A California billionaire who fled to Las Vegas weeks before the cutoff for the state’s proposed wealth tax is blasting the measure, as more than 100 leading economists, including four Nobel laureates and a former top White House economic adviser, warn it is already driving the rich out of the state.
asserted
it → flee → state
At least seven billionaires, with a combined fortune of nearly $540 billion, about 30% of the state’s billionaire wealth, have already cut ties with California over the proposed tax, according to a Stanford study published last month.
uncertain
billionaires → combine → study
Among them is car loan titan Don Hankey told the California Post he left the state last December, just ahead of the residency deadline for Proposition 40’s proposed billionaire tax.
asserted
he → tell → tax
“I felt I just wasn’t treated well, and they really didn’t want me to stay there with my companies,” said Hankey, whose firm Hankey Group specializes in real estate investments, insurance and auto loans.
asserted
Group → feel → investments
Hankey confirmed his move came before the January deadline, saying he entered escrow in December.
asserted
he → confirm → December
He warned that California has sacrificed years of income tax revenue by driving wealthy residents away.
asserted
California → warn → residents
“It just economically makes no sense to me,” he said.
asserted
he → make → me
Hankey employees around 2,000 people in Southern California, telling Forbes in January his HQ will stay in LA for now.
asserted
HQ → tell → LA
But on Sunday he told The Post: “We own 50% of an office building (400 South 4th street) in Las Vegas.
asserted
We → tell → Vegas
We currently occupy 2 floors and may expand more next year.
uncertain
We → occupy → floors
The economists, in an open letter organized by economist Jon Hartley, urged voters to reject the tax on Tuesday.
asserted
economists → organize → Tuesday
Signatories include Glenn Hubbard, who chaired the White House Council of Economic Advisers under President George W. Bush, and University of Pennsylvania professor Jesús Fernández-Villaverde.
asserted
who → include → Pennsylvania
“There is already evidence that a considerable number have already left California to avoid any possibility of paying a potential Prop 40 wealth tax,” the letter states.
asserted
letter → be → tax
The economists warned there is no way to guarantee the tax would only be imposed once.
asserted
tax → warn → ?
“Such reputational harm could further drive capital and taxpayers out of California,” they wrote.
uncertain
they → drive → California
The letter also flags legal questions over the tax’s retroactive reach, interstate taxation and constitutional limits on taxing intangible property.
asserted
letter → flag → property
It also warns that valuing privately held businesses and other illiquid assets would be a nightmare for taxpayers and the state.
asserted
valuing → warn → taxpayers
Meanwhile, opponents of California’s proposed billionaire tax are preparing a legal challenge if Proposition 40 passes, sources told the California Post.
asserted
sources → propose → Post
Wealth tax supporters, including lead sponsor SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, say the proposal would tap billionaires’ fortunes to support health care and other services.
asserted
proposal → include → care
The state’s legislative analyst projects an ongoing decline in possible income tax revenue as some billionaires leave.
asserted
billionaires → project → revenue
Dave Regan, the SEIU-UHW president who masterminded the measure, has pitched it as a five-year stopgap to backfill federal health care cuts.
asserted
who → mastermind → cuts
He has also hit back at billionaires who say they’re being unfairly targeted, telling ABC7 the tax “makes you a participant in a society that’s made you incredibly wealthy.”
asserted
you → hit → society
The union dismissed the Stanford research, telling CBS News the tax is about making billionaires pay their fair share to keep the state’s health care system from collapsing.
asserted
billionaires → dismiss → system
Stanford researchers Benjamin Jaros and Joshua Rauh estimated the wealth tax would collect just a third of the $100 billion Prop. 40 advocates claimed — between $28 billion and $36 billion — but wipe out billions in annual income tax revenues from wealthy taxpayers who leave California.
asserted
who → estimate → California
Polls show a tight race for Prop. 40, with 46% of likely voters backing the billionaire tax and 43% against, according to one poll released last month.
uncertain
% → show → poll
An Oct. 27 poll shows Prop. 40 support slipping, with Props. 41 and 42 now polling ahead of it.
asserted
. → show → it
Even if Prop. 40 gets majority support in Tuesday’s election, two “poison pill” measures pushed by Google co-founder Sergey Brin, Prop. 41 and Prop. 42, could invalidate key parts of the billionaire tax if they win more votes.
uncertain
they → get → votes
“Wealth taxes don’t make a very good form of tax,” writes Stanford economist Jon Hartley in a California Post op-ed from over 100 economists against the wealth tax.
asserted
Hartley → make → tax
Unlike property taxes, sales taxes, and income taxes, it’s very easy to just change one’s residence to avoid a wealth tax.
asserted
it → ’ → tax
Investment, capital, and firms can move very easily to avoid such a tax and this is well documented.”
asserted
this → move → tax
Rob Lapsley, president of the California Business Roundtable, told The Post his organization has spent months developing a courtroom strategy to combat the wealth tax if it does pass.
asserted
it → tell → tax
“We’re fully prepared to litigate should it become necessary,” Lapsley said.
asserted
Lapsley → prepare → ?
Addressing Brin directly in an interview with NPR, Regan said California was “the state that made you rich, enormously rich.”
asserted
you → address → NPR
Gov. Gavin Newsom, who has opposed the billionaire tax from the start, threw his weight behind Prop. 42 last month.
asserted
who → oppose → .
He said in a statement that “Californians deserve to have their retirement and life savings protected from new state taxes.”
asserted
retirement → say → taxes
Newsom has long warned the levy would backfire.
asserted
levy → warn → ?
In January he told Fox Business that “It’s really damaging to the state,” as reports showed wealthy residents moving money and businesses out.
asserted
residents → tell → money
Xavier Becerra, the front-runner to succeed Newsom, has also come out against Prop. 40.
asserted
Becerra → succeed → .
He has called the tax “sketchy” and argued the state needs a long-term fix for health care funding.
asserted
state → call → funding
Prop. 40’s backers accused the governor of siding with billionaires over patients.
asserted
backers → accuse → patients
…and 16 more, not listed.
The Aporia
