Last month, religious leaders from across San Francisco gathered behind closed doors to discuss what it means to be human in the age of artificial intelligence.
asserted
it → gather → intelligence
Anthropic, the AI company operating only a couple of miles from my parish, has been courting priests, rabbis and theologians.
asserted
Anthropic → operate → priests
Its billionaire cofounder, Christopher Olah, has even pressed Vatican advisers to take seriously the possibility that his company’s chatbot might possess consciousness.
uncertain
chatbot → press → consciousness
As a priest, I find this pursuit deeply troubling.
asserted
pursuit → find → priest
I welcome serious conversations about AI’s moral implications, especially theological ones.
asserted
I → welcome → implications
But the extraordinary effort to establish whether a machine might have consciousness, or possess a soul, reveals a profound misunderstanding of what makes us human.
uncertain
us → establish → misunderstanding
Our souls and minds and bodies are so much more than the tasks we perform.
asserted
we → perform → tasks
We as humans make mistakes, sometimes catastrophic ones, and then we may or may not try to correct course.
uncertain
we → make → course
We may double down in stubbornness, insisting on our rightness.
uncertain
We → double → rightness
We express ourselves, connect with others, reproduce, indulge, purge; we strive toward a goal, transform in an encounter, make vows, renege them, encounter the void, try to fill it, fail, drown out the dread, and go about the humdrum tasks of everyday life as honestly as we can.
asserted
we → express → life
From a young age, we are nurtured and protected by our caregivers.
asserted
we → nurture → caregivers
We experience beauty and sit with mysteries.
asserted
We → experience → mysteries
We do not exist merely for utility.
asserted
We → exist → utility
Artificial intelligence could never replicate the transcendent mundanity of who we are.
uncertain
we → replicate → mundanity
Even if every synapse in our brains were externally replicated, even if the perfect AI configuration were designed to duplicate our central nervous system, it would still lack divine spark.
asserted
it → replicate → spark
Artificial intelligence is formed as commerce, pure utility.
asserted
intelligence → form → commerce
Its existence requires enormous concentrations of capital, infrastructure, and the accumulated intelligence of humanity.
asserted
existence → require → humanity
It’s an ongoing economic choice, driven by pursuit of profit, hope for a better world, and sociopolitical fear.
asserted
It → ’ → world
If a model doesn’t make a good return, it’s cast aside.
asserted
it → make → return
Whatever the sincere hopes of its creators, AI is being developed within an economic system that increasingly measures the worth of everything solely by its productivity.
asserted
that → develop → productivity
That is what makes Silicon Valley’s fascination with the spirituality of its machines so strange.
asserted
fascination → make → machines
Its founders are turning to religious leaders to ask whether their creations might possess consciousness, how they might be taught goodness, even whether they should learn to confess their wrongdoings.
uncertain
they → turn → wrongdoings
Yet the very traditions they are consulting have spent millennia teaching us that goodness cannot be reduced to a set of behaviors, any more than the soul of humanity, as magnificent and ineffable as it is, can be replicated by a machine.
asserted
it → consult → machine
And while Silicon Valley seeks to establish the humanity of its products, it seems increasingly comfortable treating actual human beings as little more than instruments of production.
Consider confession, a practice Anthropic researchers have reportedly considered teaching their models.
uncertain
researchers → seek → models
In Christianity, confession demands more than acknowledging a mistake or expressing regret.
asserted
confession → demand → regret
It requires us to confront the harm we’ve caused, seek forgiveness, and strive to change how we live.
asserted
we → require → forgiveness
If Silicon Valley’s founders want to learn from this tradition, they might begin by asking what they themselves have to confess about the technologies they’re unleashing upon the world.
uncertain
they → want → world
So how do we counter this impoverished vision of humanity?
asserted
we → counter → humanity
Well, I have a radical suggestion for all of us, but especially the tech billionaires searching for answers in Christianity.
asserted
I → have → Christianity
If you stop trying to be effective and instead strive to be good – that is, to be truly human, reflecting God’s light – you will be surprised by the joy that enters into the depths of your soul.
asserted
that → stop → soul
In the sacraments, prayers, beauty and mystery of the liturgy, and the shared life of faith, we encounter a vision of humanity that resists the relentless demand to be useful.
asserted
that → share → demand
We receive the body of Christ and strive to become more like him.
asserted
We → receive → him
We turn toward a world where justice and mercy kiss, where renewal and forgiveness are continually possible.
asserted
renewal → turn → world
When you leave church, carry those teachings back to your offices and boardrooms.
asserted
you → leave → offices
Ask how the decisions you make affect the poor, the workers whose livelihoods are being transformed, and the neighbors who will never share in your wealth.
asserted
who → ask → wealth
The mystery of the Christian faith is inseparable from its demands upon how we live.
asserted
we → live → demands
You cannot claim to embrace its wisdom while setting aside the obligations it places upon you.
uncertain
it → claim → you
Human worth is not rooted in what we produce, and our minds were not created to be quarried for profit.
asserted
minds → root → profit
We were created, in the words of Jesus and all the prophets, to love God and our neighbors.
asserted
We → create → God
The great moral question facing Silicon Valley is not whether its machines can become more like us.
asserted
machines → face → us
…and 1 more, not listed.