Photo via NBC News

Judge denies Trump administration request to segregate alleged noncitizen ballots in California

Read the original at NBC News ↗
Cite

Gregorian, D. (2026, October 29). Judge denies Trump administration request to segregate alleged noncitizen ballots in California. NBC News. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/justice-department/judge-rules-california-ballots-alleged-non-citizen-voters-trump-doj-rcna606100

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

NBC News · collected 2026-10-29 · by Dareh Gregorian

Quick Summary

A federal judge in California denied a request by the Trump administration to segregate approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots from individuals alleged to be noncitizens. U.S. District Judge David Carter ruled that such action would violate constitutional principles and disrupt ongoing elections. The Justice Department had filed the lawsuit on October 15, seeking an order for California to set aside these ballots until citizenship could be confirmed. Attorneys representing California argued that the government’s list of potential noncitizens was unreliable and vague, and that the request posed a significant risk of disenfranchising eligible voters.
Written by AI on 2026-10-29, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

On October 26, 2026, federal appellate judges questioned the Justice Department's demand for California to set aside 20,000 mail ballots from people suspected of not being U.S. citizens. The panel expressed doubt about the timing and constitutionality of this request during a rare weekend hearing. Despite initial setbacks, on November 2, Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg ordered the Trump administration to stop demanding California officials set aside these ballots, delivering another setback to the DOJ's election oversight efforts. However, in an unusual legal twist, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals briefly lifted and then restored a block on the investigation into noncitizen voting in California hours before polls opened on November 3, setting up further legal battles.

Written for “Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Bid” on 2026-11-22, grounded in this article and the 42 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

18 outlets covered “Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Bid”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

NBC NewsThis outlet29 Oct

A federal judge in California denied a request by the Trump administration to segregate approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots from individuals alleged to be noncitizens. U.S. District Judge David Carter ruled that such action would violate constitutional principles and disrupt ongoing elections. The Justice Department had filed the lawsuit on October 15, seeking an order for California to set aside these ballots…

Judge denies Trump administration request to segregate alleged noncitizen ballots in California (this article)2 articles from NBC News on this story
CBS News30 Oct

A 9th Circuit Court of Appeals panel rejected the Justice Department’s request to set aside disputed ballots in California, which the department alleged were sent to people who may not be U.S. citizens. The appeals court ruled that separating these ballots could have "catastrophic effects" on election integrity, with only one judge dissenting. This decision is part of a broader legal battle between federal and state…

Appeals court rejects DOJ bid to set aside disputed California ballots →5 articles from CBS News on this story
Al Jazeera30 Oct

An appeals court in the United States has again denied President Donald Trump’s request to invalidate nearly 20,000 ballots in California due to alleged non-citizen voting. The ruling came just days before the November 3 midterm elections and was issued by a panel including judges appointed by both Trump and his predecessor Joe Biden. While two judges supported the decision, one dissented. Critics argue that the…

US appeals court again rejects Trump bid to set aside California ballots →4 articles from Al Jazeera on this story
The Straits Times29 Oct

On October 28, US District Judge David Carter denied the Justice Department's request for a temporary restraining order to block California from counting votes received from individuals allegedly not citizens. This decision was part of an ongoing dispute over alleged non-citizen voters and reflects broader tensions between the federal government under President Trump and states like California regarding election…

US Justice Department loses initial bid to block votes from alleged non-citizens in California →4 articles from The Straits Times on this story
Washington Examiner3 Nov

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a recent ruling that allowed the Trump administration to require election officials to separate ballots from suspected noncitizens and threaten them with criminal prosecution. The court’s decision came late Monday when a majority of active judges voted to rehear the case en banc, reversing an earlier three-judge panel's decision. This action reinstated restrictions…

Appeals court wipes out Trump DOJ’s brief victory in California →4 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
Show 12 more outlets
Los Angeles Times29 Oct

Courts have twice rejected the Trump administration’s attempt to block the counting of approximately 20,000 ballots in California, alleging they may be from noncitizens. The Justice Department has appealed these rulings, intensifying a legal battle over election integrity between federal officials and state authorities days before midterms. Governor Gavin Newsom announced he would deploy lawyers to safeguard voting…

California, feds continue election war after courts rebuke challenge to 20,000 ballots →3 articles from Los Angeles Times on this story
ABC News (US)29 Oct

A federal judge in California denied the Justice Department’s request for an emergency order that would have required California to isolate approximately 20,000 ballots allegedly belonging to noncitizens. The Trump administration had argued these voters were “likely” ineligible, but Judge David Carter rejected this claim, emphasizing it was unprecedented for the federal government to interfere with a state's…

Judge rejects Trump admin request for order to segregate 20,000 Calif. ballots →3 articles from ABC News (US) on this story
Fox News3 Nov

A federal appeals court initially lifted a block on the Trump administration's investigation into alleged noncitizen voting in California but then reversed its decision hours later. The three-judge panel had temporarily allowed the Justice Department to proceed with requests to set aside ballots under threat of prosecution against state and local election officials who refused, citing it as a core executive…

9th Circuit block on California noncitizen voter probe lifted, then restored in legal boomerang →3 articles from Fox News on this story
The Independent30 Oct

A federal appeals court has rejected the Trump administration’s effort to stop counting approximately 20,000 ballots in California, citing concerns that such actions could jeopardize midterm elections and disenfranchise eligible voters. The decision, handed down on Friday with two days remaining until Election Day, marks the third consecutive loss for the administration in its attempt to block these ballots due to…

Trump’s bid to toss 20,000 California ballots could ‘jeopardize’ midterm elections, appeals court warns →2 articles from The Independent on this story
The Guardian29 Oct

Federal judge David Carter rejected a request from the Trump administration's Justice Department to isolate approximately 20,000 ballots in California from individuals claimed to be non-citizens. This ruling came two weeks after the Justice Department delivered a USB drive containing this list of names to election officials, who had only 48 hours to review it before facing legal action if they did not comply. Judge…

Judge rebuffs Trump DoJ’s bid to order California to set aside 20,000 ballots →2 articles from The Guardian on this story
New York Post30 Oct

A federal appeals court has denied the Trump administration's attempt to block over 20,000 California ballots that were flagged by the Justice Department for suspected noncitizen voting. The ruling follows a previous rejection by US District Judge David O. Carter and comes days before Election Day. The decision supports California’s state laws for managing voter rolls, while the DOJ continues to argue that these…

Court rejects DOJ effort to block 20,000 California votes →2 articles from New York Post on this story
Time28 Oct

The Trump administration is increasing efforts to interfere with the midterms, raising concerns about unprecedented federal influence over election outcomes. These actions include legal challenges in Alaska and threats against California officials, along with suggestions of extreme measures like declaring martial law. Election officials across multiple states are bracing for potential disruptions on Election Day and…

How Trump Could Interfere With the Midterms on Election Day, and the Days After →
NPR29 Oct

A federal judge has denied the Justice Department’s request to halt processing ballots for 20,000 individuals deemed “likely” noncitizens in California’s midterm elections. The ruling came days before Election Day and cited concerns over disenfranchising eligible voters and disrupting state voting procedures. Judge David Carter rejected the DOJ's claim that setting aside these ballots was necessary, stating it would…

Judge denies the Justice Department's bid to stop processing California ballots →
The Hindu29 Oct

On October 28, 2026, a federal judge dismissed the U.S. Department of Justice's attempt to invalidate ballots from over 20,000 California voters potentially lacking citizenship status, calling it interference in the upcoming midterms. The decision supported California’s Democratic government and criticized the Trump administration for allegedly trying to cast doubt on electoral integrity ahead of November 3…

U.S. judge rejects Trump administration’s interference in California midterm vote →
Reason29 Oct

U.S. District Judge David O. Carter dismissed a federal lawsuit brought by the Justice Department against California's Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County's top election official Dean Logan. The Justice Department sought to compel them to segregate ballots from individuals listed as "likely noncitizens" before verifying their citizenship status, based on an initial DHS estimate that suggested…

Trump's Claims About Noncitizen Voting Are 'Not Credible,' a Federal Judge Says in a Scathing Decision →
Mother Jones29 Oct

A California district court dismissed a lawsuit filed by the Trump administration that sought to invalidate ballots from approximately 20,000 voters in California on grounds of potential non-citizenship, without providing concrete evidence. The decision was made based on concerns over federal interference with state election procedures and protecting voter rights. Judge David Carter’s ruling emphasized that such…

Court Denies White House Bid to Toss California Ballots →
Daily Mail1 Nov

The Justice Department under President Trump is refusing to comply with a court order to provide a list of California voters it seeks to remove from voter rolls, arguing that fulfilling this request would be unnecessary and burdensome. US District Judge James Boasberg plans to rule on Monday regarding the administration’s efforts to pressure states into investigating alleged noncitizen voting before midterms…

Trump DOJ thumbs its nose as nemesis judge in noncitizen voting war days before midterms →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

Reported by outlets on both sides of the middle

“This request violates longstanding constitutional principles mandating that states have control over their elections,” U.S. District Judge David Carter wrote.

4 outlets

Framing

How the first headlines put it

Stated as fact4
The headlines (4)

9th Circuit questions DOJ demand to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots Toronto Star · stated as fact

US appeals court sceptical of Trump’s lawsuit over California voter rolls Al Jazeera · stated as fact

Chabria: California votes. Trump's Justice Department panics Los Angeles Times · stated as fact

Trump-appointed judge questions president’s bid to block 20,000 California ballots The Independent · stated as fact

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 43 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 10% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
ABC News (US)
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 65/100
Mother Jones
Hedges 1 of 9 claims Outlet record 60/100
New York Post
Hedges 0 of 20 claims Outlet record 66/100
The Straits Times
Hedges 3 of 26 claims Outlet record 64/100
CBS News
Leans left Hedges 5 of 41 claims Outlet record 66/100
The Guardian
Hedges 2 of 18 claims Outlet record 64/100
The Straits Times
Hedges 2 of 18 claims Outlet record 64/100
Washington Examiner
Leans left Hedges 1 of 3 claims Outlet record 66/100
Toronto Star
Leans left Hedges 0 of 2 claims Outlet record 65/100

Story

Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Bid
Politics · 43 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
31
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
10%
3 of 31 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
withheld
no quote in the article backed the model's score
Publisher signals
74/100
NBC News's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
43
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-29 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

NBC News · 2752 article(s) · 5 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 5 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Dareh Gregorian
19 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
“I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND, whose record of 4,256 Hits in a Season will never be broken,” Trump said in a post on Truth Social as he was returning from a meeting in China with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin.
“Congress can turn off the lights of the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they will not fund their activities,” he said.
Hegseth, his wife, Jennifer, and some of Hegseth’s top aides were taking pictures, talking and laughing in front of the tomb on Wednesday when Iglesias directed them to stop. “All visitors will maintain an atmosphere of silence and respect at all times,” he shouted.
The National Capital Planning Commission is expected to vote Thursday to approve President Donald Trump’s massive — and controversial — “Triumphal Arch” for Washington, D.C., with construction scheduled to begin almost immediately.
She focused on issues such as border security and tax cuts, and she chose John Giles, a former Republican and former mayor of Mesa, as her running mate.
The dismissal came after an FBI agent testified at a preliminary hearing last week that he was concerned the investigation, which had been directed by FBI Director Kash Patel, would be viewed as “political.”
It included a typewritten note depicting an imaginary conversation with Epstein, who would later be charged with sex trafficking.
Witt said he was unhappy with the assignment, in part because “I had concerns that this would be viewed as political.”
“If Plaintiff’s last-minute request for relief were granted, either party could create chaos for their own political purposes to disrupt the election process.”
Prosecutor John Borchert of the U.S. attorney’s office for Washington, D.C., acknowledged in court Tuesday that “this has never been done before” but suggested the complaint could be signed during the hearing.
Also by Dareh Gregorian
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 19 articles by Dareh Gregorian →

Topics

California The Justice Department U.S. United States the Federal Government

Subjects

California GPE · 10× Carter PERSON · 7× Essayli PERSON · 2× The Justice Department ORG · 2× U.S. GPE · 2× Christina McCall PERSON · 1× David Carter PERSON · 1× Trump PERSON · 1× United States GPE · 1× the Federal Government ORG · 1×

Narrative

Circuit Judge Gabriel Sanchez wrote in a concurring opinion that the government was asking the “court to dictate to a state legislature a matter squarely within the state’s traditional domain, upending the state’s policies in this regard and inviting disorder and confusion for voters and election officials alike.”
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-29
“If Plaintiff’s last-minute request for relief were granted, either party could create chaos for their own political purposes to disrupt the election process.”

Claims (31 extracted, 3 hedged)

A federal judge in California is refusing a request by the Trump administration to segregate 20,000 mail-in ballots from individuals it alleges are noncitizens. asserted
it → refuse → individuals
“This request violates longstanding constitutional principles mandating that states have control over their elections,” U.S. District Judge David Carter wrote. asserted
Carter → violate → elections
“If Plaintiff’s last-minute request for relief were granted, either party could create chaos for their own political purposes to disrupt the election process.” uncertain
party → grant → process
Carter, as he did during Tuesday’s hearing, notes there is a “clear remedy” available to the federal government: the use of its prosecutorial tools. asserted
he → do → tools
Carter also notes California has established procedures to cancel the voter registration of any individual proven ineligible. asserted
California → note → individual
“The Executive’s requested relief, however, would wreak havoc and disrupt the election that is already underway, create a chilling effect on election workers and voters alike, and discount the votes of United States citizens,” Carter writes. asserted
Carter → request → citizens
The Justice Department filed the suit on Oct. 15, seeking a court order that the state “set aside vote-by-mail ballots from persons identified by the Federal Government likely to be noncitizens” and not count them until their citizenship is confirmed. asserted
citizenship → file → them
The department said it had compiled “a list of over 20,000 names of people” the government “believes are likely noncitizens.” asserted
government → say → people
Attorneys for the state countered that the government’s numbers are unreliable. asserted
numbers → counter → state
In a July letter, it put the number of suspect voters at 190,000 and has refused to release information about how it has generated its lists. asserted
it → put → lists
“Where is the evidence?” an attorney representing California, Christina McCall, said it a hearing Tuesday, calling the government’s allegations “vague” and “not reliable.” asserted
attorney → represent → allegations
Another attorney for the state, Anne Bellows, told the judge “the stakes here are enormous,” arguing the government was trying to force California to initiate an unclear investigation into the citizenship of tens of thousands of people without any clear standards shortly before an election. It “is a recipe for disenfranchisement,” Bellows said. uncertain
Bellows → tell → disenfranchisement
First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli told the judge, “We’re not telling California what they have to do. asserted
they → tell → what
We’re telling them what they can’t do.” asserted
they → tell → what
Essayli said once the state is made aware of potential noncitizens on its voter rolls, “they need to do something. asserted
they → say → something
” “What they cannot do is do nothing, and proceed to count the votes,” he said. asserted
he → do → votes
The judge said that if the government believes there is non-citizen voting, which is a crime, it should bring charges. asserted
it → say → charges
“Don’t you have the power of indictments?” Carter asked Essayli. asserted
Carter → have → Essayli
“You brought 28 indictments,” he said, referring to a recent announcement by prosecutors of individuals that have been found to have voted illegally in California in recent years. asserted
that → bring → years
“You may find others. uncertain
You → find → others
You have the right to bring that indictment against them.” asserted
You → have → them
“You’ve got a remedy, for goodness’ sakes,” Carter said. asserted
Carter → get → sakes
“Go out and indict.” The Justice Department has already been to a federal appeals court once on the case. asserted
Department → go → case
It filed a motion to expedite the case to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last week, after Carter didn’t act on its request to rule in the matter by Thursday. asserted
Carter → file → Thursday
The appeals court held an emergency hearing Sunday, and ruled against the administration in a 2-1 ruling the following day. asserted
court → hold → ruling
The majority found they didn’t have jurisdiction because Carter had not yet ruled, but found the government’s “claimed emergency” was at least partly “a self-constructed one.” asserted
emergency → find → jurisdiction
“At least part of the delay here is attributable to the United States’s own delay in filing suit,” Judge Mark Bennett wrote in the ruling. asserted
Bennett → file → ruling
“The United States has taken issue with California’s voter rolls since at least July 16, when it sent a letter to California’s secretary of state citing its ‘[p]reliminary’ analysis of California’s voter rolls. asserted
it → take → rolls
And neither California’s law permitting the processing of ballots twenty-nine days before an election, nor its law providing for the issuance of mail-in ballots to registered voters, is new.” asserted
law → permit → voters
Circuit Judge Gabriel Sanchez wrote in a concurring opinion that the government was asking the “court to dictate to a state legislature a matter squarely within the state’s traditional domain, upending the state’s policies in this regard and inviting disorder and confusion for voters and election officials alike.” asserted
government → write → voters
The dissenting judge, Trump appointee Patrick Bumatay, wrote, “We should’ve granted the federal government relief — federal law precludes California from commingling ballots likely cast by aliens with legitimate ballots, because it encourages and induces illegal voting.” asserted
it → dissent → voting
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support