Photo via Reason

Critics of AR-15 Bans Urge SCOTUS To Reject the 7th Circuit's Distinction Between Civilian and Military Arms

Read the original at Reason ↗
Cite

Sullum, J. (2026, September 11). Critics of AR-15 Bans Urge SCOTUS To Reject the 7th Circuit's Distinction Between Civilian and Military Arms. Reason. https://reason.com/2026/09/10/critics-of-ar-15-bans-urge-scotus-to-reject-the-7th-circuits-distinction-between-civilian-and-military-arms/

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Reason · collected 2026-09-11 · by Jacob Sullum

Quick Summary

The U.S. Solicitor General D. John Sauer is urging the Supreme Court to reject an Illinois ban on AR-15s, arguing that such a distinction between civilian and military arms is misguided and ahistorical. Sauer claims that the founders would have been surprised by the idea of banning common-use arms like the AR-15 if they can also be used for military purposes. The case, Viramontes v. Cook County, involves a similar Connecticut law targeting "assault weapons", which includes AR-15s and semi-automatic rifles. Several briefs, including one from the Cato Institute, argue that the Second Amendment protects the right to possess such arms for common defense and individual self-defense.
Written by AI on 2026-09-11, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit upheld an AR-15 ban in Cook County, Illinois, ruling that the gun falls on the "military side" of a line between civilian and military arms. However, Solicitor General D. John Sauer has filed a brief with the Supreme Court arguing that this distinction is misguided and ahistorical, suggesting that the founders would be surprised by such a claim. Sauer's brief points out that the Second Amendment is connected to the idea of a well-regulated militia, which implies that weapons useful in defense against invaders or tyrants should also be protected under the amendment. Several other briefs have elaborated on this point, highlighting the importance of common defense and the founders' intention to include arms "in common use" in the Second Amendment's protections. The case is currently before the Supreme Court, which will decide whether to reject Cook County's rifle restrictions.

Written for “AR-15 Gun Control Debate” on 2026-11-21, grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 17% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
Reason
Hedges 2 of 18 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A discusses a future Supreme Court decision on 'assault weapon' bans, while Article B refers to a past 7th Circuit decision and its implications for SCOTUS”
Reason
Hedges 11 of 37 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A discusses a court case (Bondi v. VanDerStok) and another case (Defense Distributed v. Blanche), while Article B mentions a different court case (7th Circuit's decision in Cook County, Illinois) with no direct connection to the cases mentioned in Article A.”

Story

AR-15 Gun Control Debate
Politics · 1 article(s) covering the same event.
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
54
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
17%
9 of 54 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
withheld
no quote in the article backed the model's score
Publisher signals
67/100
Reason's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-11 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Reason · 1464 article(s) · 4 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 4 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Jacob Sullum
45 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Contrary to the implication of that label, the initiative affected many people who had no criminal convictions that would justify revoking their visas.
Trump also averred that his projects do not involve much money, although the ballroom alone is expected to cost around $600 million, half of which will be covered by taxpayers.
Last week, the city of Delray Beach, Florida, announced that it will not organize or sponsor next year's St. Patrick's Day parade, citing a state law that takes effect on January 1.
That means SSJC members cannot even legally transport their guns to the vicinity of the synagogue on those occasions, since they would pass within 300 feet of parks, schools, and other houses of worship while walking there.
In a 60 Minutes interview that aired on Sunday night, President Donald Trump conceded that his mass deportation campaign may have contributed to the Republican rout in last week's midterm elections because "a lot of people think it's too tough."
2026-11-11 · assertive framing · Trump Debates Mass Deportation With Himself
They say Hegseth is flouting the law, undermining basic principles of justice, and perverting the mission of the U.S. military by treating civilians as combatants who can be killed at will, from a distance and in cold blood, without any semblance of due process.
Attorney General Todd Blanche nevertheless seemed to reinforce Trump's threat during an interview on CNN's State of the Union yesterday, saying members of the House Oversight Committee, which will be chaired by Rep. Robert Garcia (D–Calif.) in the next congressional session, should "be very worried."
President Donald Trump today announced that Stephen Miller will replace Susie Wiles as White House chief of staff.
Like many other police officers in New Mexico, Paul Jessen Jr., a Bernalillo County sheriff's deputy, was willing to accept bribes from Albuquerque defense attorney Thomas J. Clear III in exchange for compromising DWI cases against Clear's clients.
These results might be dismissed as anomalous, the product of anger at the party of an unpopular president whose war, tariff, and deportation policies, combined with his constant self-aggrandizement and presidential profiteering, alienated Americans who otherwise might have voted for Republicans.
Also by Jacob Sullum
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 45 articles by Jacob Sullum →

Topics

Cook County The Second Amendment the 7th Circuit the Second Amendment's the Supreme Court

Subjects

the Supreme Court ORG · 4× Heller PERSON · 3× Sauer PERSON · 3× the 7th Circuit ORG · 3× Cook County GPE · 2× Illinois GPE · 2× Miller PERSON · 2× Viramontes PERSON · 2× D. John Sauer PERSON · 1× the U.S. Court of Appeals ORG · 1×

Narrative

At the Founding, the "well regulated militia," which was viewed as a safeguard against the dangers posed by a standing army and a potentially oppressive national government, included all able-bodied men, who "were expected to appear bearing arms supplied by themselves and of the kind in common use," as the Supreme Court explained in the 1939 case United States v. Miller.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-11
"The founders would have been astonished at the claim that legislatures may ban arms in common use if those arms can also be used for military purposes," he writes.

Claims (54 extracted, 9 hedged)

The Second Amendment does not cover "military-grade weapons," the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit averred last year, when it upheld an AR-15 ban enacted by Cook County, Illinois. asserted
it → cover → County
The ruling reaffirmed the reasoning of a 2023 decision in which the 7th Circuit distinguished between civilian and military arms, saying the "assault weapons" that Illinois had banned "lie on the military side of that line. asserted
Illinois → reaffirm → line
That distinction is misguided and ahistorical, Solicitor General D. John Sauer argues in a brief urging the Supreme Court to reject Cook County's rifle restrictions. asserted
Sauer → argue → restrictions
"The founders would have been astonished at the claim that legislatures may ban arms in common use if those arms can also be used for military purposes," he writes. uncertain
he → astonish → purposes
Several briefs in that case, Viramontes v. Cook County, elaborate on Sauer's point, highlighting the Second Amendment's connection to "a well regulated militia," which implies that a weapon's usefulness in that context counts in favor of concluding that Americans have a constitutional right to possess it. asserted
Americans → elaborate → it
Relatedly, the briefs note that the Second Amendment's purposes include common defense against invaders, insurrectionists, and tyrants as well as individual self-defense against criminal predators. asserted
purposes → note → predators
The Supreme Court is considering Viramontes along with Grant v. Higgins, which involves a similar Connecticut law. asserted
which → consider → law
Both laws target "assault weapons," which they define to include AR-15s and similar semi-automatic rifles. asserted
they → target → AR-15s
Those rifles, the petitioners argue, are plainly covered by the Second Amendment because they are "in common use" for "lawful purposes like self-defense"—the test that the Supreme Court applied when it overturned the District of Columbia's handgun ban in 2008. asserted
it → argue → 2008
The Court's decision in District of Columbia v. Heller focused on the use of handguns "in defense of hearth and home." asserted
decision → focus → hearth
But as Sauer notes, Heller acknowledged that the Second Amendment also "protects the right to possess arms so that they are available for the common defense—i.e., for 'repelling invasions,' 'suppressing insurrections,' and 'resist[ing] tyranny.' asserted
they → note → tyranny
The Second Amendment's prefatory clause, which describes "a well regulated militia" as "necessary to the security of a free state," indicates that "the founders codified the right precisely because it would promote 'the security of a free State' by enabling armed common defense," Sauer writes. asserted
Sauer → describe → defense
"The founding generation understood that the individual right to keep and bear arms 'helped to secure the ideal of a citizen militia, which might be necessary to oppose an oppressive military force if the constitutional order broke down.' uncertain
order → found → force
The Cato Institute's brief in Viramontes emphasizes that theme. asserted
brief → emphasize → theme
"Although Heller's holding [regarding] guns in 'common use' for self-defense resolves this case," Cato attorneys Matthew Cavedon, Clark Neily, and Dan Greenberg say, "the Second Amendment protects AR-15s for a further reason: they are suited to the reserve militia"—i.e., "the entire population of 'citizens capable of bearing arms.' asserted
they → regard → arms
At the Founding, the "well regulated militia," which was viewed as a safeguard against the dangers posed by a standing army and a potentially oppressive national government, included all able-bodied men, who "were expected to appear bearing arms supplied by themselves and of the kind in common use," as the Supreme Court explained in the 1939 case United States v. Miller. asserted
Court → regulate → Miller
Although Miller upheld the federal ban on short-barreled shotguns, its rationale was that the petitioner had failed to show that such weapons were "part of the ordinary military equipment or that [their] use could contribute to the common defense." uncertain
use → uphold → defense
The implication was that arms are covered by the Second Amendment if they meet that test. asserted
they → cover → test
Cavedon et al. argue that the AR-15 does, as the 7th Circuit implicitly conceded. asserted
Circuit → argue → ?
The features of the AR-15 "align with those of the small arms historically used by the reserve militia," they say, and that counts as "an independent reason for constitutional protection." asserted
that → align → protection
In declaring the militia "necessary to the security of a free state," the Framers were not talking merely about repelling invasions or maintaining law and order. asserted
Framers → declare → law
"A 'free state' meant a republic or constitutional monarchy, not despotic rule," Cavedon et al. note. asserted
. → mean → republic
"The Amendment checked military power and would deter tyranny. asserted
Amendment → check → tyranny
The Second Amendment "was enacted so 'the people could resist oppression' as well as private violence," Cavedon et al. say, citing a 2014 Indiana Law Journal article by Robert Leider, now a professor at George Mason University's Antonin Scalia Law School. uncertain
. → enact → School
"William Blackstone wrote that the right to keep arms was a way to combat 'the violence of oppression.' asserted
right → write → oppression
Blackstone was alluding to the people's remedy against tyranny: armed resistance. asserted
Blackstone → allude → tyranny
The Founders were "suspicious of standing armies," Cavedon et al. note. asserted
. → stand → armies
"The reserve militia would reduce 'civil-military tensions' and deter the prospect of devolution into tyranny that was thought to be inherent in democracy. asserted
that → reduce → democracy
This cultural outlook was a pillar of civic republicanism, and it was meant to ensure that the people 'could readily resist' any government oppression. uncertain
people → mean → oppression
Historically, that background guided courts in deciding which arms are covered by the Second Amendment and state analogs. asserted
arms → guide → Amendment
"Even for courts with a relatively narrow understanding of the right to keep and bear arms," Cavedon et al. say, "the suitability of arms for militia use weighed in favor of their protection. asserted
suitability → keep → protection
Courts consistently protected 'rifles, muskets, and army pistols.' asserted
Courts → protect → rifles
The upshot: "Arms suited for militia service are not outside the Second Amendment's protection. asserted
Arms → suit → protection
Although the features triggering the bans at issue here focus more on comfort than on martial effectiveness, the usefulness of such arms for militia service should weigh in favor of Second Amendment protection." The Cato brief addresses concerns about the potentially "absurd" implications of that principle, such as the possibility that Second Amendment could be construed to protect "the private ownership of nuclear weaponry, warplanes, or ballistic rocketry." uncertain
Amendment → trigger → weaponry
Since Heller restricts the Second Amendment to "bearable arms," that scenario seems implausible. asserted
scenario → restrict → arms
As understood in Heller, the Second Amendment was "not meant to equalize the strength of the reserve militia compared with that of the nation's military," Cavedon et al. write. asserted
. → understand → military
"Rather, Heller protects Americans by preserving access to 'the sorts of lawful weapons that they possessed at home' for use in militia duty." asserted
they → protect → duty
Although "it may be true that no amount of small arms could be useful against modern-day bombers and tanks," the Supreme Court said in that case, "the fact that modern developments have limited the degree of fit between the prefatory clause and the protected right cannot change our interpretation of the right." uncertain
developments → say → right
Cavedon et al. add that "semiautomatic rifles using the AR-15 platform," which fire just one round per trigger pull, are "easily distinguishable" from machine guns, which fire continuously. asserted
which → add → guns
"A restriction on fully automatic firing 'narrowly regulates' a potential use without banning 'an entire class of weapons,'" the brief says. asserted
brief → regulate → weapons
…and 14 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support