Attorneys for Representative Ilhan Omar have accused the Justice Department of violating a magistrate judge's order by failing to follow certain protocols designed to safeguard her constitutional interests as a member of Congress during
in Washington, D.C.In the Oct. 16 letter
asserted
Attorneys → accuse → letter
, Omar's attorneys Amy Jeffress and Joshua Matz asked the government to immediately return the congresswoman's property, and they also demanded all video and audio recordings of the search be preserved.
asserted
recordings → ask → search
"This vindictive, retributive, and politically motivated criminal investigation into one of the President's chief congressional critics violates Representative Omar's constitutional rights and threatens the separation of powers," they wrote in the letter, which was reviewed by CBS News.
asserted
which → violate → News
In a statement, a Justice Department spokesperson disputed the claims in the letter, saying it was "riddled with false allegations and inaccuracies."
"Our attorneys and law enforcement partners complied with all court orders and legal obligations, as they always do," the spokesperson said.
uncertain
spokesperson → dispute → orders
"Leaking a letter to the press right after sending it is not good faith.
asserted
Leaking → leak → it
Agents from the Homeland Security Investigations executed a search warrant at Omar's home on Monday, as part of a sprawling criminal investigation into her family's history for evidence of possible fraud and false statements in their immigration paperwork.
asserted
Agents → execute → paperwork
Her personal cellphone was among the materials seized in the search, CBS News
, and grand jury subpoenas were also issued just days before the search to some of Omar's family members.
asserted
subpoenas → seize → members
The search warrant was first presented to a magistrate judge in U.S. District Court about a week before it was executed.
asserted
it → present → Court
Prosecutors and the judge engaged in a lengthy back-and-forth, after the judge raised concerns that the search warrant failed to incorporate any protocols to protect Omar's legislative privileges under the Constitution's speech and debate clause, CBS News previously reported.
asserted
News → engage → clause
Those protections stem from the 2007 United States v. Rayburn House Office Building D.C. Circuit Court case, which held that in a criminal investigation of a sitting member of Congress, the executive branch can't review information that is seized in a search without allowing that member to first screen it for legislative privilege.
asserted
member → stem → privilege
Initially, prosecutors tried to argue the case shouldn't apply because the search was being carried out at Omar's home, and not at her congressional office, CBS News previously reported.
asserted
News → try → office
In the letter to the Justice Department, Omar's lawyers alleged several key requirements imposed by the judge had been violated.
asserted
requirements → allege → judge
HSI agents, for example, were supposed to notify both Omar and the House of Representatives Office of General Counsel of the execution of the search warrant — a step Omar's lawyers say never took place.
asserted
lawyers → suppose → place
Agents also allegedly prevented her from contacting her attorney for more than an hour after the search started, the letter alleges, even though she and her counsel were supposed to be presented with a copy of the search warrant at the outset.
uncertain
she → prevent → outset
The timing of the search warrant and issuance of grand jury subpoenas in the case have raised eyebrows among many veteran former prosecutors.
asserted
timing → raise → prosecutors
Such overt investigative steps involving a sitting member of Congress so close to an election appear to run afoul of internal Justice Department guidelines, which state that prosecutors and agents should avoid taking overt investigative steps that could affect the outcome of an election or give one candidate an advantage or disadvantage.
uncertain
that → involve → advantage
Omar's lawyers also raised these same concerns in their letter to the department, saying: "Historically, the Department has refrained from this type of investigative activity so close to an election, so as to avoid even the appearance of politically motivated law enforcement actions.
asserted
Department → raise → actions
For the reasons given above, this search was neither justified nor lawful.
asserted
search → give → reasons
Mr. Trump has also made derogatory comments about her Somali heritage and her religion, and he has repeatedly accused her of immigration fraud.
asserted
he → make → fraud
"There is no legitimate basis for any suggestion that she has violated any law concerning her citizenship status," her attorneys wrote in the letter to DOJ, adding the search of her home "arose from a years-old, tired conspiracy theory concerning conduct stretching back decades."
asserted
search → violate → decades
Department of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin
about the nonpublic criminal investigation in a podcast on Friday, calling it a "strong case."In an interview with Andrew Kolvet, who hosts "The Charlie Kirk Show," Mullin volunteered that multiple warrants had been served on Monday, adding that a judge had authorized the enforcement action and investigators expected to present their case to a grand jury.
asserted
investigators → call → jury
It is unusual for federal officials to speak openly about ongoing criminal investigations beyond confirming a court-authorized search was conducted, in part due to due process protections and grand jury secrecy rules.
asserted
search → speak → protections
The Aporia
