Albertans are going to the polls to decide their place in Canada, in a referendum that has exposed deep divisions within the province, not least in the separatist movement itself.
asserted
that → go → movement
On Monday, voters will respond to the question of whether Alberta should remain in Canada, or hold a second binding independence referendum.
asserted
Alberta → respond → referendum
A minority have long argued that separation is the only way to address their belief that Alberta is short-changed by its financial relationship with Ottawa, and prevented from fully exploiting the province’s vast fossil fuel reserves.
asserted
Alberta → argue → reserves
Any enthusiasm either side might have held headed into the referendum was muted after a deadly fire broke out at a major military base in the province.
uncertain
fire → hold → province
On Saturday afternoon, a blaze tore through the CFB Wainwright and into the nearby town.
asserted
blaze → tear → town
Canada’s armed forces announced with “profound sadness” that there had been multiple deaths and injuries.
asserted
forces → announce → sadness
The premier of Alberta, Danielle Smith, argued for years that a referendum was not needed, but called one anyway after pressure from some within her United Conservative party.
asserted
referendum → argue → party
Nevertheless, Smith did not campaign in favour of independence, saying in June she estimated the cost of separating at about C$400bn (£212bn) for the transition and another $25bn-$50bn in annual costs associated with starting a new country.
asserted
she → campaign → country
Smith’s caution prompted some of her supporters to accuse her of betraying the independence movement.
asserted
caution → prompt → movement
Opponents of independence have focused heavily on the costs of separation, with the University of Calgary’s school of public policy saying in June it could be up to $170bn over a five-year period and be highly unpredictable in the long term.
uncertain
it → focus → term
The issue has not divided neatly along partisan lines.
asserted
issue → divide → lines
The former premiers Jason Kenney and Rachel Notley – from the rightwing Conservative and leftwing New Democratic party – have appeared on stage together, setting aside a bitter ideological rivalry that more usually defines Albertan politics.
asserted
that → appear → politics
Mark Carney, who grew up in the province, visited both Calgary and Edmonton last week to campaign for a united Canada.
“At this pivotal moment, Albertans have a choice: to build a stronger Alberta and a greater Canada to leave for our children, or to burden them with years of deep division and great uncertainty,” the prime minister told a raucous crowd.
asserted
minister → grow → crowd
Carney, who previously served as the governor of the Bank of England, saw first-hand the effects of the Brexit vote and the economic upheaval that followed.
asserted
that → serve → vote
A vote against Canada is a dangerous bluff that will lead to years of deep uncertainty and lost opportunities,” he said.
asserted
he → lead → uncertainty
“Our country and your futures are too precious to play games with.”
asserted
country → play → games
Carney, whom recent polls identify as the most popular politician in Alberta, joined the former deputy premier of Alberta Thomas Lukaszuk at a rally for the latter’s Forever Canadian group.
asserted
polls → identify → group
Lukaszuk has driven more than 40,000km (24,855 miles) around Alberta in a 1992 motorhome named the Unity Bus and distributed at least 100,000 lawn signs.
asserted
Lukaszuk → drive → signs
Rather than campaigning frequently, Carney has pointed to big projects his government is looking to move ahead with that would benefit the province, including a pipeline to the Pacific coast to increase the flow of Alberta crude oil to Asia.
asserted
that → campaign → Asia
“I won’t sugar-coat it: some of those threads have needed to be repaired.
asserted
some → coat → threads
The frustrations that many Albertans have felt are real,” said Carney.
asserted
Carney → feel → that
Energy policy has long been at the heart of Alberta’s grievance with Ottawa, stemming from the 1980 national energy programme, which sought greater federal control over the energy sector, provoked fierce opposition in Alberta and helped erode Liberal support across western Canada.
asserted
policy → stem → Canada
The sense that the province’s wealth was being siphoned eastward is older still: a 1915 cartoon, “The Milch Cow”, depicted Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba as farmers feeding a cow whose milk was funnelled into buckets labelled Ottawa, Toronto and Montreal.
asserted
milk → siphon → buckets
“Growing up, I remember.
asserted
I → grow → ?
I remember how Ottawa made Albertans feel like our resources weren’t our own,” Carney told the crowd.
asserted
Carney → remember → crowd
“And more recently, we were made to feel that our energy contributions were running against the tides of history.”
asserted
contributions → make → history
The movement seeking to capitalise on those grievances, however, has been marked by competing interests, personal rivalries and allegations surrounding some of its leading figures.
asserted
movement → seek → figures
Jeff Rath, a bombastic lawyer linked to the Alberta Prosperity Project, is alleged to have mismanaged millions of dollars of First Nations trust funds, while David Parker, a longtime rightwing political organiser, was at the centre of a voter-data scandal that exposed the personal information of nearly 3 million Albertans and remains under investigation.
asserted
that → link → investigation
Keith Wilson, one of the principal intellectual and legal architects of the province’s modern separatist movement, recently published the Alberta transition plan, a 214-page blueprint for turning it into an independent country.
asserted
Wilson → publish → country
Rejecting comparisons to Brexit and the economic fallout, Wilson said: “Every single thing we found that needs to be addressed to do the transition is absolutely doable,” calling most of the tasks “super easy”.
asserted
that → reject → tasks
Wilson dismissed the idea that negotiations between an independent Alberta and Canada’s federal government would be acrimonious and lengthy.
asserted
negotiations → dismiss → Alberta
“It would be economic suicide for them to challenge Alberta,” he said.
asserted
he → challenge → Alberta
“You want to cut off trade with us?
asserted
You → want → us
By the way, go buy axes and chainsaws because you’re going to have to cut down all the maple trees to keep warm this winter because you’re not going to get our energy products.”
asserted
you → go → products
Even within the separatist camp, there are doubts about how quickly independence could be achieved.
uncertain
independence → be → camp
Bill Jones, a member of the Wildrose Independence party, said its leaders were moving too quickly without the institutions a new country would need, from a police force to a pension system.
asserted
country → say → system
“We – Alberta – were always meant to be a colony, to get resources that were here to go east,” said Jones.
asserted
Jones → mean → resources
“I don’t see the evidence for our independence.
asserted
I → see → independence
If we go out today, we’d be a failed state for generations.
asserted
we → go → generations
The great-great-grandchildren would be still suffering.
asserted
grandchildren → suffer → ?
…and 26 more, not listed.
The Aporia
