You’re reading Dispatch Markets, a weekly dive into the forces driving economic growth—and those holding it back—featuring Scott Lincicome, Kyla Scanlon, Karl Smith, Marian Tupy, and Adam Ozimek.
asserted
You → read → Lincicome
On November 3, voters sent a resounding message to their elected officials.
asserted
voters → send → officials
Even though Republicans had a bad night, the data center industry might have envied them.
uncertain
industry → have → them
Voters backed limits on data centers or rejected proposals that would have made them easier to build in 52 of the 53 local contests Ballotpedia tracked.
asserted
Ballotpedia → back → contests
Worse, the sole win comes with an asterisk: In Harwood, North Dakota, voters rejected an amendment that would have required extra review for manufacturing, warehousing, and energy projects, as well as data centers.
asserted
that → come → manufacturing
Measures solely focused on data centers went worse for AI proponents.
asserted
Measures → focus → proponents
In Sunbury, Ohio, 79 percent of voters backed a ban on data centers above 25 megawatts in capacity.
asserted
percent → back → capacity
In Edgewater, Florida, 74 percent voted for a ban on new data centers altogether.
asserted
percent → vote → centers
According to an estimate from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, data centers accounted for 4.7 percent of U.S. electricity use in 2024.
uncertain
centers → accord → 2024
By 2030, they could account for nearly 12 percent.
uncertain
they → account → percent
It’s reasonable to ask who will pay for all that power.
asserted
who → ’ → power
In 2024, Virginia’s legislative auditors found that data centers were paying the utility costs allocated to them, but that providing the infrastructure for their growing demand could still raise everyone else’s bills.
uncertain
providing → find → bills
Despite industry assurances that newer cooling systems are more efficient, voters remained suspicious about the effects on the local drinking water supply.
asserted
voters → cool → supply
Yet suppose data center developers could answer every question about the electricity bill and reassure voters about the water supply.
uncertain
developers → suppose → supply
Would that settle it?
asserted
that → settle → it
It’s doubtful.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
University of Virginia researchers asked 809 people to consider building one of four types of facilities within 10 miles of home.
asserted
researchers → ask → home
The prospect of a data center drew more opposition than a nuclear plant.
asserted
prospect → draw → plant
Among people who thought the data center developer would take advantage of the community, 90 percent withheld support.
asserted
percent → think → support
That seems understandable.
asserted
That → seem → ?
More disquieting for those who care about America’s AI future, the survey found that even 41 percent of respondents who gave the developer the benefit of the doubt still opposed the project.
asserted
who → care → project
That leaves open the question of which came first: distrust or opposition.
asserted
which → leave → question
It also gives us reason to seriously contemplate voter sentiments that someone else is making the decisions.
asserted
someone → give → decisions
In a recent survey, 62 percent said they had little or no confidence that officials would consider residents’ views when deciding whether and where to build data centers in their area.
asserted
officials → say → area
All this comes at a time when workers are being told that AI is about to transform the kind of work they’ve spent their lives doing.
asserted
they → come → lives
They have very little say over how or when that will happen, and they do not know how fundamentally their lives and their livelihoods will be disrupted.
asserted
lives → have → say
Then a measure appears on their local ballot about whether an AI company can build a data center in their town.
asserted
company → appear → town
This might be their only chance to fight back against the tide.
uncertain
This → fight → tide
It’s little wonder voters reacted the way they did, and marginal improvements to water-cooling systems or behind-the-meter power generation by data centers are unlikely to change their minds.
asserted
improvements → ’ → minds
For America to maintain its lead in building data centers, we’ll have to find places to put data centers.
asserted
we → maintain → centers
Fortunately, one final frontier remains: space.
asserted
frontier → remain → ?
Google is testing its AI chips in low Earth orbit, and SpaceX has bet the farm on orbital data centers.
asserted
SpaceX → test → centers
To most people, this sounds a bit far-fetched.
asserted
this → sound → people
I, too, was skeptical at first, but repeated exercises in estimating costs and physical feasibility turned me into a convert.
asserted
exercises → repeat → convert
With a cheap enough ride and constant sunlight, the math behind putting chips on satellites in space rather than in giant buildings closer to home starts to pencil out.
asserted
math → put → home
Outer space is closer than it used to be.
asserted
it → use → ?
The closest region, known as low Earth orbit, extends from 60 to 1,240 miles above Earth’s surface.
asserted
region → know → surface
Yet for decades, satellite operators have favored a more distant location known as geostationary orbit.
asserted
operators → favor → orbit
In geostationary orbit, a satellite circles 22,236 miles above the equator in the same direction Earth turns.
asserted
Earth → circle → direction
One circuit takes 23 hours and 56 minutes, roughly as long as Earth’s rotation, and the satellite appears fixed in the sky.
asserted
satellite → take → sky
…and 91 more, not listed.