A US lawmaker has asked a federal judge to order President Donald Trump's administration to release nearly 200 text messages and other records linked to the Kennedy Center in Washington, according to the Associated Press.
uncertain
lawmaker → ask → Press
Democratic lawmaker Joyce Beatty wants communications involving senior officials and the performing arts centre's management examined as she challenges plans to close the building for renovations.
asserted
she → want → renovations
The request comes months after the same judge ruled that Trump's name had been illegally added to the Center and ordered its removal.
asserted
name → come → removal
Beatty, an Ohio Democrat who serves as an ex officio member of the Kennedy Center's board, filed the latest request through her lawyers on Sunday.
asserted
who → serve → Sunday
She argues that the messages could help establish how closely Trump was involved in decisions concerning the centre, including its planned closure.
uncertain
Trump → argue → closure
Meanwhile, the Trump administration has maintained that the communications should remain confidential under executive privilege.
asserted
communications → maintain → privilege
The legal protection allows presidents to withhold certain official discussions.
asserted
presidents → allow → discussions
What court filings reveal about the messages
The latest filing identifies two sets of text messages involving Matt Floca, the Kennedy Center's executive director and CEO.
asserted
filing → reveal → Floca
Both sets concern the institution's affairs, but the people involved and the timing of some exchanges have drawn particular attention from Beatty's lawyers.
asserted
people → concern → lawyers
One set contains 19 messages between Floca and Natalie Harp, Trump's executive assistant.
asserted
set → contain → Floca
Eleven of these were exchanged on September 15, when Kennedy Center's board voted for a third time to close the facility.
asserted
board → exchange → facility
The other set, considerably larger, consists of approximately 180 texts involving Floca and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick.
asserted
set → consist → Floca
The contents of the messages have not been disclosed.
asserted
contents → disclose → messages
However, the list of records has led Beatty's legal team to argue that Trump may have been in frequent communication with Kennedy Center officials, directly or through others.
uncertain
Trump → lead → others
The lawyers want the court to consider these communications while examining how the closure decisions were made.
asserted
decisions → want → communications
“These communications directly bear on the issues before the Court, and the claim of privilege cannot stand,” they wrote.
uncertain
they → bear → privilege
Trump says records should remain private
Earlier in October, the Justice Department explained its position on the withheld communications.
asserted
Department → say → communications
As reported by ABC News' Good Morning America, the administration argued that Trump has an official role in the Kennedy Center's operations because of his authority to appoint members of its board.
asserted
Trump → report → board
It also said that this responsibility allows him to assess how the institution is being managed.
asserted
institution → say → ?
Federal law allows the president to appoint members of the centre's board.
asserted
president → allow → board
The administration says that responsibility includes assessing whether those members are properly managing the institution.
asserted
members → say → institution
Deputy White House Counsel Josh Hoyt also addressed the confidentiality issue in a sworn declaration.
asserted
Hoyt → address → declaration
His explanation extended the administration's claim of executive privilege to discussions with advisers outside government, as well as government officials.
uncertain
explanation → extend → government
Beatty's lawyers have rejected the broad application of the privilege arguing that the administration has not established sufficient grounds to keep the requested material from the court proceedings.
asserted
administration → reject → proceedings
Dispute over Trump's name
The dispute began before the latest disagreement over confidential records.
asserted
dispute → begin → records
Trump became chairman of the Kennedy Center last year after board members aligned with him selected him for the position.
asserted
members → become → position
His name was later added to the building.
asserted
name → add → building
In May, Judge Cooper ruled that the name had been added unlawfully and directed that it be removed.
uncertain
it → rule → May
The court also examined plans for a two-year renovation closure.
asserted
court → examine → closure
Cooper also blocked the two-year closure approved by the board in March, finding that members had not properly considered its impact on the centre's finances and programming.
asserted
members → block → finances
The Justice Department later asked the judge to lift that restriction so renovations could proceed.
uncertain
renovations → ask → restriction
Trump has also argued that the building was in dangerous condition and required extensive work.
asserted
building → argue → work
He has even said it may need to be “ripped down.”
uncertain
it → say → ?
Board voted to close centre
The legal restrictions did not end the disagreement over the building's future.
asserted
restrictions → vote → future
On September 15, the Kennedy Center's board voted again in favour of closing the facility.
asserted
board → vote → facility
The following day, Floca ordered a temporary closure of the main building.
asserted
Floca → order → building
Cooper responded by requiring the Kennedy Center to provide 30 days' notice before carrying out major physical changes to the property.
asserted
Cooper → respond → property
Several messages between Floca and Harp were exchanged on the day of the board's vote.
asserted
messages → exchange → vote
Beatty's lawyers now want to examine the withheld communications as part of their challenge to the administration's actions.
asserted
lawyers → want → actions
The Aporia
