A US federal judge has ordered Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to stop sending religious messages to employees through her official government email account, ruling that her communications crossed boundaries by assuming that staff members shared her Christian beliefs.
asserted
members → order → beliefs
US District Judge Trina Thompson issued the order on Thursday while granting a preliminary injunction sought by federal employees who accused Rollins of using her position to promote Christianity within the Department of Agriculture (USDA).
asserted
who → issue → Agriculture
The judge said the secretary must recognise limits when communicating religious messages and cannot use her official authority to pressure subordinates.
asserted
secretary → say → subordinates
"The Court ORDERS that the Secretary must recognise certain boundaries when communicating religious messages," Thompson wrote in her ruling.
asserted
Thompson → order → ruling
The case was brought by seven USDA employees from different religious backgrounds, including those who do not identify with any religion.
asserted
who → bring → religion
They alleged that Rollins had sent increasingly religious messages to the department's entire workforce, making employees feel excluded and pressured to conform to her beliefs.
asserted
employees → allege → beliefs
Judge says Rollins crossed boundaries with Christian messages
According to the complaint, Rollins began sending department-wide holiday emails shortly after taking office.
uncertain
Rollins → say → office
Some of the messages included references to Jesus Christ, Christmas and the resurrection of Jesus.
asserted
Some → include → Jesus
In a Christmas message sent on December 23, 2025, Rollins said that the spirit of generosity came from "the very first Christmas when God gave us the greatest gift possible, the gift of his Son and our Savior Jesus Christ".
asserted
God → send → Son
In another message sent on Easter, April 5, 2026, she described the occasion as "the greatest story ever told" and referred to employees as being like the first disciples who encountered the risen Christ.
asserted
who → send → Christ
The employees argued that the messages amounted to government-sponsored religious promotion and violated the First Amendment's protections against the establishment of religion.
asserted
messages → argue → religion
Thompson agreed that the communications went too far, finding that they created pressure on employees to accept or appear to share the secretary's religious beliefs.
asserted
they → agree → beliefs
The judge also took issue with Rollins' repeated use of words such as "we", "us" and "our" in the messages, saying the language suggested that employees universally shared her Christian beliefs.
uncertain
employees → take → beliefs
She noted that the emails did not acknowledge employees who followed other religions or held no religious beliefs.
asserted
who → note → beliefs
The court also rejected the argument that employees could simply ignore the messages, pointing out that Rollins used the same official email account to communicate important departmental information, including agency restructuring and government shutdown plans.
uncertain
Rollins → reject → restructuring
The buck stops with Secretary Rollins," Thompson wrote, adding that her senior position warranted greater scrutiny because she sat at the top of the agency's hierarchy.
asserted
she → stop → hierarchy
The judge clarified that the order did not prevent Rollins from expressing her faith in her personal capacity or discussing religion with colleagues who were interested.
asserted
who → clarify → colleagues
USDA considers appeal as religious messaging sparks debate
The USDA said it was evaluating all available options, including filing an appeal, and described the ruling as a "completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary".
asserted
it → consider → Secretary
The department had argued that Rollins was merely sharing her personal views about religious holidays and was neither conducting religious exercises nor forcing employees to follow her beliefs.
asserted
Rollins → argue → beliefs
However, Thompson pointed to the department's own November 2025 guidance on religious expression in the workplace, saying Rollins should follow the boundaries outlined in her own directives.
asserted
Rollins → point → directives
The guidance allows employees to discuss their faith with interested colleagues but prohibits persistent unwanted religious advances and the use of official authority to pressure subordinates.
asserted
employees → allow → subordinates
The ruling comes amid a wider debate over the role of religion in the Trump administration.
asserted
ruling → come → administration
Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth has incorporated Christian prayer into activities at the Pentagon, while critics have accused administration officials of blurring the separation between religion and government.
asserted
critics → incorporate → religion
Advocates of church-state separation have also raised concerns over religious messaging by senior officials and the use of government platforms to promote Christianity.
asserted
Advocates → raise → Christianity
The USDA ruling, however, does not prevent Rollins from practising or expressing her faith privately.
asserted
ruling → prevent → faith
It restricts the use of her official government communication channels in ways that could amount to religious coercion in the workplace.
uncertain
that → restrict → workplace