A federal judge has ordered a top Department of Justice official back into court after President Donald Trump posted on his social media account affirming that East Potomac Golf Course will close Nov. 15 for renovations — directly contradicting repeated assertions from administration officials in a hearing last week.
asserted
Course → order → hearing
District Judge Ana Reyes has ordered Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward to clarify whether his prior statements to her that there were no plans to close the course remain accurate.
asserted
statements → order → course
She further ordered Woodward's attendance at a hearing either Friday or Monday where she is expected to press the government for more updates on its compliance with her injunction barring further construction at East Potomac.
asserted
she → order → Potomac
In a sharply worded 70-page ruling, Reyes criticized the Trump administration over its plans for the historic golf course in Washington, D.C., and concluded the administration likely violated environmental laws in the process.
asserted
administration → word → process
"Rarely, if ever, has the United States Department of Justice urged a federal court not to believe the sitting President," Reyes wrote.
asserted
Reyes → urge → President
"Not to believe him that a cabinet secretary has 'developed' a federal land project.
asserted
secretary → believe → project
Not to believe him that the secretary's agency will destroy a historic golf course already on the land.
asserted
agency → believe → land
Not to believe him that 'Restoration work' will begin 'IMMEDIATELY!'
asserted
work → believe → him
Not to believe him that the course 'will be closed' for over a year.
asserted
course → believe → year
Not to believe what the President has repeatedly told the American public.
asserted
President → believe → public
The case began over golf and long walks, Reyes said, but has now morphed into an effort to reconcile sworn statements made by members of the administration with statements made by Trump.
asserted
Reyes → begin → Trump
The administration must give "ten business days' written advance notice before making any irreparable modification to any forms or features of East Potomac Park, pending the outcome of this litigation," Reyes said.
asserted
Reyes → give → litigation
Hours before the hearing was set to start, the president had posted on social media that construction on East Potomac Golf Course would begin immediately, despite the administration suggesting to the court that it would not.
asserted
it → set → court
"If, as DOJ insists, President Trump is wrong, Secretary Burgum can just say so," Reyes wrote.
asserted
Reyes → insist → ?
"He has not.
asserted
He → have → ?
That said, at this juncture Plaintiffs carry the burden of showing a final plan likely exists.
asserted
plan → say → burden
They have done so.
asserted
They → do → ?
This is confirmed not just by the President's and Secretary's many posts, but also by the Government's actions, not the least of which is the removal of hundreds of healthy, non-invasive trees on no real notice.
asserted
least → confirm → notice
"
The tree removal had been scheduled a week earlier, but Reyes concluded that those involved in the lawsuit had little notice to stop the cutting.
asserted
those → schedule → cutting
The administration also likely violated environmental laws — specifically the National Environmental Policy Act -- by "segmenting" the environmental impacts of the construction, she said.
asserted
she → violate → construction
Trump said his administration will appeal the ruling, insisting he will move forward with his plans to shut down the course on Nov. 15 to start the project.
"We are closing the East Potomac Golf Course Site as scheduled on November 15th in order to renovate and rebuild for Competitive (with other such projects!), Safety, Modernization, and Aesthetic reasons," Trump wrote on his social media platform overnight.
asserted
Trump → say → platform
He said the judge's request for updates is "unconstitutional.
asserted
request → say → updates
"We believe this Project is totally 'as of right,' and that the judge does not have the Constitutional Right to 'ask for or receive notices,' which are time-consuming, unnecessary, expensive, and unconstitutional.
asserted
which → believe → notices
We will immediately appeal this decision," Trump wrote.
asserted
Trump → appeal → decision
During a gaggle with reporters on Monday night after his Mississippi rally, Trump also said he has a "go-ahead" to work on the renovations and blasted the judge for being an "architectural critic of golf courses."
"It's not my golf course, it's a public course being built in Washington D.C. and it has a go-ahead," Trump said.
asserted
Trump → say → ahead
He added that the current public course is "extremely dangerous to play" because it is too close together and that he was asking the D.C. Circuit Court for "immediate remedy."
asserted
he → add → remedy
The Aporia
