The Islamabad High Court (IHC) on Monday disposed of a plea against the PTI’s planned long march and protest in the federal capital on Sept 27, directing the chief ministers of all provinces to ensure that no government resources or official machinery were used in this regard.
asserted
resources → dispose → regard
The PTI has announced a nationwide protest, including in Islamabad, on Sept 27 to demand the release of party founder Imran Khan and mobilise people for the supremacy of the Constitution.
asserted
PTI → announce → Constitution
A citizen, Waqas Ahmed, had challenged the planned move on the grounds that the protest could disrupt routine life, traffic and business activities in the federal capital.
uncertain
protest → challenge → capital
A larger bench, headed by IHC Chief Justice Sardar Muhammad Sarfraz Dogar and including Justice Muhammad Azam Khan and Justice Muhammad Asif, took up the plea.
asserted
bench → head → plea
The bench’s short order, which was announced in the court, said that no political party or its leadership had the “lawful right to occupy public roads, highways, interchanges, toll plazas and buildings in Islamabad that would obstruct in any manner access to educational institutions and medical facilities”.
asserted
that → announce → institutions
No political party or political leader had the right to obstruct the free movement of citizens, the order stated, adding that provincial governments must ensure that government resources were not used for any march, procession or rally.
asserted
resources → have → march
Chief ministers must ensure that public funds or government officials were not used for any protest, and official vehicles, machinery or other government equipment must not be used to facilitate any march, procession or rally, it said.
asserted
it → ensure → march
Moreover, no public servant should be compelled to participate in any march, procession or rally, the court ruled.
asserted
court → compel → march
Any person, public office holder who undertook any activity against these instructions should be deemed to have violated the Constitution, it said.
asserted
it → undertake → Constitution
The court directed the Islamabad administration and the interior ministry to ensure protection of citizens’ constitutional rights, and the chief secretaries and provincial police chiefs to ensure implementation of court directives.
asserted
secretaries → direct → directives
The interior secretary and Islamabad chief commissioner and inspector general were directed to ensure compliance with court orders.
asserted
secretary → direct → orders
The bench had reserved its verdict on the plea earlier in the day after the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa police chief assured the court that no “illegal or unconstitutional activities” would be allowed in connection with the protest.
asserted
activities → reserve → protest
At one point during the hearing, Chief Justice Dogar recalled that the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Advocate General (AG) Shah Faisal Utmankhel had stated during the previous hearing that notices had been issued to provincial authorities for judicial assistance.
asserted
notices → recall → assistance
The chief justice clarified that the court had not issued any notice under Section 27-A of the Civil Procedure Code for judicial assistance from provincial law officers, observing that such assistance could only be sought through the attorney general, the federal government’s law officer.
uncertain
assistance → clarify → general
Islamabad Advocate General Naveed Hayat Malik, who was among those who appeared before the court today, informed the bench that a miscellaneous application had been filed seeking permission to screen videos of the PTI’s protests in 2022 and 2024.
asserted
application → appear → 2022
The Islamabad AG noted that the PTI leadership was claiming that its planned long march would remain peaceful and was aimed at strengthening the judiciary.
asserted
march → note → judiciary
He said he wished to place before the court statements made by PTI leaders as well as videos of the party’s previous protests.
asserted
he → say → protests
Initially, Justice Dogar expressed reluctance to allow the screening of videos.
asserted
Dogar → express → videos
“That is not the practice of this court,” he observed when the AG sought permission to play footage of the November 2024 protest.
asserted
AG → observe → protest
When the law officer pointed out instances of videos being played in the Supreme Court, Justice Dogar remarked that the IHC did not wish to establish a precedent of routinely playing videos during court proceedings.
asserted
IHC → point → proceedings
After a brief break, however, the bench allowed the footage to be screened, with the chief justice making it clear that the videos would be played only once.
asserted
videos → allow → break
The Islamabad AG then played videos related to the PTI’s 2022 and 2024 protests and argued that the demonstrations could not be described as peaceful.
uncertain
demonstrations → play → protests
He alleged that state machinery had been used during the 2022 protest and that barriers placed by the Islamabad administration to stop the march were removed with the help of cranes.
asserted
barriers → allege → cranes
The law officer alleged that property at D-Chowk was set on fire and that a police official was martyred during the violence.
asserted
official → allege → violence
He claimed that similar incidents occurred during the PTI’s 2024 protest, which he described as an “assault on Islamabad”.
“This was by no means peaceful.
asserted
This → claim → means
This does not look like a scene from a public rally,” the AG argued.
asserted
AG → look → rally
He alleged individuals were seen firing shells at Islamabad police personnel and that Rangers officials were run over by a vehicle during the protest.
asserted
officials → allege → protest
The law officer also referred to vehicles being set ablaze near F-9 Park, and pointed out that there was a legal framework governing public meetings and protests in the federal capital.
asserted
vehicles → refer → capital
He said any person or political party intending to hold a protest was required to submit an application containing complete details so that the administration could make appropriate security arrangements.
uncertain
administration → say → arrangements
According to the AG, the district magistrate had the authority either to grant or reject the request for permission, and no protest could be held without such approval.
uncertain
protest → accord → approval
He further argued that the government also had the authority to declare any area a “red zone” and impose restrictions, including Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, where required to maintain law and order.
asserted
area → argue → law
The Islamabad AG contended that there were two objectives of the PTI’s planned march: the “release of a convicted prisoner and the removal of the government”.
asserted
AG → contend → government
And both of those objectives were unconstitutional, he remarked.
asserted
he → remark → objectives
“They claim to be protesting for the rule of law and the strengthening of the judiciary,” the law officer said, adding that the “release of a convicted prisoner could only be sought through legal remedies before the courts”.
uncertain
release → claim → courts
“If you are dissatisfied with the prime minister, go to Parliament and move a vote of no-confidence,” he added.
asserted
he → go → confidence
“If you want to topple the government in the streets and public squares, then do not speak of the rule of law.”
asserted
you → want → law
Questioning the PTI’s claim that it was marching to strengthen the judiciary, the AG argued that an increase in litigation showed growing public confidence in the courts.
uncertain
increase → question → courts
He further contended that there was no evidence to suggest that the proposed rally would remain peaceful.
asserted
rally → contend → ?
The Islamabad AG further said the administration did not have the “physical capacity to stop a massive crowd if the PTI brought its full resources to Islamabad”.
asserted
PTI → say → Islamabad
“We can only make precautionary arrangements, such as imposing Section 144 and placing containers,” he said.
asserted
he → make → containers
…and 21 more, not listed.
The Aporia
