Despite the labour market taking a turn with several Australian industry giants revealing thousands of job cuts within weeks or days of each other and unemployment figures hitting a five-year-high, economists say it’s not all because of AI.
asserted
it → take → AI
On Thursday, data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics showed unemployment reached 4.9 per cent in October, the highest in five years.
asserted
unemployment → show → years
This month, KPMG announced it would cut 230 jobs and about 20 partners, Bunnings said it would slash 350 local jobs, and David Jones revealed it would axe 1500 jobs by the end of this year.
asserted
it → announce → year
While National Australia Bank chief executive Andrew Irvine has denied that AI is driving the bank’s latest round of 2500 redundancies, some firms such as Qantas, which announced it would cut 850 positions under a deal with AI services provider Accenture, have suggested the technology – and the efficiencies it brings – is a key reason for trimming their workforces.
uncertain
it → deny → workforces
So, how much of the recent job cuts are a result of AI uptake by firms, is there likely to be more disruption to come, and what might the employment landscape look like over coming years?
uncertain
landscape → come → years
How much is AI to blame for recent job cuts?
asserted
AI → blame → cuts
While AI has played a part in some of the recent wave of redundancies and retrenchments, economists say it’s not the only reason that unemployment has ticked up.
asserted
unemployment → play → redundancies
Bob Breunig, director of the Tax and Transfer Policy Institute at the Australian National University, says interest rates, which hit 4.85 per cent – the highest level since the global financial crisis – after the Reserve Bank lifted them for the fifth time this year, are one key factor.
asserted
Bank → say → time
“Interest rates are really starting to bite,” he says.
asserted
he → start → ?
“People pull back spending meaning retail has been hit, and some job losses are attributable to that.”
Major retailers such as David Jones, for example, have been squeezed by mounting debt and a slowdown in household spending.
Melbourne University labour economist Jeff Borland says while interest rates have played a major role, AI has also led to some job cuts.
“There have definitely been some retrenchments to do with AI,” he says, noting it is “very believable” for companies such as Canva – which earlier this month announced more than 1200 people would either lose their jobs, be asked to relocate or change roles – to have been disrupted by AI given software designers are among the most exposed to the technology.
asserted
designers → pull → technology
However, Borland also notes that some companies are likely dressing up job losses to avoid stronger backlash for offshoring.
asserted
companies → note → offshoring
“Historically, it’s often convenient for businesses to make job cuts and say it’s because of new technology coming along rather than saying they are offshoring jobs because that’s cheaper,” he says.
Australia Institute co-chief executive Richard Denniss also says one of the major drivers of recent job losses has been the Reserve Bank’s continued interest rates rises, which are aimed at dampening inflation but have also slowed the economy.
However, Denniss says some business leaders are likely packaging up job losses as a response to AI even when it is not the primary reason for their job cuts.
asserted
it → ’ → cuts
“Two things are happening at the same time: old-fashioned offshoring in pursuit of lower wages and reducing costs, and the need to convince investors that the company is preparing for AI,” he says.
asserted
he → happen → AI
“Chief executives, such as at WiseTech and Telstra, are deliberately trying to signal they are forward-looking and gearing up for an AI revolution.
asserted
they → try → revolution
They have to tell a story that they will not be eaten or threatened by AI, but enhanced by it.
asserted
they → have → it
Will AI lead to more job losses?
asserted
AI → lead → losses
Evidence of mass job losses has not yet emerged in Australia, but there are signs of a hiring slowdown, especially in some occupations and programs.
asserted
Evidence → emerge → occupations
Borland says looking at countries such as the US suggests there may be more disruption and job losses to come from AI uptake.
uncertain
looking → say → uptake
“We might not be able to predict the exact extent or timing, but the US, which is ahead of us, can give us an indication.
uncertain
which → predict → indication
Breunig says the main immediate effect of AI on the jobs market is slower growth in employment rather than widespread job losses.
asserted
effect → say → losses
“We’re not yet seeing a lot of firing because of AI, but we are seeing downward revision in hiring because of AI,” he said, noting some big banks and consultancy firms he has spoken to have cut down their graduate intakes, specifically citing AI.
asserted
he → see → AI
“Mass unemployment is not an unintended consequence of the AI boom, it’s the business plan.
asserted
it → ’ → boom
Denniss does not have a prediction for the extent of job losses from AI uptake, but believes the Reserve Bank is “massively underestimating” the effect of AI on the labour market.
asserted
Bank → have → market
“The only reason Anthropic and Open AI can be worth a trillion dollars is if businesses and government departments replace millions of workers with AI, swapping their wage bill for an AI bill,” he says.
asserted
he → replace → bill
“Mass unemployment is not an unintended consequence of the AI boom, it’s the business plan [for AI companies].
asserted
it → ’ → companies
Either companies such as Anthropic are not worth as much as markets think, or there are a hell of a lot of job losses to come.”
How will AI change employment?
Although AI has led to some job losses, like most technologies, it is likely to create demand for new jobs and change the nature of the work we do.
asserted
we → think → work
“It could go either way,” Bruenig says.
uncertain
Bruenig → go → ?
“Every time new technology is introduced, old jobs die and new jobs emerge, but it’s really hard to predict what those new jobs will look like.”
asserted
jobs → introduce → what
Breunig also says it may affect some intakes such as graduate programs more than others, and that it could change how jobs are done or the skills – such as softer human skills – that are sought after.
uncertain
that → say → skills
Borland says while some jobs such as computer or mathematics related fields and office administration – and tasks such as research and translating or summarising documents – may be more exposed to AI displacement, the effect may be more complex.
uncertain
effect → say → displacement
“Automation can reduce employment, but it can also complement other tasks that require humans, making them more productive, creating new tasks and driving demand,” he says.
asserted
he → reduce → demand
“And if it increases real incomes, and money gets spent – especially on things humans produce – demand for labour in those areas may grow.”
uncertain
demand → increase → areas
The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion.
asserted
newsletter → deliver → stories