The NRL will allow players to challenge the market value ascribed to them by head office in a move that could revive the PNG Chiefs’ pursuit of NSW and Canberra star Hudson Young.
uncertain
that → allow → NSW
The governing body initially placed a notional value of $1.1 million per season on Young, in line with the offer tabled by the Raiders to retain their gun back-rower.
asserted
body → govern → rower
That valuation helped placate existing clubs, who were concerned the Chiefs – armed with tax-free dollars – could seek to stretch their advantage even further.
uncertain
Chiefs → placate → advantage
Their offer of $900,000 a year would have given Young a huge increase in his take-home pay when compared with the taxable wages on offer at Canberra.
asserted
offer → give → Canberra
Under the NRL’s initial valuation, the Chiefs would have had to carry Young in their salary cap for $1.1 million, even if he accepted the $900,000 deal.
asserted
he → have → deal
The salary cap auditor subsequently revalued Young at $1 million, but the Chiefs are adamant that is still $100,000 more than they are willing to pay for a player coming off a serious Achilles injury, and at a time when other back-row options are available.
asserted
options → revalue → time
Young had been poised to tour the Chiefs’ facilities in Port Moresby before deciding whether to join the expansion franchise or remain at the Raiders.
asserted
Young → poise → Raiders
However, the Chiefs pulled their offer when the NRL signalled they would be required to pay “market value” for all of their recruits.
asserted
they → pull → recruits
Canberra, meanwhile, extended their offer from three years to four in a bid to take Young off the market.
asserted
Canberra → extend → market
Regardless, the NRL will accept submissions on behalf of any player who wants to challenge their market value.
asserted
who → accept → value
“The salary cap applies to everybody and requires the market value of a player,” said NRL executive chairman Peter V’landys.
asserted
V’landys → apply → player
“In saying that, we’ve discussed it with the RLPA – and we both agree – there can be exceptional circumstances.
asserted
we → say → RLPA
We will always look at exceptional circumstances.”
asserted
We → look → circumstances
On the one hand, the NRL wants to make sure the Chiefs don’t sign players for “unders”, a prospect raised by clubs concerned at the newcomers further stretching their tax-free advantage.
asserted
newcomers → want → advantage
The other consideration is if a player is prepared to accept less money from a club for other reasons, such as a family situation or the belief they are more likely to experience on-field success at a different destination.
asserted
they → accept → destination
That echoes a theme in recent Rugby League Players’ Association polls, which suggest money isn’t one of the biggest drivers for players changing clubs.
asserted
players → echo → clubs
V’landys said there had always been a provision for players who want to challenge their value.
asserted
who → say → value
“They can make submissions to the salary cap auditor, and we always look at the circumstances,” he said.
asserted
he → make → circumstances
“Let’s say a player wanted to be with his family or there are other specific reasons.
asserted
player → let → family
We just don’t want the salary cap rorted.
asserted
cap → want → ?
However, we know that at times there are exceptional circumstances, so we take those exceptional circumstances into account.
asserted
we → know → account
“We won’t have a situation where people manipulate the salary cap.
asserted
people → have → cap
The unfortunate thing is with the tax-free status of PNG, we have to be extra cautious with the market value of the players there.”
asserted
we → have → players
The development leaves the prospect of further representations being made on behalf of Young, which may result in a further reduction of his market value.
uncertain
which → leave → value
RLPA boss Clint Newton, in a meeting with V’landys, raised his own experience of rejoining Newcastle from Penrith in 2014 after the move was initially blocked by the NRL.
asserted
move → raise → NRL
He had wanted to return to the Knights despite then-coach Wayne Bennett making a much lower offer than the Panthers for his services, but the NRL initially frowned upon it before he contested its stance.
asserted
he → want → stance
Newton said he recognised the intent and purpose of market value figures but believes they can put unreasonable restraint on players’ freedom to decide where they want to play.
asserted
they → say → freedom
The RLPA had made a submission to the NRL outlining its concerns about the policy and was waiting to hear back, Newton said.
asserted
Newton → make → policy
“I certainly believe that if PNG want to pay him $900,000, that shouldn’t be stopped,” Newton said of the Young situation.
asserted
Newton → believe → situation
“I understand if something doesn’t smell right from an integrity perspective, but that’s not the case here.
asserted
that → understand → perspective
“I said to Peter, ‘I don’t want us to go down the legal path here, but my greatest concern is clubs are trying to put the genie back in the bottle’.
asserted
clubs → say → bottle
Everyone has been very aware of the tax-free money and no one batted an eyelid.
asserted
one → bat → eyelid
“Now it seems as though because PNG are doing well from a recruitment perspective, these things are being put up as roadblock.
asserted
things → seem → roadblock
“I’ve spoken to Hudson and [his manager] Sam Ayoub and met with Peter about it, and he’s committed to reviewing any submission that a player wants to make if there’s a challenge about market value.
asserted
player → speak → value
“It’s now resting with Sam Ayoub as to whether they want to make a submission to Peter.
asserted
they → rest → Peter
I’ve offered to be there with Hudson and Sam [in a meeting] with Peter to work through it.”
asserted
I → offer → it
V’landys added: “We have due process and natural justice with everything we do.
asserted
we → add → everything
Hudson will absolutely be given that.
asserted
Hudson → give → that
“The last person we want to affect is Hudson, I personally have a lot of time for him.
asserted
I → want → him
But we have to keep the salary cap objective.
asserted
we → have → cap
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
