A federal judge on Monday barred the Trump administration from removing trees from East Potomac Golf Links in Washington, D.C., in a colorful ruling that follows a weekslong controversy over President Trump's plans to overhaul the publicly owned course.
asserted
that → bar → course
"The Court earlier stated, 'I am not the Lorax.
asserted
I → state → ?
I do not speak for the trees,'" U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes wrote.
asserted
Reyes → speak → trees
"The Court still does not speak for the trees.
asserted
Court → speak → trees
It speaks only for the rule of law."
asserted
It → speak → law
In a 70-page preliminary injunction ruling, Reyes prohibited the government from "removing or damaging" any trees on the golf course while a lawsuit challenging the renovation plan works its way through the court system.
asserted
lawsuit → prohibit → system
The judge also required 10 days' notice before the government makes "any irreparable modification" to the course.
asserted
government → require → course
The judge had previously
.Mr
asserted
judge → have → ?
. Trump has sought to overhaul the golf course — which sits beside the Potomac River — for months, pitching a "World Class Championship Golf Course" fit to host high-profile professional tournaments instead of the current "dysfunctional" course.
asserted
which → seek → course
The D.C. Preservation League sued over the planned changes to the course, arguing the government violated the National Environmental Policy Act by failing to analyze the project's impacts.
asserted
government → sue → impacts
Reyes has sparred with the government since it
earlier this month with little notice to the court or plaintiffs.
asserted
Reyes → spar → court
In a hearing two weeks ago, after more than 430 trees were felled, the judge told lawyers for the government that they had "lost credibility," and she was "furious" and "thoroughly unamused.
asserted
she → fell → credibility
. Trump reopen in 15 months.
asserted
Trump → reopen → months
He later said work would begin "IMMEDIATELY."
asserted
work → say → ?
the course would close for construction beginning in November, and it wouldIn her ruling Monday, Reyes argued Mr. Trump's statements about the renovation plans were tough to square with government lawyers' position that it's legally too early to challenge the plans in court because there was no final decision.
asserted
it → close → court
"Rarely, if ever, has the United States Department of Justice urged a federal court not to believe the sitting President," she wrote.
asserted
she → urge → President
"This started as a case about golf.
asserted
This → start → golf
That good walk spoiled.
asserted
walk → spoil → ?
But it has become much more.
asserted
it → become → ?
It now forces the Court to reconcile assertions by President Donald J. Trump with the sworn testimony of multiple government employees and the argument of senior Department of Justice attorneys.
asserted
It → force → attorneys
"
Reyes said she was initially reluctant to intervene in the case, writing that she "would much prefer not to have to resolve Lorax v. Once‑ler redux" — a reference to an earlier court hearing in which Reyes invoked the Dr. Seuss character to explain why she wasn't interested in micromanaging the federal government's tree management efforts.
asserted
she → say → efforts
She said she only intervened "because the Government did what it assured all it would not do," by chopping down hundreds of trees on the golf course.
asserted
it → say → course
Reyes found that the D.C. Preservation League is likely to succeed in showing the Trump administration's plans for the golf course violate the legal requirement for an environmental review.
asserted
plans → find → review
She also found that the tree-cutting efforts were part of the renovation plan.
asserted
efforts → find → plan
The judge said she did not find statements by the Department of Interior's deputy chief of staff to be credible, including his description of the agency's tree management plan as "cleaning up" the course.
asserted
statements → say → course
CBS News has reached out to the Justice Department and the Department of Interior for comment.
asserted
News → reach → comment
Mr. Trump has feuded with Reyes, calling her a "crazed lunatic."
asserted
Trump → feud → her
Earlier this month, the Trump administration asked Reyes to recuse herself from the case, arguing that she had shown "open hostility" to the government and that her "histrionics in prior hearings have clearly demonstrated she is no longer impartial."
"To name just a few examples of bias, Judge Reyes has unfairly questioned Trump Administration attorneys' intelligence, allowed her disdain for the Trump Administration to influence how hearings unfold, and systematically disregarded basic separation of powers principles and Article III constraints on judicial authority," government attorneys wrote.
asserted
attorneys → ask → authority
Reyes rejected that request and denied that she is biased, listing out compliments that she has paid government lawyers.
asserted
she → reject → lawyers
"So what happened?
asserted
what → happen → ?
Not sudden onset bias," Reyes wrote in her denial.
asserted
Reyes → write → denial
"Instead, the Government decided to remove over 500 healthy, non-invasive trees from East Potomac Golf Course.
asserted
Government → decide → Course
It waited until 4:55 p.m. on the Friday of a holiday weekend to give notice that it would begin removing trees within 15 hours.
asserted
it → wait → hours
It removed nearly 430 trees in one day and would have destroyed hundreds more but for a rain delay."
asserted
It → remove → delay
The Aporia
