribe voters to back Republicans in this year's midterm elections, Vice President J.D. Vance was asked about the idea by Fox News' Bret Baier.
asserted
Vance → offer → Baier
Vance's response is, in many ways, more important than Trump's ridiculous pitch—that he would send $5,000 checks to every adult citizen of the U.S. if the GOP retains control of Congress in November.
asserted
GOP → send → November
Baier asked Vance the obvious question: How does the administration plan to pay for such a scheme, which would cost an estimated $1.3 trillion?
asserted
which → ask → trillion
"We're taking in an extraordinary amount of revenue," said Vance.
asserted
Vance → take → revenue
"What the president is saying is: 'If you keep it going…if you keep us in power and allow us to continue to do these things, then you're going to share in some of the benefit of this incredible wealth that we are creating in the United States of America.'
asserted
we → say → America
"
As a practical matter, it is simply false for the vice president to suggest that tariffs will fund this expensive promise.
asserted
tariffs → suggest → promise
Revenue from tariffs, which are really just taxes on Americans, will not come close to covering this proposed expenditure.
asserted
which → come → expenditure
In fact, tariff revenue has been in negative territory in recent months as the Trump administration issues refunds for the illegal tariffs it levied last year.
asserted
it → issue → tariffs
(There are several other practical hurdles too, like the fact that the federal government is already $40 trillion in debt and the likelihood that stimulus spending on this scale would cause more inflation, as Reason's Liz Wolfe explained this morning.)
What's more interesting is Vance's suggestion that those checks reflect "this incredible wealth that we are creating."
asserted
we → be → that
Government doesn't create wealth, of course.
asserted
Government → create → course
All it can do is redistribute money from one person to another—which is exactly what Trump is proposing.
asserted
Trump → do → what
Opposing those kinds of schemes used to be a core tenet of conservative politics.
asserted
Opposing → oppose → politics
That Vance is willing to play ball with such a ridiculous, unconservative, fiscally irresponsible idea is telling.
asserted
is → play → idea
After all, the vice president likes to position himself as a serious, thoughtful critic of the political and economic status quo.
asserted
president → like → quo
His supporters see him as the heir apparent to Trump—the guy with the political and policy chops to make this populist movement stick and to redefine the Republican Party and the conservative movement for the next generation.
asserted
movement → see → generation
Even amid Wednesday night's parade of absurdity, longtime Vance cheerleader Rod Dreher condemned Trump's bribe idea and wrote that he is "ready for [Trump] to go away and let JD be president, and focus on the economy."
But how can that notion of Vance be squared with vice president throwing his support behind a recklessly impractical, utterly unprincipled (and possibly illegal) plan to bribe voters?
Focus on the economy?
uncertain
president → condemn → economy
Promising to drop free money out of government helicopters is the stuff of outlandish socialist caricatures.
asserted
Promising → promise → caricatures
It is, as National Review's Charles Cooke put it, "a reckless, shapeless, irritable spasm, divorced from the nature and purpose of our government and from the Constitution that created it.
asserted
that → put → it
The alternative, of course, is that Vance knows this is a silly, unworkable idea.
asserted
this → know → course
But that means he just plainly lied to Baier, Fox News, and the American people.
asserted
he → mean → Baier
This entire incident exposes how completely out of ideas the entire Trump political project is.
asserted
project → expose → ideas
The president promised that he would make life more affordable and that tariffs would deliver a "golden age" for Americans, but the reality has fallen well short.
asserted
reality → promise → Americans
Prices are still rising uncomfortably fast—data released this morning shows that wholesale prices rose by 0.4 percent in August and are up 5.4 percent over the past year.
asserted
prices → rise → year
The tariffs and Trump's foolish, endless war with Iran are contributing to that.
asserted
tariffs → contribute → that
Now, the president is literally promising to throw money at the problem, and Vance is dutifully playing along.
asserted
Vance → promise → problem
This is the inevitable end of all populist movements, which begin by promising easy solutions to complex problems and eventually collapse when those "solutions" are revealed to be grifts or oversimplifications.
asserted
solutions → begin → problems
Hey, remember when everyone was going to get a DOGE dividend check?
asserted
everyone → remember → check
Vance is supposed to be the guy with the real answers, but it is becoming obvious that there is no there there.
asserted
it → suppose → answers
If you're unwilling to say that nakedly bribing Americans with their own money is a bad idea, you're not fit for public office.
asserted
you → say → office
(And for that reason, every Republican running in the midterms ought to be asked about this.)
asserted
Republican → run → this
Trumpism is out of ideas, and soon it is likely to be out of power—no matter what ridiculous promises the president makes along the way.
asserted
president → make → way
The Aporia
