Cameron Ortis, who was convicted of violating Canada’s secrecy laws while working as a top RCMP intelligence director, insists he didn’t get a fair trial, according to a legal filing ahead of a highly anticipated appeal at Ontario’s top court.
uncertain
he → convict → court
Mr. Ortis’s lawyers argue that his ability to mount a full defence was badly hampered because of the secrecy that has enveloped the case.
asserted
that → argue → case
Mr. Ortis doesn’t deny having intentionally communicated special operational information – the reason the RCMP arrested him in 2019 and the basis of his conviction after a jury trial in 2023 – but he asserts that he wasn’t able to properly explain his actions.
asserted
he → deny → actions
He had been accused of trying to pass along highly sensitive police dossiers to transnational gangs.
asserted
He → accuse → gangs
The work of his team at the RCMP included gathering secret information on such groups.
asserted
work → include → groups
At trial, Mr. Ortis said he worked with a counterpart at a foreign agency and had tried to lure suspected criminals into using an encrypted e-mail service where authorities could tap their communications.
uncertain
authorities → say → communications
The 54-year-old former director general of the RCMP’s National Intelligence Coordination Centre had been sentenced in early 2024 to 14 years, minus time served, for a total of 7½ years.
asserted
general → sentence → years
The Parole Board of Canada in February granted day parole, saying that Mr. Ortis posed a low risk to reoffend.
asserted
Ortis → grant → risk
In a legal filing at the Ontario Court of Appeal, Mr. Ortis’s lawyers argue his “position at trial was severely curtailed” by pretrial secrecy rulings.
asserted
position → argue → rulings
The jury trial was at the Ontario Superior Court but related decisions were made in Federal Court, as the federal government successfully won orders there that included a prohibition on Mr. Ortis testifying to classified information in his defence.
“The jury was left with an incomplete picture because of these evidential handcuffs,” lawyers Matthew Gourlay, Jon Doody and Matthew Kay state.
The details behind this argument, however, are secret, submitted to the appeal court in a confidential filing.
asserted
details → make → filing
The appeal at Ontario’s top court had been scheduled to start on Monday but because the case wasn’t ready to proceed, it is now booked for February.
asserted
it → schedule → February
Like the jury trial in the fall of 2023, the appeal will be heard partly in secret.
asserted
appeal → hear → secret
Based on the new schedule, the public portion of the appeal will take place on Feb. 8 and 9 in Toronto.
asserted
portion → base → Toronto
The secret portion is set for a secure facility known colloquially as the bunker at the Federal Court in Ottawa on Feb. 11 and 12.
asserted
portion → set → Feb.
Such secrecy is unusual in the Canadian justice system, in which the principle of open courts is foundational, yet it has been a defining theme of Mr. Ortis’s case.
asserted
it → define → case
This secrecy, and its alleged undermining of Mr. Ortis’s ability to mount a full defence against the charges, is one pillar of his appeal.
asserted
secrecy → allege → appeal
Before the jury trial began, several other charges were dropped because the court decided various restrictions meant Mr. Ortis wouldn’t be able to fully defend himself on those accusations.
asserted
Ortis → begin → accusations
Mr. Ortis in his appeal also argues the trial judge incorrectly interpreted the Security of Information Act, under which he was found guilty in November 2023 of four counts of unauthorized communication of special operational information – the first time such charges were tested at trial under provisions that date back to 2001.
asserted
that → argue → 2001
His appeal filing states that Mr. Ortis, in his former role as an RCMP intelligence director, had been praised at trial by numerous witnesses and that his bosses held him in high regard.
asserted
bosses → state → regard
“His commitment to Canada’s national security was evident from their testimony,” the legal filing says.
asserted
filing → say → testimony
“The Crown put forward no tangible motive for his actions and even the trial judge could not understand why [Mr. Ortis] did what he did.”
uncertain
he → put → what
The federal government is also appealing the case, arguing that Mr. Ortis’s sentence was far too lenient.
asserted
sentence → appeal → case
The Crown in its legal filing says he betrayed his country and put Canada’s entire security apparatus at risk.
asserted
he → say → risk
The Public Prosecution Service of Canada argues the judge should have levied a much longer sentence, near or at the maximum.
asserted
judge → argue → maximum
At sentencing, the Crown called for 28 years’ imprisonment, which is more than the minimum jail time for first-degree murder.
asserted
which → call → murder
In February 2024, when the Prosecution Service announced its planned appeal, it cited “the seriousness of the offence and the moral blameworthiness of the offender.”
asserted
it → announce → offender
The Crown says Mr. Ortis, in his job near the top of the RCMP, was privy to the highest levels of classified information and had a “profound responsibility” to keep that information, and his country, safe.
asserted
Ortis → say → information
“Instead,” argue Crown counsel Lisa Mathews, Jennifer Conroy and Judy Kliewer in their appeal filing, “he engaged in conduct that breached his duty to safeguard that information, and he put lives – and Canada’s entire security apparatus – at risk.”
asserted
he → argue → risk
The federal government further argues that Mr. Ortis’s actions “harmed Canada’s international reputation for safeguarding intelligence [and] thwarted ongoing domestic and international criminal organization investigations.”
asserted
actions → argue → investigations
Later in the legal filing, the Crown states: “His conduct betrayed the Canadians he was meant to serve.”
asserted
he → state → Canadians
In the February report from the Parole Board that granted day parole, it states that Mr. Ortis at the start of his sentence maintained that he believed he had the authority to share the information he did, the kinds of decisions his job required a half-dozen times each year, and he had to occasionally walk a fine line in such choices.
But the Parole Board then states Mr. Ortis has since acknowledged and understood he did not have the authority to share the information and should have consulted others.
asserted
he → grant → others
“You have expressed regret for your actions,” the Parole Board states, “and are aware of the negative impact your actions have had on others.”
asserted
actions → express → others