A senior United States Navy official has claimed that insurance costs for commercial ships crossing the Strait of Hormuz have soared to $64m for a single transit, highlighting the enormous economic toll of the US-Israeli war on Iran.
asserted
costs → claim → Iran
Acting US Navy Secretary Hung Cao made the remarks during a Senate Armed Services Committee confirmation hearing on Tuesday, as lawmakers questioned the cost of the war and its impact on freedom of navigation.
asserted
lawmakers → act → navigation
Recommended Stories
list of 3 items- list 1 of 3Is the US-Israel war on Iran turning into a ‘frozen conflict’?
- list 2 of 3Iranians fear more civilian infrastructure could be targeted in new US war
- list 3 of
uncertain
infrastructure → turn → war
3Trump warns Iran over reported ‘dirty bomb’ threat plans against Washington
asserted
3Trump → warn → Washington
After the US and Israel launched strikes on Iran on February 28, Iran in effect closed the strait, allowing only some ships to pass while targeting those it says are unauthorised.
asserted
it → launch → those
This has raised the risks for shipping in the strait exponentially and caused severe shortages of oil, gas, fertiliser and other essential products from Gulf producers usually shipped via this route.
asserted
This → raise → route
Cao’s claim has not been independently verified and challenges previously reported rises in insurance costs over the course of the nine-month-old conflict.
uncertain
claim → verify → conflict
The remarks come as US President Donald Trump insists that the military campaign against Iran is effectively over, and that the US Navy is successfully escorting ships through the strait, even as new attacks on oil tankers and continued restrictions on shipping raise questions about whether one of the world’s most important energy waterways is really open.
asserted
one → come → waterways
The strait, the only sea route from the Gulf to the Arabian Sea and the open ocean beyond, carried about one-fifth of the world’s oil supplies before the war began.
asserted
war → carry → supplies
Although some vessels are still navigating the waterway, shipping remains substantially below pre-war levels, while Iran and the US continue to impose competing restrictions.
asserted
Iran → navigate → restrictions
Here’s what we know.
asserted
we → ’ → what
What did Hung Cao say in the Senate hearing?
asserted
Cao → say → hearing
During an exchange with Democratic Senator Elissa Slotkin, Cao said insurance costs for commercial vessels had risen dramatically since the conflict began.
asserted
conflict → say → vessels
He initially cited an insurance cost of $54,000 for a single crossing before clarifying that that was what insurance had previously cost, before the war.
asserted
insurance → cite → war
The cost now, he said, stood at $64m.
asserted
he → say → 64
Slotkin responded by blaming the war for the increase, arguing that commercial vessels no longer enjoyed the same freedom of navigation they had before the conflict.
asserted
they → respond → conflict
Cao also detailed the strain the war has placed on the US Navy, including prolonged deployments, deteriorating conditions and pressure on military resources.
asserted
war → detail → resources
“This war, again, I know it’s a strain on our navy,” he told lawmakers.
asserted
he → know → lawmakers
Democrats accused Cao of being a Trump “yes man” on the US-Israeli war on Iran, and downplaying its toll on sailors’ mental health after eight suicide attempts on an aircraft carrier.
asserted
Democrats → accuse → carrier
Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, a Democrat from New York, asked him about a sailor who went overboard.
asserted
who → ask → sailor
“Senator, that sailor was not trying to kill himself and he admitted that,” Cao told her, saying he used a life preserver.
asserted
he → try → preserver
Gillibrand responded: “What was he trying to do?
asserted
he → respond → What
“I think you are minimising what mental health strain is on these service members,” Gillibrand replied, while dismissing Cao’s response as “inhumane”.
asserted
Gillibrand → think → response
Did Cao misstate the cost of insurance?
asserted
Cao → misstate → insurance
Cao’s $64m figure appears unusually high, even by the standards of wartime shipping insurance.
asserted
figure → appear → insurance
There is no independently verified evidence that $64m is the current insurance premium for a regular commercial vessel crossing the volatile strait.
asserted
m → be → strait
“He gave no context.
asserted
He → give → context
Is he talking about additional premiums for war risk insurance which are set as a percentage of hull value?” Michelle Bockmann, an analyst at maritime intelligence company Windward, told Al Jazeera.
asserted
Bockmann → talk → Jazeera
“If so, it depends on the vessel type and the rate paid in order to get proper perspective.”
asserted
it → depend → perspective
In July, a report published by S&P Global said that war-risk insurance premiums had climbed to between 7.5 and 10 percent of a ship’s hull value, compared with 1 to 3 percent previously.
asserted
premiums → publish → percent
It estimated that insurance for a tanker carrying 270,000 metric tonnes of crude could, therefore, cost approximately $21m.
Separately, Reuters news agency reported in September that the cost of moving an oil cargo through Hormuz had risen to roughly $10m-$20m, quoting an executive at Dubai’s Emirates National Oil Company (ENOC).
uncertain
cost → estimate → Company
Regardless of whether it now costs $20m or $60m for insurance to transit the Strait of Hormuz, premiums have surged because ships face the possibility of being struck by missiles, drones or naval mines while passing through the waterway.
asserted
ships → cost → waterway
War-risk insurance covers vessels against losses arising from military conflict.
asserted
insurance → cover → conflict
Its price depends on the value of the vessel, the cargo and the likelihood of an attack.
asserted
price → depend → attack
Higher insurance costs can also feed into freight rates, fuel prices and the cost of goods transported around the world.
asserted
costs → feed → world
But it remains far from fully and freely open as it was before the war.
asserted
it → remain → war
Shipping traffic through the Strait of Hormuz remains approximately 65 percent below pre-war levels, according to the latest weekly report from the United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO).
uncertain
traffic → remain → Operations
The UKMTO recorded 308 vessel crossings during the seven days ending November 11, comprising 139 outbound and 169 inbound journeys.
asserted
UKMTO → record → journeys
Nevertheless, Trump has repeatedly suggested that Washington has secured shipping through the strait by providing naval escorts and maintaining the US naval blockade of Iranian ports.
uncertain
Washington → suggest → ports
Meanwhile, Iran insists that it, in fact, controls the passage of shipping through the strait.
asserted
it → insist → strait
…and 11 more, not listed.