The world’s top international court has ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya Muslim minority, more than a million of whom remain displaced.
asserted
million → rule → whom
The verdict, issued Thursday, is the first time a state has been found responsible for committing genocide in the history of the International Court of Justice, which was established in 1945.
asserted
which → issue → 1945
In a weekslong military campaign in 2017, Myanmar forces killed at least 10,000 people, including up to 2,109 children under five, and forced more than 700,000 others to flee the country’s northern Rakhine State.
asserted
forces → kill → State
The landmark decision could have significant implications for the legal treatment of cases brought under the 1948 Genocide Convention, Melanie O’Brien, a professor of international law at the University of Western Australia Law School, tells TIME.
uncertain
O’Brien → have → TIME
That includes South Africa’s pending case alleging that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, where Israeli forces have killed tens of thousands of people over the past three years.
asserted
forces → include → years
A spokesperson for Myanmar President Min Aung Hlaing told reporters on Friday that the ruling is “unfair.”
asserted
ruling → tell → Friday
“It was not a decision made unanimously,” spokesperson Khine Khine Soe said, pointing out that six of the 15 judges dissented.
asserted
judges → make → ?
She did not say whether Myanmar would comply with the ruling.
asserted
Myanmar → say → ruling
Myanmar’s military junta-backed government denied committing genocide during the proceedings.
asserted
government → back → proceedings
The National Unity Government, a parallel government formed after Myanmar’s 2021 military coup, said on Thursday that it respects the judgment.
asserted
it → form → judgment
For the Rohingya, the ruling is “public acknowledgment in a court of law and in the top court in the world that what happened to them was genocide,” says O’Brien, who has published multiple books on genocide and international criminal law, is working on a book about the Genocide Convention in the ICJ.
asserted
who → happen → ICJ
Members of the Rohingya community also said the ruling is a historic recognition of the Rohingya as a distinct ethnic group.
asserted
ruling → say → group
“Myanmar denies the existence of the Rohingya,” Sayed Ullah, a community leader at a refugee camp in Bangladesh, told the Associated Press, “but now the court made it clear.
asserted
it → deny → Press
Two previous genocide cases brought before the ICJ have gone to the merit stages, both arising from the wars that followed the breakup of Yugoslavia in the 1990s.
asserted
that → bring → 1990s
In 2007, the court ruled on a case brought by Bosnia against Serbia.
asserted
court → rule → Serbia
The court determined that the killing of thousands of Bosniak men and boys in Srebrenica in 1995 was genocide, but it found insufficient evidence to attribute the killings by Bosnian Serb forces to Serbia.
asserted
it → determine → Serbia
Still, the court ruled that Serbia violated its obligation under the Genocide Convention by failing to use its influence over those forces to prevent genocide.
asserted
Serbia → rule → genocide
In the second case, which was brought by Croatia against Serbia, the court made no finding that genocide was committed.
asserted
genocide → bring → finding
It instead ruled in a 2015 judgment that Yugoslav army and Serb forces had an intent to ethnically cleanse Croats from Serb-held areas of Croatia, forcing between 80,000 and 100,000 Croats and other non-Serbs to flee the Krajina region between April 1991 and April 1992.
asserted
Croats → rule → April
“The Court has not rewritten or expanded the legal definition of genocide” since the earlier cases, Marko Milanovic, a professor of public international law at the University of Reading, said in a statement.
asserted
Milanovic → rewrite → statement
“What it has done is take a more flexible approach to the evidence used to establish genocide, particularly the notoriously difficult question of proving genocidal intent.”
asserted
done → do → intent
The dissenting judges argued that the evidence could support the intent of forced expulsion or collective punishment instead of an intent to destroy a substantial part of the group.
uncertain
evidence → dissent → group
What comes next for Myanmar
The court ordered Myanmar’s military-backed government to ensure the safe, voluntary return of the Rohingya to the country and prosecute those suspected of having committed genocide.
asserted
court → come → genocide
Myanmar has two years to report to the ICJ on its orders of restitution.
asserted
Myanmar → have → restitution
If it is unable to carry out restitution, the court ordered the government to pay reparations to the Rohingya, the amount of which will be determined at a later stage.
asserted
amount → carry → stage
It’s uncertain whether Myanmar will implement the ruling, which is legally binding.
asserted
which → ’ → ruling
“Therein lies the rub in that there isn’t necessarily a mechanism for enforcing them,” says O’Brien.
asserted
O’Brien → lie → them
If Myanmar does not comply, The Gambia, which brought the case to the ICJ, can turn to the United Nations Security Council, which has discretion over whether to act, although China, which has veto power as a member of the council, is friendly to the Myanmar government.
asserted
which → comply → government
Third party states can also exert pressure on Myanmar to comply with the ruling, such as through direct diplomatic pressure or sanctions on individuals or companies linked to the genocide.
asserted
states → exert → genocide
On Thursday, the U.K. ordered the expulsion of Myanmar’s defense attaché and called for an urgent U.N. Security Council meeting to discuss the judgment.
asserted
U.K. → order → judgment
ASEAN Parliamentarians for Human Rights (APHR), an independent group of current and former Southeast Asian parliamentarians, called on the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) to support implementation of the ruling.
asserted
Parliamentarians → call → ruling
Cheah Wui Ling, an associate professor at the National University of Singapore’s faculty of law, says ASEAN is obligated to “act in ways that respect and not undermine” the ruling, given the organization’s commitment to international law.
asserted
that → say → law
Cheah says the ruling could give “fresh momentum” to efforts seeking to hold individuals criminally accountable for the genocide, including an investigation in Argentina and a criminal complaint in Indonesia.
uncertain
individuals → say → Indonesia
The prosecutor at the International Criminal Court also requested an arrest warrant in 2024 for Min Aung Hlaing.
asserted
prosecutor → request → Hlaing
The ruling could have a “snowball effect” on that investigation, says Vincent-Joël Proulx, an associate professor at National University of Singapore’s faculty of law and a former special adviser to the ICJ’s president.
uncertain
Proulx → have → president
Even so, other challenges remain to seeing restitution through, O’Brien says.
asserted
O’Brien → remain → restitution
Nine years after the mass displacement, more than a million Rohingya refugees live in Bangladesh, with most in camps in Cox’s Bazar.
asserted
refugees → live → Bazar
Some refugees told the AP that they want to return home to Myanmar.
asserted
they → tell → Myanmar
But many of those homes and villages were completely destroyed, O’Brien says.
asserted
O’Brien → destroy → homes
“They have nothing physically to come back to.”
asserted
They → have → nothing
…and 31 more, not listed.