For years, political analysts across the board, from pro-Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) commentators to supposedly neutral and anti-PTI observers, insisted that PTI was the most popular political party in the country.
asserted
PTI → insist → country
This narrative was even widely echoed by Western media outlets.
asserted
narrative → echo → outlets
Lately, however, that conviction has eroded.
asserted
conviction → erode → ?
Commentators first began backtracking by limiting their claims about PTI’s dominance to Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP), but even that has started to falter.
uncertain
that → begin → Pakhtunkhwa
What many mistook for widespread support may simply have been what political scientists refer to as “manufactured popularity.”
uncertain
scientists → mistook → popularity
Instead, it is a carefully crafted construct accumulated through symbolic engineering, media management, state or institutional sponsorship, and the strategic exploitation of public disillusionment.
asserted
it → craft → disillusionment
At its core, manufactured popularity depends on presenting a leader as a spotless saviour, who is capable of dismantling a ‘corrupt’ old order.
asserted
who → manufacture → order
This form of popularity is built on exaggerated promises and carefully curated media narratives.
asserted
form → build → promises
But the moment an engineered project makes the transition from opposition to executive power, tensions between rhetoric and governance begin to dissolve the illusion.
asserted
tensions → engineer → illusion
Throughout history, political regimes and movements have demonstrated how manufactured popularity can decay when confronted with cold realities.
asserted
popularity → demonstrate → realities
In the 1950s, former president Juan Perón’s initial popularity in Argentina was sustained by heavy state subsidies and nationalistic appeals.
asserted
popularity → sustain → subsidies
Yet, as economic historian Carlos Díaz-Alejandro documented in his analyses of Argentine economic history, the regime’s inability to sustain fiscal extravagance amidst soaring inflation and foreign exchange depletion eventually caused Perón’s populist economic model to unravel, hastening widespread unrest and military intervention.
asserted
model → document → unrest
While PTI’s online dominance is often taken as proof of overwhelming public support, digital visibility, electoral success and the ability to mobilise people on the streets are three very different measures of political strength
In post-communist Eastern Europe, the rise and fall of political movements that relied on media-driven anti-corruption narratives, such as Simeon Saxe-Coburg-Gotha’s movement in Bulgaria during the early 2000s, illustrate that popularity constructed primarily on outsider status and high moral claims quickly evaporates when administrative ineptitude and economic compromises take hold in daily governance.
uncertain
ineptitude → take → governance
PTI, formed by Imran Khan in 1996, is an intriguing example.
asserted
PTI → form → 1996
It remained a minor player on the margins of Pakistani politics till its transformation into a dominant force in 2011.
asserted
It → remain → 2011
The transformation was not merely an ‘awakening’ but also a carefully constructed political phenomenon.
asserted
transformation → construct → ?
PTI’s popularity was methodically cultivated, mainly by the military establishment.
asserted
popularity → cultivate → establishment
Indeed, the party effectively mobilised a real sense of grievance among urban middle-class voters who were exhausted by the perceived ‘corruption’ of traditional parties such as the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) and the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP).
asserted
who → mobilise → Nawaz
But this was amplified by institutional engineering through a hybrid scheme.
asserted
this → amplify → scheme
According to the Pakistani political scholar Muhammad Waseem, in this scheme, intelligence agencies steered the media narrative, weakened political opponents, and directed influential political “electables” towards PTI.
uncertain
agencies → accord → PTI
The architecture of PTI’s popularity was heavily built on a modern communication strategy.
asserted
architecture → build → strategy
According to the media researcher Ifrah Nadeem, PTI pioneered the use of “computational propaganda.”
uncertain
PTI → accord → propaganda
It unleashed tightly targeted social media campaigns, and emotional messaging.
asserted
It → unleash → campaigns
By leveraging digital spaces, the party bypassed mainstream journalistic scrutiny, portraying Khan as an incorruptible reformer who alone could usher in a ‘Naya [New] Pakistan.’
uncertain
who → leverage → Pakistan
According to economists such as Atif Mian and academic assessments by the International Crisis Group, governing a state such as Pakistan that is under severe balance-of-payments distress required unpopular policy adjustments.
uncertain
that → accord → adjustments
But this contradicted PTI’s idealised campaign claims.
uncertain
this → contradict → claims
So, when Khan was placed in power in 2018, the election of an ‘honest leader’ was framed by the party as a good enough condition for economic revival and institutional purification.
asserted
election → place → revival
But Khan blundered his way across almost all vital areas of governance.
asserted
Khan → blunder → governance
This resulted in the gradual pullback of the military establishment’s patronage of his regime.
asserted
This → result → regime
Therefore, the manufactured framework sustaining the government collapsed, culminating in Khan’s removal via a constitutional vote of no-confidence in 2022.
asserted
framework → manufacture → 2022
The erosion of manufactured popularity reveals a recurring dynamic in politics.
asserted
erosion → manufacture → politics
According to the American political scientist Samuel P. Huntington, while media manipulation, emotional appeals and institutional patronage can create an impression of overwhelming public approval, they cannot transform into tangible administrative competence and economic stability.
uncertain
they → accord → competence
While failing leaders who were elevated through manufactured popularity often switch to narratives of victimisation or conspiracy to retain a dedicated core, the initial perception of popularity begins to alter when tested by on-ground political realities.
asserted
perception → fail → realities
But here’s the interesting bit: even after Khan’s fall, the narrative of his ‘popularity’ did not recede as such.
asserted
narrative → ’ → popularity
Political commentators and international monitoring groups viewed the support for PTI-backed candidates in the 2024 general elections as proof of this.
asserted
commentators → view → this
However, one can posit that this was largely achieved through PTI’s formal and informal social media apparatus transitioning the party’s narrative from that of producing an incorruptible saviour to one of moral victimisation.
asserted
apparatus → posit → victimisation
In the aftermath of Khan’s arrest in 2023, PTI’s media apparatus cleverly converted the general public anger over rising inflation and political instability (which Khan’s regime left behind), into an unquestioning loyalty to the imprisoned Khan.
asserted
regime → convert → Khan
This was further reinforced by digital algorithms that amplified symbolic/performative acts of resistance, creating an impression of impressive public mobilisation.
asserted
that → reinforce → mobilisation
However, the eventual reality check occurred when the limits of this online and sentiment-based popularity were tested on the ground.
asserted
limits → occur → ground
The definitive moment arrived when the current coalition government-imposed emergency measures and governor’s rule in KP recently, sidelining PTI’s provincial government there.
asserted
government → arrive → government
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
