The Supreme Court of Canada will deliver its landmark ruling in the Quebec secularism case on Nov. 27.
asserted
Court → deliver → Nov.
In a brief announcement on Friday, the country’s top court said the ruling will be issued next Friday at 9:45 a.m. Ottawa time.
asserted
ruling → say → a.m.
The hotly political case is rooted in foundational questions about Canada’s Constitution and the limits of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
asserted
case → root → Rights
Seven judges of the top court heard the appeal over four days in March, one of the longest hearings in the history of the Supreme Court.
asserted
judges → hear → Court
The Supreme Court’s judgment is in part a reckoning with the political compromises of the early 1980s that helped achieve the patriation of the Constitution from Britain in 1982 and the inclusion of the Charter in the Constitution.
asserted
that → help → Constitution
Passed in 2019, the law prohibits many public-sector workers in the province, including teachers and police officers, from wearing religious symbols (such as a hijab or a cross) on the job.
asserted
law → pass → job
The provincial government shielded Bill 21 from court challenges with Section 33 of the Charter, the notwithstanding clause, which allows legislatures to override many of the rights in the Charter.
asserted
legislatures → shield → Charter
Quebec’s goal is secularism but some people believe Bill 21 violates freedom of religion and is a state attack on minorities.
asserted
Bill → believe → minorities
The notwithstanding clause requires renewal every five years and Quebec did so in 2024.
asserted
Quebec → require → 2024
Bill 21 was also twice upheld by the lower courts in Quebec, in 2021 and 2024, both times because of the notwithstanding clause.
asserted
Bill → uphold → clause
The clause, which went mostly unused for decades, has become popular in recent years among some conservative-led provinces.
asserted
which → go → provinces
Alberta used the clause in four laws last year, one to end a teachers’ strike and the other three to restrict the choices of transgender youth.
asserted
Alberta → use → youth
The Bill 21 case at the Supreme Court intensified federal-provincial political fissures.
asserted
case → intensify → fissures
The federal Liberal government, and numerous advocacy groups, in March argued that the judges should impose additional limits on the notwithstanding clause.
asserted
judges → argue → clause
Ottawa asserted that the clause’s extended use to override rights effectively eliminates rights and rewrites the Constitution.
asserted
use → assert → Constitution
Quebec insists its political autonomy is in peril and at the Supreme Court the province vied against six groups of appellants who argued Bill 21 should be struck down.
asserted
Bill → insist → appellants
The federal government, as well as some appellants and intervenors, want the court to endorse what are called judicial declarations, where a superior trial court could rule that a law protected by the notwithstanding clause violates Charter rights, even as that law is allowed to stand.
uncertain
law → want → rights
Quebec parried the fusillade of arguments aimed at taking down Bill 21 and rejected the idea of judicial declarations.
asserted
Quebec → parry → declarations
“It is not up to the court to answer a political question that does not concern the courts,” Quebec government lawyer Isabelle Brunet argued at the Supreme Court in March.
asserted
Brunet → answer → March
Ontario, Alberta and Saskatchewan, all conservative led, sided with Quebec.
asserted
all → lead → Quebec
The NDP in B.C. and Manitoba were open to judicial declarations but did not support limits on the notwithstanding clause.
asserted
NDP → support → clause
(B.C. in October elected a Conservative government.)
asserted
B.C. → elect → government
In late 1981 an agreement to formalize the notwithstanding clause in the Charter was a key compromise to bridge a political divide at the time, as Pierre Trudeau sought to patriate the Constitution and enact the Charter of Rights.
asserted
Trudeau → formalize → Rights
Many provincial leaders felt the Charter could usurp legislators, with courts striking down laws.
uncertain
courts → feel → laws
The federal government has never invoked the clause, through decades of Liberals and Conservatives in power.
asserted
government → invoke → power
The Nov. 27 date for the Bill 21 judgment had been widely viewed as likely by court watchers, after Chief Justice Richard Wagner in June at his annual news conference said the judges aimed to publish the ruling before the end of Justice Sheilah Martin’s tenure on the top court.
asserted
judges → view → court
She retired at the end of May but has six months, until the end of November, to participate in judgments.
uncertain
She → retire → judgments