A string of drone attacks on at least seven cargo vessels in the Black Sea this month, off the coasts of NATO members Romania and Bulgaria, has some members of the alliance wondering if Russian President Vladimir Putin is seeking escalation to test their support for Ukraine in its war against Moscow’s full-scale invasion.
asserted
Putin → have → invasion
The attacks in the two countries’ exclusive economic zones threaten a global shipping route and have left two people dead, with at least 25 still missing.
asserted
25 → threaten → people
They also run the risk of drawing other countries directly into the war for Ukraine.
asserted
They → run → Ukraine
Throughout the war, Russia has repeatedly bombarded Ukraine’s Black Sea and Danube river ports, leaving Kyiv increasingly reliant on alternative routes to get its grain exports to markets in Africa and the Middle East.
asserted
Russia → bombard → Africa
Russian drones have repeatedly violated Romanian airspace near some of Ukraine’s Danube ports.
asserted
drones → violate → ports
In the latest incidents, fires broke out on two ships struck by drones Wednesday and Thursday, one in Romania’s territorial waters.
asserted
fires → break → waters
Nicusor Dan said Thursday in Brussels that “two drones” had hit the vessels but did not say whose drones they were.
asserted
they → say → vessels
“There will be a reaction from the Romanian state,” he warned.
asserted
he → warn → state
Increasingly, the suspicion falls on Russia.
asserted
suspicion → fall → Russia
“There is no logic in Ukraine attacking its own ships and crews, given that the outcome of all these attacks favors Russia — and indeed, the logic points in that direction,” Bulgarian Prime Minister Rumen Radev told his country’s Parliament.
asserted
Radev → be → Parliament
“The problem is that we cannot prove it.”
asserted
we → prove → it
Multiple vessels struck by drones in October
The San Marino-flagged Wine Trader, a chemical tanker traveling from Tunisia to Romania, was struck by a drone Thursday and caught fire.
asserted
Trader → strike → fire
Five crew members were rescued but another seven are missing.
asserted
seven → rescue → ?
On Wednesday, a drone strike and fire were reported on the Comoros-flagged Yara J, a chemical and oil tanker traveling from Turkey to Romania.
asserted
strike → report → Romania
Romania’s acting Defense Minister Radu Miruta said an investigation was underway.
asserted
investigation → act → ?
On Tuesday, two ships were struck by drones off Bulgaria’s coast.
asserted
ships → strike → coast
Rescuers evacuated all 15 crew members from the Ukraine-operated Chelsea 3, sailing under a Maltese flag, but 11 crew from the Guinea-Bissau-flagged HS Dignity are still missing.
asserted
crew → evacuate → Dignity
The crew of the Chelsea 3 reported the ship’s deck and hull were hit by three aerial drones.
asserted
deck → report → drones
Earlier this month, sea and aerial drones attacked two other commercial vessels in Bulgaria’s exclusive economic zone.
asserted
drones → attack → zone
A Togo-flagged ship sank with no sign of the 12 sailors reported on board, while a Bulgarian ferry evacuated 18 crew members from a Palau-flagged vessel that was damaged.
asserted
that → flag → vessel
A day earlier, a Turkish-owned cargo ship carrying corn caught fire following a drone attack and later sank off the coast of Romania.
asserted
ship → own → Romania
Two people died and 11 crew members were rescued.
asserted
members → die → ?
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy described the attack as “a horrific strike by two Russian drones on a civilian vessel” in neutral waters.
asserted
Zelenskyy → describe → waters
Russia’s ambassador in Sofia, Bulgaria, said she didn’t have any information from the Russian defense ministry.
asserted
she → say → ministry
NATO’s defense clause under scrutiny
NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte said on X on Thursday that he met Radev and Dan to discuss security in the Black Sea and “the latest attacks on commercial shipping.”
asserted
he → say → shipping
“NATO has strengthened our posture along the eastern flank including with increasing counter-drone capabilities,” he said.
asserted
he → strengthen → capabilities
“NATO will continue to work closely with our Allies in the Black Sea, adjusting our deterrence and defense posture as needed.”
asserted
NATO → continue → posture
Article 5 of the NATO charter has a mutual defense guarantee — an attack on one is an attack on all — but Romanian defense analyst Radu Tudor said it was uncertain as to whether it covers many of the Black Sea drone strikes because they occurred in the alliance members’ exclusive economic zones.
“It’s a matter of discussion whether the exclusive economic zone is included in the Article 5-type reaction or not,” he said.
asserted
he → have → reaction
“And it seems that until now, it isn’t — which raised a lot of questions.”
asserted
which → seem → questions
NATO has been too slow to respond in the Black Sea, he argued.
asserted
he → respond → Sea
“Tens of incidents are happening and Russia is getting closer to NATO borders.
asserted
Russia → happen → borders
Words are not enough,” Tudor said.
asserted
Tudor → say → ?
A growing threat
The Black Sea drone incidents in October are just the latest in a long string of drone airspace incursions to rock Romania and other NATO members since Moscow launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
asserted
Moscow → grow → Ukraine
While most have come from Russia, Ukrainian drones have also crossed borders.
asserted
drones → come → borders
In August, Romania deployed two F-16 fighter jets to destroy a naval drone that was reportedly carrying explosives and was spotted near a major Black Sea gas project, a decision that Acting Defense Minister Miruta said was made to “protect the lives of the several hundred people” working on the gas platform.
uncertain
Miruta → deploy → platform
A source in Romania’s defense sector, who was not authorized to speak publicly about the incidents, told The Associated Press that the attacks are designed to hurt Ukraine economically and that “Romania is not the target right now.”
asserted
Romania → authorize → Ukraine
“All summer we’ve been hunting all kinds of (drone) debris, water drones, sea drones, air drones, debris in the water, on the beaches,” they said.
asserted
they → hunt → beaches
“If this continues … someone should do something about that.”
asserted
someone → continue → that
Potential calls for an escort corridor
The source added they have heard Turkey “would like to summon all the riparian (Black Sea) states to plan a mission to escort these convoys” through a militarized safe corridor.
asserted
Turkey → add → corridor
“I’m not sure about Turkish, but our Romanian vessels don’t have anti-air defense systems to protect against drones,” they said.
asserted
they → ’m → drones
…and 15 more, not listed.
The Aporia
