Large AI companies 'desperate for compute' are crowding out Canadian startups at home
Ottawa's budget promises 500 megawatts of compute for Canadian startups
asserted
budget → crowd → startups
Ottawa's new budget promises to help Canadian AI companies access processing power on home soil — something that's been a challenge as smaller startups struggle to compete with tech giants for increasingly scarce computing resources.
asserted
startups → promise → resources
The federal government is promising 500 megawatts of "sovereign AI compute" to help expand domestic computing capacity using financial tools such as backstops and offtake agreements to encourage private investment, but questions remain about when that capacity will become available and how companies will be able to access it.
asserted
companies → promise → it
For Al Vigier, CEO of Vancouver-based AI company Caseway, accessing computing capacity in Canada is critical to serving his customers.
asserted
accessing → base → customers
Caseway develops AI and automation tools primarily for the court system, and also works with law firms and the defence sector.
asserted
Caseway → develop → firms
Many of its clients require their information to remain in Canada.
asserted
Many → require → Canada
"Most of our clients, the courts, the defence, the Canadian military, they require sovereign AI, which basically means that they don't want their data to leave Canada.
asserted
data → require → Canada
They want their data to be governed by Canadian law and they want to enter into agreements with Canadian companies," he said.
asserted
he → want → companies
But that option doesn't exist in Canada at the moment, Vigier added, so certain Caseway customers won't use the company's AI offerings.
asserted
customers → exist → offerings
For other clients who are more flexible with where their data lands, Caseway has to turn to the U.S. or elsewhere for computing power.
asserted
Caseway → land → power
Al Vigier is the CEO of Caseway, a Vancouver-based AI company that builds automation for enterprises and government.
asserted
that → base → enterprises
Canada, like many other countries, relies heavily on U.S. technology companies for cloud services, including remote computing and data storage offered by tech giants such as Amazon and Microsoft.
asserted
Canada → rely → Amazon
That dependence raises concerns about data sovereignty, since U.S. laws can give American intelligence and law-enforcement agencies access to information held by technology providers under certain circumstances.
asserted
laws → raise → circumstances
Vigier said the federal government's commitment is exciting because it could help address those concerns.
uncertain
it → say → concerns
But while he'd like to offer sovereign computing services to clients immediately, he's worried about how the policy will be implemented and when the capacity will become available.
asserted
capacity → like → clients
Canadian computing power in high demand
Sean Mullin, a senior fellow at the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy at the University of Toronto who helped launch Canada's sovereign AI compute strategy, said major technology companies such as Meta, Google and OpenAI are "desperate for compute."
asserted
companies → launch → compute
As AI models become more powerful and more people use them, he said "the demand just skyrockets."
asserted
demand → become → them
For Canadian startups looking to use AI on a larger scale, "it can be hard to secure these contracts because these big hyperscalers can come in and just buy up all the use for five to 10 years into the future," Mullin said.
asserted
Mullin → look → future
"And if you're ... a project developer for a data centre, you'd say, 'Oh, it's very easy.
asserted
it → say → centre
I'll just sign one contract with a big, huge company and I've sold all my compute.
asserted
I → sign → compute
I don't have to worry about kind of smaller contracts and selling to smaller Canadian firms.'
asserted
I → have → firms
Earlier this year, Meta announced plans to build its first Canadian data centre, a massive one-gigawatt project northeast of Edmonton.
asserted
Meta → announce → Edmonton
Once completed, it is expected to be among the country's largest data centres and the first hyperscale data centre in Alberta.
asserted
it → complete → Alberta
In October, U.S. AI company Anthropic announced it had signed a long-term lease for the first 95-megawatt phase of a data centre project in Nova Scotia.
asserted
it → announce → Scotia
Canadian clean energy company EverWind Fuels will build and own the facility, while Anthropic will lease the capacity for at least 20 years.
asserted
Anthropic → build → years
Ramping up efforts for sovereign AI
Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED) says it is working to bring the capacity online "as quickly as possible," but has not provided a firm timeline.
asserted
it → ramp → timeline
"The government is engaging with a number of proponents on potential projects across Canada that could significantly expand domestic AI compute capacity," a spokesperson said in an emailed statement to CBC News.
uncertain
spokesperson → engage → News
"These projects are at different stages of development and commercial discussions are ongoing, and it would be premature to confirm specific timelines, projects or locations."
asserted
it → confirm → timelines
ISED said pricing and access arrangements have not yet been decided, although the government expects companies using the capacity to pay market-based rates.
asserted
companies → say → rates
The commitment is part of a broader federal strategy to support sovereign AI.
asserted
commitment → support → AI
In October, Ottawa also announced it would invest up to $1.6 billion in Toronto-based AI company Cohere
asserted
it → announce → Cohere
Clay Swerdelian, CEO of Calgary-based Verano.AI, said he'd welcome the opportunity to keep his company's computing operations in Canada, provided the price was right.
Verano.AI primarily supports the energy sector, using AI-powered tools to automate work related to regulatory matters.
asserted
AI → base → matters
Swerdelian says the company has developed their own AI agents and models to handle tasks involving confidential information, including enterprise data and methane emissions data that clients wouldn't want to share with external AI services.
asserted
clients → say → services
Clay Swerdelian is the CEO of Verano.AI based in Calgary which primarily supports the energy sector with AI-powered automation of workflow on regulatory matters.
asserted
which → base → matters
Swerdelian says he expects Canada to experience a "massive boom" when it comes to companies looking for computing power, partly driven by the recent U.S. midterm election results.
asserted
it → say → results
"A lot of the red states are now blue states and a lot of the blue states won't allow data centres, so they're shifting to Canada," he said.
asserted
he → allow → Canada
"And the place to be is Alberta for the most part, because the gas and all the land that we have and the infrastructure and everything is kind of built out already other than, of course, the data centres themselves."
asserted
we → have → centres
Given that growing demand, Swerdelian says Ottawa's proposed 500 megawatts of computing capacity could be a "drop in the bucket."
uncertain
megawatts → give → bucket
And with no firm timeline for when that capacity will become available, Mullin said Canadian startups may have little choice but to continue relying on computing services outside the country.
uncertain
startups → become → country
"These firms could try and just buy compute back from hyperscalers, and in many cases that may be south of the border and that just makes us more vulnerable as a country," he said.
uncertain
he → try → country
…and 2 more, not listed.